It's always tough to read the next work by an author whose previous work you considered an amazing masterpiece.
That is where I am with Wonderstruck. It is amazing. It combines two stories with artwork and prose. It combines a motley assortment of knowledge - deafness, the beginning of museums, lightning strikes, family secrets, stars, meteors, and even David Bowie. It's wild and fabulous, and I should be giving it five stars on any objective scale.
However, I couldn't help comparing it to "Hugo Cabret," Selznick's previous work that just blew my socks off - and this one isn't as good . . . but then what is?
I think my greatest struggle with this book is the amount of telling that goes on at the end, rather than the showing that you get throughout the first three-quarters of the novel. It had to be wrapped up, and, yes, having someone just explain all the connections does that - but it makes you miss those moments of actual discovery from earlier in the book.
Soooo - it's a five-star book, that I can only give 4 (4 1/2 if goodreads allowed) due to my own subjectiveness.
Still - pick it up. It's awesome!