A stimulating book for both believers and skeptics. The first half of the book presents arguments against God; the second, arguments for.

I was most impressed with Keller’s fair presentation. He writes, “Understanding, sympathy, and respect for the other side… happens when each side has learned to represent the other’s argument in its strongest and most positive form.” Keller firmly argues for God, yet he gives others a fair shake. I like that.

Though I didn’t agree with 100% of his points (namely parts of chapter six on God and science), I found the book largely convincing.

Keller approaches argument with “critical rationality”: “There is no argument that will be persuasive to everyone…,” he writes. “Nevertheless, this doesn’t mean that we can’t evaluate beliefs, only that we should not expect conclusive proof, and to demand it is unfair. Not even scientists proceed that way.”

Keller’s primary influences include C.S. Lewis, Jonathan Edwards, and (I noticed) Alvin Plantinga. Still, he is clearly well read in fields of philosophy, classic literature, and science. His broad base increases his credibility in my mind.

This book could easily spur a provocative discussion group. It’s high thought in layman’s voice. Very well done and highly recommended for all.