April's Reviews > Love in the Time of Cholera

Love in the Time of Cholera by Gabriel Garcí­a Márquez

by
600502
's review
May 09, 09

bookshelves: book-club, 2008, 1001-books-list
Recommended for: people who enjoy torturing themselves, perverts, sex offenders, and jerks

** spoiler alert ** I don't like this book.

I don't like the characters. (This was going to be a list, but then I realized that this is the only reason I have.)

Florentino Ariza is a baby. Seriously, his mom gives him whatever he wants, and she tries to make everything all right for him, and he is very, very ... if he lived today, he would be one of those emo kids with the dyed black hair and the eye liner and the journals full of bad poetry (he does write bad poetry, in the book), all "Nobody gets me," and just a grating, time-sucking, high maintenance type. He rationalizes his behavior in whatever way he can, so he never feels that he is doing anything wrong.

I grew impatient with him fairly quickly; I wanted to wring him by his neck and yell, "GET OVER IT!!!" I have no tolerance for that kind of behavior.
Sometime during the Seduction of the 600, it says that Florentino Ariza thought that when a woman said no, she really meant something else (that's a paraphrase). This is another thing I have no tolerance for. So, when he persisted in his attentions to Fermina Daza, even after she'd made her own feelings quite clear (TWICE), and she came around to his way of thinking, it justified his behavior. I don't think he should be rewarded for that. I think he should be kicked to the curb.

Fermina Daza was almost likable; I was almost there with her, but then I realized that there wasn't anything really likable about her. She was efficient and organized, she was well-behaved, and she was boring. Why did men love her? What did she have to offer? I DON'T KNOW.

I did like Juvenal Urbino. Of course he dies in the first chapter.

It seemed to me that the book dragged on FOREVER; I kept looking ahead to the end of a chapter and sighing, "Forty-two more pages." (The chapters are long.) Even though two weeks doesn't seem like a long time, it's a long time for ME to be reading a book, particularly one that isn't a thousand pages long and written in Elizabethan English.

I didn't think this was any kind of love story. Like Wuthering Heights, it's more a love-gone-wrong story, or an obsession story; none of the characters really displayed any of the traits that I would associate with love, one which--the chief one, I would say--is selflessness. None of them were willing to put anyone else above themselves, and maybe that's why I didn't particularly care for them, or for this book.

I've written a more in-depth review here.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Love in the Time of Cholera.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-21 of 21) (21 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Tresa I totally agree....it is a time-sucking boring book.....


Rachel I agree also. I thought I would never get through it. I have to care about the characters in some way (positive or negative) but I did not care what happened to them.


Kristal Right?!? Seriously! And is no one else disturbed...terribly disturbed by the continuous child abuse (of America, his mysterious relative)?


Bronwyn Why this book won the Pulitzer is a mystery to me. I agree with this (hilarious) review and I'm nearly 100 pages from the end of this book. Determined to trudge through it...


Andrea I actually liked the book, but I just think April's review is hilarious. Thanks!


Candice your recommendations for this novel are so funny!!! and true...


Matt Wow, completely forgetting he was very successful in a boat business, so where can you get the idea that he's emo? Don't emo's only make it as far as the corner of their bedrooms? Recommended for "people who enjoy torturing themselves, perverts, sex offenders, and jerks," blasphemy in the name of Gabriel Garcia Marquez.


message 8: by Zuzu (last edited Jul 12, 2009 06:09pm) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Zuzu I read your review after I wrote mine, because frankly, I thought that there might be people who would be doing the virtual version of"egging me" and I was relieved to see people score the same or less than I did. I found it so cool that you also saw the whole Cathy and Heathcliff thing, which I touched on in my very short review. The most annoying couples in history of literature.


message 9: by Berna (new)

Berna Bronwyn wrote: "Why this book won the Pulitzer is a mystery to me. I agree with this (hilarious) review and I'm nearly 100 pages from the end of this book. Determined to trudge through it..."

This book never won a Pulitzer prize. However the author won the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1982.


Simone Ramone Agony. Pity cholera skipped the main characters.


Alenna I hate being a book-quiter, but this book may push me to the dark side. I actually read this "spoiler alert" review in the hopes of finding either a strong reason to continue plodding on, or a good reason to quit. I think I might have my reason to quit - I completely agree with you on the characters and I still have about 150 pages left. I wish there was something redeemable about this story, but I even hate the way this author writes and the pointless, sometimes disgusting facts that he uses to make this plot even more rambling than it is. Ugh...


Blakelyn I could have copied and pasted your review as my own. Agree with every word of what you wrote 100%


message 13: by Dj (new)

Dj Good lord, I have never read such shallow, insipid crud as these reviews. If you don't like the south american tradition of mystical fiction, you won't get this book. I recommend you stick with Dan Brown or romance novels...


Melanie I agree with everything ! I hated it but for all it's flaws Wurthering Heights is a million times better than this BOOK It disgraces the word BOOK seriously ! I hated so much I felt I wasted my time and he caused the death of a woman too and he didn't care ! He's such a perv ! I felt sick literally reading it ! I can't understand how anyone can LIkE this !! Unless they were blinded by the hype surrounding it ! How can any normal human being find this book appealing at ALL is a mystery to me !


message 15: by David (new) - rated it 1 star

David Ivory Terrible book - this review is spot on. Even worse for me was the child molestation by the 'hero' - and (SPOILER ALERT) the girl kills herself when he eventually spurns her when she gets too old - WTF? I almost suspect this book was written as a piss-take to see how such drivel would be received by the LyFy crowd.


Shona Macdonald liked your review... :) agreed with most of it, apart from the kicking him to the kerb part, a bit harsh...i just felt a bit sorry for him having wasted his life...


message 17: by Ray (new) - rated it 1 star

Ray Totally agree!


Amanda Mcintosh Perfectly stated. This book was a huge disappointment and a huge waste of time.


Aliyah Yeah, this book put me to sleep, plus Florentino acting all rapey freaked me out. Fermina was a prude and reminded me of Rosaline in Romeo & Juliet.


message 20: by ST (new) - rated it 5 stars

ST A beautifully written book written by an author that understands life as it really is and is a complete master of language.


Maggie It's scary how much I agree with this review. This book was horrid.


back to top