Jacqueline's Reviews > The Goose Girl
The Goose Girl (The Books of Bayern, #1)
by Shannon Hale (Goodreads Author)
by Shannon Hale (Goodreads Author)
Jacqueline's review
bookshelves: fantasy, fairy-tale-retellings, books-i-own, blog-reviews, required-reading, signed, all-time-favourites
Mar 29, 09
bookshelves: fantasy, fairy-tale-retellings, books-i-own, blog-reviews, required-reading, signed, all-time-favourites
Recommended to Jacqueline by:
LRRHers, who pushed me to read this a LOT
Recommended for:
Everyone who likes a satisfying, absolutely beautiful fairytale retelling
Read in February, 2009
Imagine that you are a princess–you live in a luxurious palace that is filled with hundreds of servants, you can go on exciting rides on your very own horse, who is also your closest friend, any time you want. But think again: what if, even with all the riches surrounding you, you were lonely and constantly self-conscious of your actions? And, just what would you do if your own mother commanded you to marry a prince from a faraway land, a prince you’ve never even met? Or perhaps worse: what would happen if an acquaintance you trusted turned her back on you and forced you to face the troubles of lower class, the threat of death, and the possible outbreak of war?
Summary: Yikes. Talk about harsh. Well, that’s exactly what Ani, short for Anidori-Kiladra Talianna Isilee, goes through: unable to live up to her mother’s expectations of a proper Crown Princess, Ani is sent away from her home country of Kildenree to the country of Bayern, where she is to be wedded to the prince. However, her own lady-in-waiting, Selia, leads a mutiny, forcing Ani to run away from her escorts and try to stay in Bayern–but as a humble goose girl. Although her new path is tough, Ani learns valuable lessons and gains many things; for example, she learns the gift of friendship, story-telling, and communication with animals and the wind. However, when Ani discovers that Selia plots to start war with Kildenree and Bayern in order to hide her deceit, Ani knows it is about time that she takes back her rightful title and throne. But with even all her new talents, gifts, and loyal friends, will Ani succeed in bringing justice and fairness to all?
Thoughts: I really, really, really liked this book. I can’t say I absolutely loved it (that’s what I would say about my #1 favorite book), but it is definitely one of my favorites. Shannon Hale’s writing style shines more in this book than in any of her other works, and the simple Brothers Grimm tale was beautifully retold. Would I recommend it to someone seeking a good read? Absolutely. It is like no YA novel I have read before.
Pros: As I said before, the writing is stunning, and the lyrical style perfectly fit in with the nature-speaking concept; the character development is extremely realistic one oft forgets that this is fantasy and not historical fiction; in addition, I thoroughly enjoyed the humor inserted here and there (a few times I would recall a hiliarious scene while at school or somewhere else, and would have to really fight to stifle my giggles. In that case, I can’t even imagine how funny and comical Austenland is. ).
Cons: Even though I love the writing, sometimes I wished there was a tad bit more dialogue in some parts
Recommended for: Girls fourteen and older
Grading:
Plot: 10/10
Characters: 10/10
Writing: 10/10
Overall: 10/10 (like I said before, a favorite, but not my number one favorite)
Also Recommended:
- Book of a Thousand Days by Shannon Hale
- Princess Academy by Shannon Hale
- Harry Potter by J.K. Rowling
For more reviews like this one, please visit my review blog, Butterfly Forest.
Summary: Yikes. Talk about harsh. Well, that’s exactly what Ani, short for Anidori-Kiladra Talianna Isilee, goes through: unable to live up to her mother’s expectations of a proper Crown Princess, Ani is sent away from her home country of Kildenree to the country of Bayern, where she is to be wedded to the prince. However, her own lady-in-waiting, Selia, leads a mutiny, forcing Ani to run away from her escorts and try to stay in Bayern–but as a humble goose girl. Although her new path is tough, Ani learns valuable lessons and gains many things; for example, she learns the gift of friendship, story-telling, and communication with animals and the wind. However, when Ani discovers that Selia plots to start war with Kildenree and Bayern in order to hide her deceit, Ani knows it is about time that she takes back her rightful title and throne. But with even all her new talents, gifts, and loyal friends, will Ani succeed in bringing justice and fairness to all?
Thoughts: I really, really, really liked this book. I can’t say I absolutely loved it (that’s what I would say about my #1 favorite book), but it is definitely one of my favorites. Shannon Hale’s writing style shines more in this book than in any of her other works, and the simple Brothers Grimm tale was beautifully retold. Would I recommend it to someone seeking a good read? Absolutely. It is like no YA novel I have read before.
Pros: As I said before, the writing is stunning, and the lyrical style perfectly fit in with the nature-speaking concept; the character development is extremely realistic one oft forgets that this is fantasy and not historical fiction; in addition, I thoroughly enjoyed the humor inserted here and there (a few times I would recall a hiliarious scene while at school or somewhere else, and would have to really fight to stifle my giggles. In that case, I can’t even imagine how funny and comical Austenland is. ).
Cons: Even though I love the writing, sometimes I wished there was a tad bit more dialogue in some parts
Recommended for: Girls fourteen and older
Grading:
Plot: 10/10
Characters: 10/10
Writing: 10/10
Overall: 10/10 (like I said before, a favorite, but not my number one favorite)
Also Recommended:
- Book of a Thousand Days by Shannon Hale
- Princess Academy by Shannon Hale
- Harry Potter by J.K. Rowling
For more reviews like this one, please visit my review blog, Butterfly Forest.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Goose Girl.
sign in »
Quotes Jacqueline Liked
“Its important to know stories. I felt the earth shift to make a place for you when you were born, and I came to tell you stories while you are young. And like me, you were born with a word on your tongue.”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
“We know it's all just daydreaming. In all likelihood, no one in this forest'll ever get a javelin, and I'll never see my mother's kingdom again, let alone be hailed by crowds as the jewel of Kildenree. Maybe it's vain to wish for it. But sometimes, it'd be nice just to hold something real in your hands that felt like a measure of your worth. Right Finn?”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
“But in a country where you hang your dead up on walls and pride whether or not a man bears a javelin more than his character, how am I to persuade you out of a war? It would be suicide for Kildenree to war on Bayern and butchery for Bayern to attack Kildenree. If you don't believe me, then send me back. Or if you don't trust me to leave, I'll return to my little room on the west wall and tend your geese, and you can be sure that on my watch no thieves will touch my flock.”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
“My friends call me by my name."
"You don't have any friends."
"I don't want you to be my friend, Selia, or my servant, not now. I thought you were both. You have let me know I was wrong. So are you to treat me so. You are wrong.”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
"You don't have any friends."
"I don't want you to be my friend, Selia, or my servant, not now. I thought you were both. You have let me know I was wrong. So are you to treat me so. You are wrong.”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
“She was born Anidori-Kiladra Talianna Isilee, Crown Princess of Kildenree, and she did not open her eyes for three days.”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
“Right now I'd like all my troubles to stand in front of me in a straight line, and one by one I'd give each a black eye. ”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
“You, what are you? The brat of lucky parents who were related to a childless king. There is no such thing as royal blood. I believe we are what we make ourselves, and as such, you, Crown Princess, are nothing.”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
“When you get tired of worrying and mourning your horse and trying not to be afraid, tell me and I'll do it for you a while so you can shut your eyes and sleep peaceful.”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
“If we're mad, we're mad in large numbers, at least larger than yours.”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
“... If we don't tell strange stories, when something strange happens we won't believe it.”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
“They finished laughing and caught their breaths, and looked at each other, and Ani thought Geric looked at her too long, as though he forgot he was looking, as though he did not wish to do anything else. She looked back. Her took heart took its time quieting down.”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
“Yes, we'll yell, 'Help, help us, goose girl, and bring the terrifying legion of warrior geese'.”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
“I, Geric-Sinath of Gerhard, declare that you're beautiful and you're perfect and I'll slay any man who tries to take you from my side. Goose girl, may I kiss you?”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
“Isi, I’m trying to say that you’ve been… no, you’re so, you’re–” He stopped.
"You are,” he said. His hand found hers, and he held her finger tightly, as though he did not dare to do any more than hold her one hand, and look at her, and breathe deeply.”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
"You are,” he said. His hand found hers, and he held her finger tightly, as though he did not dare to do any more than hold her one hand, and look at her, and breathe deeply.”
― Shannon Hale, The Goose Girl
Reading Progress
| 10/01/2008 | page 36 |
|
9.0% | "*happy sigh* Back on track w/ this! I love it so much, but I wish I had more time to sit down and read it straight through!" |
| 11/02/2008 | page 60 |
|
15.0% | "Hehe, me love." |
Comments (showing 1-13 of 13) (13 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Erin
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jun 13, 2008 08:21pm
Is this a reread? Or your first time?
reply
|
flag
*
First time; yeah, hehe, that's my deepest darkest secret. :P But recently I've been kinda busy in reading stuff (I've been catching up w/ finals and studying--things like that), so I haven't gotten too far yet. Actually, I've been wanting to set summer time where I can read it straight w/o any "school distractions" if that makes sense. :)
That is so sad, but you're in for a treat!It's odd but whenever i'm super stressed or busy I start reading. A lot. :P
Hopefully I can really start reading it...Monday. Or Tuesday. And write a good review on it.Ah, I do that a lot too--reading or listening to music always helps for stress.
Honestly, you're not a true Shannon Hale fan until you've read The Goose Girl. It's really very simple. :)
I suppose. Like you're not a real Jane Austen fan until you've read Pride and Prejudice.Anyhow, I think I still like B1000 more. TGG was good, and the writing was amazing, but I guess it's because I can relate with Dashti more than Ani/Isi. :D
Well, I was talking about AVERAGE fourteen-year-olds. You, on the other hand, are very mature, so even though you're not fourteen, it still includes people like you. Maybe I should add in "psychologically fourteen or older". :D
I think thirteen is reasonable... Personally I go by maturity level. I just bought this at Christmas time for my cousin who is twelve because in my opinion she is just now able to really appreciate the beauty of the romance and such. That's just my opinion though. I read it when I was twelve... :)
Great point, Danielle! I think the thing is, everybody will see the age thing differently; some will see it as your physical age, other as your psychological age. It's actually meant to report to prospective readers of any "red flags", so maybe I should change it to that, like how I do with my album reviews. :D


