Tina's Reviews > Running with Scissors

Running with Scissors by Augusten Burroughs

by
108010
's review
Jun 17, 07

bookshelves: memoir
Read in June, 2007

I'm more than halfway through this, and I find myself liking it and hating it at the same time. Like, it's really interesting and funny and horrifying, and I want to be reading it, but as I'm reading it I'm mad at it for being such a ripoff of David Sedaris. What, can only gay men with screwed up childhoods write memoirs now? And even though it is funny and interesting, I definitely don't think he's on the same level as Sedaris -- this book isn't nearly as funny or poignant. And like I said, it feels kind of copycat (the way he plays off his gayness is just SO SIMILAR), with the notable difference that Burroughs isn't nearly as likable as Sedaris. While Sedaris jokes but then seems to use his essays as a genuine, loving tribute to the (admittedly messed up) people in life, Burroughs just comes across as selfish and self-centered, at times mocking his family and friends pretty mercilessly (whereas Sedaris is much more likely to mock himself). I'll take self-deprecating over arrogant any day. But still, annoyingly, I am enjoying this book. The chapter with the doctor and the poop (don't want to give too much away) particularly cracked me up.

ETA: After finishing this, my opinion didn't change much. It was an easy read, and I enjoyed it, but I also kind of hated that I enjoyed it. I think the problem is that this book is pure fluff, but Burroughs tries to play it off as something deeper than that. It's not. The only emotion this book really engaged was anger at how stupid and crazy and self-centered all the people in it are. I took nothing away from it. Seriously, go read David Sedaris or Sarah Vowell instead.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Running with Scissors.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Lauren Whitehead I read this a few years ago and although I like Burrough's style and found the story so fascinating that it propelled me through the book, I didn't actually LIKE it.


Danielle I'm currently reading this book, and I feel the same exact way. I'm enjoying it overall, but I just don't think it's very good.


betsy I'm was getting the exact same vibe. While Sedaris tells his stories with a sort of "oh hey here's a funny thing..." dry humor, Burroughs seems to be screaming "OH MY GOD LOOK AT ME!" A lot of the book seems so over the top I question how much of it is even real (I'm not sure what I can say without giving too much away.) That having been said I've enjoyed his other books quite a bit more than this one; they're much better written and much less phony.


message 4: by [deleted user] (new)

"It was an easy read, and I enjoyed it, but I also kind of hated that I enjoyed it." Sums up my thoughts.


back to top