karen's Reviews > Daughter of Smoke & Bone
Daughter of Smoke & Bone (Daughter of Smoke & Bone, #1)
by Laini Taylor (Goodreads Author)
this book is astonishingly good.
this is the book i should have been handed when i first expressed an interest in exploring the world of the fantasy novel. never mind that isn't not going to be published for three more months (thank you to the girl with BEA access for getting this for me), it should have happened somehow.
this is the most pure example of fantasy that i have seen so far.
and it is nearly perfect.
once upon a time, an angel and a devil fell in love. it did not end well.
a fantastic opening to a book. and it really takes off from there, revealing its secrets slowly, and deliciously and only occasionally predictably.
i appreciate a sad love story, and this one really delivers. this is a fairy-tale fantasy that has its roots in the traditional fairy tale rather than the sweet disneyland versions where everyone is a-ok in the end. (or is it just the beginning...?)
there is a great deal of struggle in this book. internal struggles involving the pain of separation from "family", from new love, from friends - the distance of secrets and the necessity of this distance. as in most fairy tales, there is subtext out the wazoo here. and she manages to just spread it on there like delicious jam and you are like "hmmm what kind of fruit is this jam? it tastes a little bitter but i cannot stop eating it,"and then you're dead, because it is one of those delicious poisons that nature puts out there to ensnare you. lainie taylor, i am on to you. but i am still addicted to you.and that's just what you wanted, dammit.
for a month of stolen nights and the occasional sun-drenched afternoon when madrigal could get away from loramendi by day, they cupped their wings around their happiness and called it a world, though they both knew it was not a world, only a hiding place, which is a very different thing.
yeah, yeah, i get it: you can write.
and i was so resistant to her because of the name/cover of lips touch three times, but when i was forced (again, thanks to tommy) to actually read it, i realized that lainie taylor is the real deal. and this book just solidifies that opinion.
and my only quibble - the only thing that is keeping this from being "best book ever" is so stupid, but i just felt that the pacing was a little bit skewed. these was so much in the first half, so much slowly spooled out story of "mysterious girl in prague" and then by the end, it was so rapidly told: angels, demons, war, love, betrayal,blam blam blammo!! it left me a little breathless.
which was probably just what she wanted, but i'm no spring chicken: "i can't take any more scares!!" or rapid changes in pacing. but i feel like a jerk for even finding something to whine about, because this is pretty much as good as it gets, book-wise.
september, my kittens...
by Laini Taylor (Goodreads Author)
this book is astonishingly good.
this is the book i should have been handed when i first expressed an interest in exploring the world of the fantasy novel. never mind that isn't not going to be published for three more months (thank you to the girl with BEA access for getting this for me), it should have happened somehow.
this is the most pure example of fantasy that i have seen so far.
and it is nearly perfect.
once upon a time, an angel and a devil fell in love. it did not end well.
a fantastic opening to a book. and it really takes off from there, revealing its secrets slowly, and deliciously and only occasionally predictably.
i appreciate a sad love story, and this one really delivers. this is a fairy-tale fantasy that has its roots in the traditional fairy tale rather than the sweet disneyland versions where everyone is a-ok in the end. (or is it just the beginning...?)
there is a great deal of struggle in this book. internal struggles involving the pain of separation from "family", from new love, from friends - the distance of secrets and the necessity of this distance. as in most fairy tales, there is subtext out the wazoo here. and she manages to just spread it on there like delicious jam and you are like "hmmm what kind of fruit is this jam? it tastes a little bitter but i cannot stop eating it,"and then you're dead, because it is one of those delicious poisons that nature puts out there to ensnare you. lainie taylor, i am on to you. but i am still addicted to you.and that's just what you wanted, dammit.
for a month of stolen nights and the occasional sun-drenched afternoon when madrigal could get away from loramendi by day, they cupped their wings around their happiness and called it a world, though they both knew it was not a world, only a hiding place, which is a very different thing.
yeah, yeah, i get it: you can write.
and i was so resistant to her because of the name/cover of lips touch three times, but when i was forced (again, thanks to tommy) to actually read it, i realized that lainie taylor is the real deal. and this book just solidifies that opinion.
and my only quibble - the only thing that is keeping this from being "best book ever" is so stupid, but i just felt that the pacing was a little bit skewed. these was so much in the first half, so much slowly spooled out story of "mysterious girl in prague" and then by the end, it was so rapidly told: angels, demons, war, love, betrayal,blam blam blammo!! it left me a little breathless.
which was probably just what she wanted, but i'm no spring chicken: "i can't take any more scares!!" or rapid changes in pacing. but i feel like a jerk for even finding something to whine about, because this is pretty much as good as it gets, book-wise.
september, my kittens...
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Daughter of Smoke & Bone.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-31 of 31) (31 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
karen
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Jun 20, 2011 02:25pm
holy shit - jen didik!
reply
|
flag
*
i know. too much reading for work to indulge in outside reading. i've been hitting the published/about to be published books pretty hard over the last few weeks though. and it's great to be back in these parts!
karen wrote: "i think that's her thing. she has crummy covers and great books. it's a strange strategy..."I wrote to her (and the publishing houses - which didn't answer) and told her the cover is not really suitable (aka unattractive). Laini said:
Many many people in the publishing houses spend very much time deliberating and making the final decision. It was a long process with Daughter and will not be changed now.
^--- DAMN!
Exactly, on the cover. I never would have picked it up because of the cover. But I did because of your review.
I'm looking forward to this one... I was put off by the cover/title of Lips Touch Three Times too, but when I read it for one of my (Lib Tech) classes I was really surprised by how good it was. I don't know about for this one but for LTTT it was her husband/partner's artwork on the cover so I'm not sure how open to criticism she'd be about it. I liked his illustrations inside better than what they picked to go on the front.
There is or rather was an alternate cover for LIPS TOUCH up for auction and it look like this *drumRoll*
~ dramatic music ~
...

You can read about it.
Tommy wrote: "The illustrations are all gorgeous. It's what they did to it that made it not work"Huh?
Tommy wrote: "I think the design elements they added made it cheesy."aha. i understand (except i don't agree). *shrug*
I loved your review Karen. I think this is a fantastic book....more fantasy like you said but I don't think it is YA!
i know! YA has come a long way since i was Y. these kids today don't know how good they have it. in my day uphill both ways blah blah...
karen wrote: "i know! YA has come a long way since i was Y. these kids today don't know how good they have it. in my day uphill both ways blah blah..."So true and a lot of them won't appreciate the complexity of this boom. I strugged to put it into a coherent review!
I just finished this book. I really enjoyed it. What left me a bit annoyed was the amount of time wasted on her relationship w/ her ex boyfriend. Why even bother with the whole "posing for the art class" scene? Other than this little detour, I was impressed with the detailed writing, the fantasy names of animals, characters and places and the "ending".





