stephanie's Reviews > The Kommandant's Girl

The Kommandant's Girl by Pam Jenoff
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
May 11, 2008

it was ok
bookshelves: 2008, historical-fiction, holocaust, prize-winners
Read in May, 2008

huh. i can't decide how i really liked this. there's so much controversy, sometimes, over setting a story during the holocaust . . . this was a different take on things.

emma marries jacob, a young political dissident, and less than a year later, the nazis invade poland and jacob is on the run as part of the krakow resistance. emma is forced to "pass" as a gentile in order to survive - to the point where she works for the highest ranking officer in the region, and becomes "anna".

i found the scenes where she had to go to church more interesting than most. i liked the secondary characters a lot - especially krysie and alek and marta. the scene with emma's father broke my heart.

i could have done without the whole kommandant relationship thing - i didn't think it was necessary, and thought it made the story even more over-wrought than needed. but it brought interesting consequences.

i don't really get why this was labeled adult fiction, while The Book Thief is YA. i actually found this book more simplistic, easy to understand, and in a way, pandering to the reader.

interesting, but not a must-read, and kind of a disappointment. i think the real problem was that the author tried to deal with too many emotions and plot points in not enough space.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Kommandant's Girl.
Sign In »

No comments have been added yet.