Summer's Reviews > The Master Butchers Singing Club

The Master Butchers Singing Club by Louise Erdrich

by
998334
's review
Mar 24, 08

Recommended for: people i purposely enjoyed frustrating

VERY mixed feelings about this book. The author has some beautifully worded sentences and an overall engaging story (in the sense that it would have made a good screenplay) however, what the author states in the included interview as to her intention for writing the book (1--to show the affects of war and 2--to show the difficulties of immigrants to build a life in a country devoid of familial support or the familiarity of cultural fortification)was at best, used as a backdrop for a story about the friendship of two women. Even the title is misleading as the importance of the club is not even effectively woven throughout the story, but disappears and then pops up at odd intervals. The same could be said of the character from whose perspective the story is initially told; he seems to be only a vehicle for introducing us to the two women upon whom the majority of the novel is focused.

I finished the book thinking that the author's intentions were very poorly implemented and that I felt shorted by the fact the novel left me with no entertaining questions or themes other than wondering why it deserved to be published.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Master Butchers Singing Club.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-1 of 1) (1 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Gentlyferal (last edited Dec 23, 2008 12:10pm) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gentlyferal @ Summer: Well, you could say the same about Erdrich's other titles: Love Medicine was only tangentially about love magic for a couple of the minor characters; The Bingo Palace had only one or two scenes set in a gambling establishment; The Last Report on the Miracles at Little No Horse was only tangentially about background research on a candidate for sainthood. But beautiful, sweeping, human stories, all.

Another thing: I felt that all the other relationships in the book -- and most of them were members of the Master Butchers Singing Club -- got pretty much equal play and satisfying treatment.


back to top