Marte Patel's Reviews > Three Cups of Deceit: How Greg Mortenson, Humanitarian Hero, Lost His Way

Three Cups of Deceit by Jon Krakauer

by
24126
's review
Jun 18, 11

bookshelves: kindle, non-fiction
Read in June, 2011

I saw Greg Mortenson speak in Miami in July last year and was captivated by his story. Each delegate at the conference were given a copy of Three Cups of Tea (the young adult version) and a hardback copy of Stones into Schools. I thought this was very generous of the publisher, but according to this exposé, Mortenson usually buys the books for such events using his charity's funds, so that (a) he can receive royalties (not his charity, mind!), which he wouldn't if the publisher donated the books or if they were bought at wholesale prices and (b) the books can stay in the bestseller lists. This is appalling and I would like to find out how the books I received were procured. I am going to write to the conference organisers and I'll update this review if I get a response.

This title is an excellent piece of investigative journalism and is divided into three sections: one section exposes a number of myths/lies in Mortenson's books, one section deals with the financial fraud and malpractice of his charity, and one section deals with the failures resulting from him trying to run everything as a one-man show. It's distressing reading and has made me feel angry and upset about being taken in so easily by Mortenson last July. Like Krakauer, I hope the charity itself can continue, but with proper management and accounting practises. I also hope something will be done about the financial fraud that has been going on for years.

Unlike Mortenson, who receives all the royalties from his books, whilst his charity funds his personal travel and buys the books being given away at events, 100% of Jon Krakauer's proceeds from the sale of Three Cups of Deceit will be donated to the "Stop Girl Trafficking" project at the American Himalayan Foundation.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Three Cups of Deceit.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Uma (new)

Uma C I gather I really need to read this one, as I really enjoyed Three Cups of Tea... It's unfortunate that this is how his story has unfolded.


Marte Patel Yes, unfortunately I think you need to read this, too. I took the time to read Greg's side of the story as well, but it's very woolly and vague, and reads very much like someone who doesn't want to give straight answers. Some of the questions he has been asked requires factual answers (dates, amounts) and he is so evasive.

I don't even mind so much that Greg 'compressed' events into shorter time-spans etc. - but Krakauer list an uncomfortably long line of straight lies. For example Greg made up that he got to attend Mother Theresa's wake alone, but she died three years before he said he was there. The financial situation also looks really dodgy and this might put people off donating to charity. It all makes me very angry.


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

Mae, thanks for the review. I've just known of the scandal today and, as one of the people who bought Mortenson's book, I feel so upset and angry! And I was naive enough as to think money got from the book would help the org, not only Mortenson's bank account! Could you please tell me how to purchase Krakauer's book? I clicked on the link in your review but it just appears a "Not Found" message. Thanks


Marte Patel I bought Krakauer's book from Amazon's Kindle Store, but you can read about the various ways of getting it here: http://byliner.com/originals/three-cu....

Not sure why my link isn't working, but it wasn't meant to be a link to purchasing the book anyway, but rather to the charity project that Krakauer's royalty earnings are going to.


back to top