Pat's Reviews > A Dance With Dragons

A Dance With Dragons by George R.R. Martin

by
5520441
's review
Jul 20, 11

Read in July, 2011

George R. R. Martin is an asshole. And you know what? I knew after finishing the first book (Game of Thrones) in the Song of Fire and Ice series. I remember being 14 years old and, (grievous spoiler, in case you’ve neither read the first book nor seen the HBO series) when that fateful moment came where our righteous and heroic Lord Stark was killed, walking up to my mom aghast saying “He KILLED the hero. You can’t kill the hero.” He was true to the series most quoted saying, then: Winter is coming.

He is just as true to the saying with the latest offering. A Dance With Dragons picks up where the last one ended off, and once again R. R. Martin remains the only major fantasy writer that has produced sequels where the quality of the writing and the storytelling does not degraded with each new entry. The novel is a turn-pager. I got through the plus-1000 page hardcover book in less than 5 days, and that is despite the fact that I had other things to do. I could not help myself. The book just kept pushing me back.

I won’t spoil any moments in the story, and to be honest, that is the draw of this series. Once again, R. R. Martin paints us a world at once fantastical, where some people can change their faces and others possess animals, and starkly real; characters are just as likely to die of sickness brought on by overpopulation and old age than they are in some glorious fight or by the hand (paw) of some monster or another. Once again we are brought into what serves just as much of a deconstruction of the fantasy epic as an epic itself, and once again the end result is one of the best things the genre has ever produced.

Now lets hope he has an easier time writing the next installment and that it does not take five or seven years to write. But even if it does, I’m sure the end result will not disappoint.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Dance With Dragons.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-3 of 3) (3 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Kate (new) - added it

Kate had to laugh, my husband turned me on to the series after I complained that all fantasy was the same....(I think I compared them to Popeye cartoons, Bluto shows up, Bluto takes Olive Oyl, but you know Popeye is always going to win!) He said read Game of Thrones.....I did, and got totally ticked off at HIM when Ned Stark is killed......You don't kill the hero! hehehe, I love this series, and hopefully Dance With Dragons doesn't disappoint!


Bryson Valentine Same thing happened to me when I first read thrones. It was quickly becoming the best book I've ever read and then stark was beheaded. I've never had such a visceral reaction to a character's death before. At first I was pissed at Martin, but then I realized how good the book was if it gave me that reaction. Then I was just pissed at the Lannisters!


Tara Richardson My complaint about killing Ned was that I thought he was dead after the throne room stabbing. Several chapters go by and all of a sudden Ned is alive! It was the first ressurection of the series for me... Then he's beheaded 2 chapters later.

Martin is definitely unpredictable in his plotline twists. Maybe he'll surprise us all with someone actually winning in the end!


back to top