Angela's Reviews > Babylonne

Babylonne by Catherine Jinks
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Jun 29, 2011

liked it
bookshelves: medieval, historical-fiction
Read from December 02 to 08, 2009

Like the WNBA or Supergirl, the female character spin-off franchise just isn't as good.

The siege of La Becede has nothing on, well, Jerusalem. Or even Carcassone. On the plus side, the "dress up like a boy and run away from an arranged marriage" cliche, though played straight, is surprisingly appealing just from Babylonne's grit, resilience, and surprising lack of wallowing self-pity. Plus, the tongue-in-cheek portrayal of daily communal life (and survival) in the Cathar diaspora is strangely vibrant and riveting.

Man, what happened to Isidore? He kind of dropped the epileptic fits/guilt therefrom, the awkwardness around women, the super hard-line Catholic idealism, the worrying, the misanthropy.... pretty much any distinguishing character feature. He's a blander, happier version of Roland without the Templar badassery and dysfunctional family issues.

Honestly, a one-sided two-person relationship does not a good novel make. At certain points, even though it would've been a terrible idea and completely non-canonical, I couldn't help but think, "have sex already!" or, "Stab the bishop in the neck!"

It would've made the book actually interesting.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Babylonne.
Sign In »

No comments have been added yet.