Suzanne's Reviews > Grand Pursuit: A History of Economic Genius

Grand Pursuit by Sylvia Nasar

by
3739451
's review
Sep 06, 11

bookshelves: non-fiction, favorites
Read from July 11 to 24, 2011

In the era of huge national deficits and concerns over a balanced budget, Ms. Nasar’s book couldn’t be more timely. Grand Pursuit, is the story of the science of economics – and how the human race has benefited (and suffered) as a result of the beliefs concerning government actions and its effects.

The book opens in the year 1842 in Charles Dickens’ London. Dickens himself set out to awaken men’s souls to the hardships of the working class in the hopes that something would be done to ease their plight. Nasar shows us how two schools of thought (socialism and capitalism) emerged and how, over time, they were tweaked and molded to serve various countries’ interests.

Nasar’s writing style is simply wonderful. She takes on the history of a science and makes a fascinating story out of it. Not only does she have a mastery of the subject, her research on the time periods she covers is so thorough, it enables her to connect people. places and events in a compelling and readable manner.

One thing that came across in Grand Pursuit was how reactionary the application of the science has been throughout history. In my opinion, the problem with this is that our system is so complex, those that seek to influence the direction of an economy must be aware of all the variables in place (a virtual impossibility) before taking action. At best, we can hope that our lawmakers and fiscal policy setters have a real understanding of economics before they fiddle with anything. Seeing our legislators appeal to the public for approval on budget cuts or tax increases, makes me doubtful that they have such an understanding (because the public, certainly does not). Perhaps Grand Pursuit will become required reading in high school. One can only hope…

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Grand Pursuit.
sign in »

Reading Progress

07/13/2011
43.0% "Wow! I'm really loving this book so far...you'd think about book about economics would be dry, but Ms. Nasar makes it read like a good novel!"
07/13/2011
10.0% 1 comment
show 3 hidden updates…

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Lisa (Harmonybites) In my opinion, the problem with this is that our system is so complex, those that seek to influence the direction of an economy must be aware of all the variables in place (a virtual impossibility) before taking action.

I don't know if you've heard of him or read anything by him, but this sounds very much like the key insight of Ludwig von Mises argument that socialism fails because of the "economic calculation problem"--that no one can really figure out how to organize a complex economy. It's sort of akin to the environmentalist argument about nature. That you can't improve it, just muck it up. Von Mises was part of the "Austrian School" of economics that includes Hayek and Hazlitt that greatly influences those that argue for freer markets.

I admit though I found von Mises magnum opus Human Action far too dense and difficult for me. Even with a dictionary by my side it was an ordeal trying to get through the first pages and I gave up. So I know him and his arguments through others.


Suzanne No, I haven't read anything by von Mises, but I'd have to agree with his argument. It does appear that the more governments interfere, the less chance an economy has of reaching it's full potential.


back to top