Tony's Reviews > Tomatoland: How Modern Industrial Agriculture Destroyed Our Most Alluring Fruit

Tomatoland by Barry Estabrook

by
1361000
's review
Jul 25, 11

bookshelves: non-fiction-general
Read in July, 2011

Estabrook, Barry. TOMATOLAND. (2011). ****.
Although often written in a tedious manner, this book provides an expose of the tomato farming practices in Florida that most of us don’t know about. We know that Florida tomatoes have no taste. They are grown for taste, but for size, weight, and uniformity. The problem is that Florida soil is mostly sand, not sandy soil, but sand like you find at the beach. It contains no nutrients. They have to be added. Add to this drawback the fact that sand and the weather is inducive to a variety of pests and diseases that have to be controlled by chemicals. This means that Florida tomatoes are invariable sprayed with everything in the ag-chemist’s arsenal to allow a harvestable crop. Florida tomato growers use about eight times the amount of chemical sprays as growers in California with equal sized plots. Although California tomatoes are primarily used as the basis for the sauce processors, they are usually full of flavor. Florida tomatoes are picked as ripe greens, and then conveyed to storehouses where they are subjected to treatment with ethylene – a process that turns them red. What stands out about this book, however, is not the abuse of chemicals that ultimately pollute the state and workers, but the atrocious conditions under which the pickers have to work. Many cases of outright slavery have been brought to light, along with innumerable cases of flagrant violations of safety regulations which have led to long-term illnesses among the pickers, including birth defects. There is some hope that the industry will change somewhat, but only in response to consumer pressures. Until that happens, nothing will happen. Recommended.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Tomatoland.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-5 of 5) (5 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Pondering Pig Newton I've read reviews of this and it looks interesting, sorry to hear it's written a bit tediously. Think I'll still have a go though.
Have you read Michael Pollan's The Omnivore's Dilemma? Not that is a top book on the subject and the one that got me interested in paying much more attention to what we eat.


Tony I'm a retired chemist, having worked in the food industry for over forty years. I try and keep up with advances (?) in the food industry just for old times sake. My last position was with Calgene in CA, later purchased by Monsanto. I'm surprised that the author of "Tomatoland" didn't mention their Flavr-Savr tomato - a genetically engineered variety that specifically addressed the issue of taste. I haven't read "The Omnivore's Dilemma," but it's somewhere on my list.


Pondering Pig Newton Another question, if I might: You are one of the most "omniverous" readers I have yet come across. Where do you find so many interesting books? Have you collected for years or do you live near a very good library?
PS: I will be looking forward to your take on Pollan's book.


Tony I'm a collector by default. Now I have a library of about 5,000 books and no more room to add any more. We do have a good library system with an excellent interlibrary loan program. I also manage to visit the used paperback book shops in the area. When I'm done with those, I take them back for trade credit. I always have a pile of books around as back up. I can't forget the gems you can find at library sales, too. In addition, we have several active. Chapters of the AAUW in the are a. They sponsor used book sales to raise money. Happy hunting.


Pondering Pig Newton Good work! Thanks for the follow-up.


back to top