** spoiler alert ** Re-read: November, 2012

First read: 26-30 July, 2011.
4 ½ stars. A few unnecessary repetitions and a couple of over-the-top things kept it from being a 5-star book.
Obviously, someone who's read this far in the series is a fan. For anyone unfamiliar with Dresden, this is not the book to start with. There are lots of fascinating, cool, poignant, and funny things about this book I could go on and on about, but if you've read the book, you already know about them. I've put a spoiler-cloak on this because of the one major plot point I am going to mention, just in case someone who isn't up to speed yet is surfing reviews.
Butcher didn't disappoint me. While the "mostly dead" plot is a bit of a cheap shot, it's crafted well here. I kept turning the pages, eager to see how it would all turn out and sometimes wondering if Butcher really was going to sucker punch us, after all. As I (and, no doubt, tons of other fans) always suspected, Butcher could not let the plotline of Harry becoming Winter Knight go to waste. I figured either Lea or Mab would save Harry, and it turned out to be Mab. The why of Harry's shooting, however, turned out to be much more amazing than the who or the how.
It was great to see so many recurring characters again, interacting in new ways. In particular, Molly, Murphy, and Butters had me both impressed and worried.
Butcher has such a way with the narrative voice. After 13 novels, 1 book of short stories, and a graphic novel, it's almost as if Harry is someone I know, talking to me. He is one of my all-time favourite fictional characters now--flawed, noble, sweet, goofy, damaged, angry, funny, clever, complex. I really enjoyed the backstory in this one, about Harry's childhood and teenage years. All the humour and pop culture references are so much fun for us SFF geeks, too, on top of Butcher's clever use of various aspects of legend and myth.
The Dresdenverse has become a much different place since the events of Changes, and there is a lot of potential for fascinating new plots. I look forward to continuing the journey.
I'm also going to re-read Changes and Ghost Story back-to-back to look closely at how they fit together before the release of the next book.

On the second reading (6-21 November, 2012), I've decided it's a 4 star--not 4 1/2--read, due the excess of ruminations that slow the first half down a bit and a certain problem solution that doesn't make sense. Still enjoyed it overall, though, and I do think Changes and Ghost Story flow together well.