HOLY CRAP. What the heck. I knew who the killer was from the very beginning (ive read privileged and last christmas already) AND UGH!!!!!!!!! ive never wanted to strangle a fictional character anymore in my life. I went from loving Ariana in the Spin off series to wanting to strangle her. Wow wow wow, so much happened here. Literally my heart beated so fast during some parts. Note to some , even though the identity of the killer will be spoiled i strongly suggest you read last christmas before starrting the private series. And no matter how mean and rude noelle is sometimes, i love her. I was torn apart when i realized she was going to be gone. I didnt care a Kiran or Natasha. And ugh! Reed frustrated me sosososo much. And they left me hanging with taylor . Alright alright i know what yall are thinking, this review makes no sense. Read the book and your thoughts will be just like mine. I LOVED IT