Nafiza's Reviews > Cinder
Cinder (Lunar Chronicles, #1)
by Marissa Meyer (Goodreads Author)
There’s a certain eternalness about fairytales. As humanity evolves, so do they, finding forms through which to answer the need people have to believe in happily ever afters, in victory, pyrrhic though it may be. Cinder reimagines the story of Cinderella in a way that does not just situate it firmly in the 21st century but also being careful to retain that flavor of myth, of the possibility that makes fairytales immortal. In this tale, Meyer very bravely recreates Cinderella as more (or perhaps less, it depends on who you talk to) than human. Her very identity is shrouded in mystery but the foundation of Cinderella remains firmly in place.
The best part of the story for me was finding the fairy tale elements. The orange pumpkin coach, the fairy godmother, the glass slipper – these are all important to the original fairytale but Meyer does not just use them in a superficial sense, as in, to maintain that familiarity with the original tale. These fixtures of the tale gain their own separate meaning in Cinder, have their own purpose. I love how seamlessly they are woven into the fabric of the story.
The fact that Cinder is a cyborg opens up a delicious discussion on what it means to be human. Is humanity quantified by the amount of flesh in one’s body? What is humanity? Is it extrinsic or intrinsic? With the way science is moving, I have a feeling that these will be very pertinent questions in the future.
Prince Charming is also given a makeover and comes complete with a personality and motivations that make him more human than the stereotyped prince charming of the original tales. His conflicts are easy to relate to and his frustrations at his helplessness evoke empathy. I also really liked the world building. Meyer has created an exquisitely detailed world for her characters and so impressive is her word-smithery that it is difficult to believe that this is her debut novel.
When Meyer moves away from the Cinderella story to complicate the plot and increase the stakes, she does so with a finesse and confidence that is translated in the smoothness of the prose. The pacing of the novel is just right and I liked where she ended. There is no cliff hanger but there is definitely a sense of urgency which will keep readers waiting the long months till the next installment in the trilogy. I definitely recommend this debut novel to anyone who likes fairytales, gutsy heroines and romance that makes your breath hitch and your toes curl.
by Marissa Meyer (Goodreads Author)
Nafiza's review
bookshelves: fairytale-retellings, 2011, net-galley, debut-authors-12, books-i-own, books-for-review
Jan 15, 12
bookshelves: fairytale-retellings, 2011, net-galley, debut-authors-12, books-i-own, books-for-review
Read from November 04 to 08, 2011
There’s a certain eternalness about fairytales. As humanity evolves, so do they, finding forms through which to answer the need people have to believe in happily ever afters, in victory, pyrrhic though it may be. Cinder reimagines the story of Cinderella in a way that does not just situate it firmly in the 21st century but also being careful to retain that flavor of myth, of the possibility that makes fairytales immortal. In this tale, Meyer very bravely recreates Cinderella as more (or perhaps less, it depends on who you talk to) than human. Her very identity is shrouded in mystery but the foundation of Cinderella remains firmly in place.
The best part of the story for me was finding the fairy tale elements. The orange pumpkin coach, the fairy godmother, the glass slipper – these are all important to the original fairytale but Meyer does not just use them in a superficial sense, as in, to maintain that familiarity with the original tale. These fixtures of the tale gain their own separate meaning in Cinder, have their own purpose. I love how seamlessly they are woven into the fabric of the story.
The fact that Cinder is a cyborg opens up a delicious discussion on what it means to be human. Is humanity quantified by the amount of flesh in one’s body? What is humanity? Is it extrinsic or intrinsic? With the way science is moving, I have a feeling that these will be very pertinent questions in the future.
Prince Charming is also given a makeover and comes complete with a personality and motivations that make him more human than the stereotyped prince charming of the original tales. His conflicts are easy to relate to and his frustrations at his helplessness evoke empathy. I also really liked the world building. Meyer has created an exquisitely detailed world for her characters and so impressive is her word-smithery that it is difficult to believe that this is her debut novel.
When Meyer moves away from the Cinderella story to complicate the plot and increase the stakes, she does so with a finesse and confidence that is translated in the smoothness of the prose. The pacing of the novel is just right and I liked where she ended. There is no cliff hanger but there is definitely a sense of urgency which will keep readers waiting the long months till the next installment in the trilogy. I definitely recommend this debut novel to anyone who likes fairytales, gutsy heroines and romance that makes your breath hitch and your toes curl.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Cinder.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 11/08/2011 |
|
50.0% | "This is fantastic so far. I seriously love the way the fairytale has been worked into the story. It's smart. And the whole other story is fantastic." |
Comments (showing 1-25 of 25) (25 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jess
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Nov 05, 2011 02:20am
oh man, so jealous!! I got denied for this, and I'm CRUSHED :C
reply
|
flag
*
oh man!!! I'm SO FREAKING JEALOUS!!! I wanna read!!Tell me how it is :D:D I'll live vicariously through you hahaha
I love the way she interspersed the fairy tale into the primary narrative and then built upon it. I think you'll like it too.
Okay, there are more holds for this book at my library than there are for The Fault in Our Stars. I've heard some shadier things about this from other people, but 5 stars from you, Nafiza? ... I guess I'l have to check it out. :P
We have very different reading tastes, Eden, so I'm not sure you will enjoy this book as much as I did. I have studied fairy tales in some detail (I designed a seminar class that studied fairy tale retellings, fun times I tell you)and this is one of the much better ones.
Lol, I didn't care for the fact that it was so similar to Sailor Moon. The world building needed improving in my opinion.
Oh I haven't read Sailor Moon so I couldn't make the comparisons. But I was definitely entertained by the fact that for once the setting was not in America. And I though she did a pretty decent job incorporating the fairy tale into the story. What can I say? I'm a sucker for fairy tale retellings.
Haha, you watched the show didn't you? I guess if you watch it, the similarities will become pretty apparent.
Oh, man. You gotta. I totally LOVED that thing when I was a kid. I think lots of kids did. I would get up super early just to watch it when it came on at 6:00 in the morning every day. LoL. Darien x Serena~!
Haha. We had one channel and that too went up in 97. All the cartoons were Australian or New Zealand or else long periods of documentaries starring outback heroes. -_-
Make sure you watch the subbed version, and not the dubbed version. The dub version has lots of shifty translations (such as making gay characters straight, and such).



