Penny's Reviews > Deadline

Deadline by Mira Grant

by
679025
***Warning: this review contains spoilers for Feed***

I really don't know what I can say about this book besides how disappointed and frustrated it left me. Not that I was expecting something incredible mind you. I mean, it's not like Feed left me begging for more so I have no idea why I gave Deadline the time of day.

Actually I do know. I'm not too bright. I was going to purchase The Demon's Surrender on Tuesday June 14th, because that's when it was released, but for whatever reason the audiobook was not available for sale at audible. So I wasted a precious audible credit on this ridiculously long piece of trash. How long is this audiobook you ask? 15+ hours.

Yes, more than 15 hours of what amounts to a really long episode of The Incredible Hulk, featuring zombies and the magical world of news blogging. Except to make things extra fun The Hulk Bruce Banner Shaun, our main character, has his dead sister's voice stuck in his head running commentary on everything he does. And he talks back to that voice. Vocally. Like, all the time no matter who is around.

When people encounter Shaun's strange behavior and make the mistake of asking if he's feeling okay, Bruce Shaun looses his crap and 'splodes out of his clothes in a fit of rage, turns green and goes on a punching spree. And he's all 'HULK MAD! HULK SMASH! HULK KILL!' starts acting like a massive douche-canoe--like, way more douche-y than he usually acts--and threatens to punch the crap out of whoever has the nerve to ask him about the state of his mental health.

That wouldn't be such worrisome behavior if he were some crazy urine-soaked hobo who lives out of a refrigerator box. But see, Shaun is the head blogger at popular news blog he and his (dead) sister started a few years before. He has a ton of employees all over the world.

Mr Crazy Pants is in charge. Really. And that's where my first issue with Deadline springs up.

Who in their right mind would put up with that crap? The answer is no one. Not even people who are supposedly friends with said crazy person. Especially when that person has not contributed ANYTHING worthwhile to the blog in over a year. A person who doesn't even make any real decisions anymore. A person who does little more than show up and carry on conversations with the dead sister living in his head himself and threaten to punch people, occasionally carrying out those threats, breaking noses in the process.

We're supposed to believe that his employees are that loyal and/or so stupid they'd be willing to stick around and take that sort of abuse. Bloggers who are at the top of their fields and could go to a number of other news blogs or easily start their own.

One could argue that he just lost his sister and his friends/employees are just really patient and understanding, but here's the deal: his sister died a year prior to the events in Deadline. Plus, they live in a world where zombies run free. Every last one of them have lost close friends and loved ones yet none of them act like Shaun.

So...what makes Shaun so special?

Nothing. He's not special. Which is why I grew weary of this book almost from the get go. But I kept reading because I thought Shaun was going to calm down and pull his act together. Don't want to be all spoiler-y but it needs to be said: that never happens. In fact his behavior worsens yet NO ONE takes a cattle prod to his crazy ass; no one throws him to the zombies just so they can get rid of their little "Debbie Downer".

There is a whole lot of other stuff that happens which, I'm sorry, doesn't really matter because (view spoiler)[Grant decides to pretty much undo something HUGE that goes down in the first book. (view spoiler)[ George is magically alive at the end of the book. That happens. Really.
(view spoiler)[The author pulls the cloning card, and a piss-poor job she does with the whole cloning thing if you ask me. Why? (view spoiler)[Because everyone knows cloning doesn't work that way. (view spoiler)[ Clones don't retain the original's memories. Sometimes they don't even look exactly like the original (hide spoiler)] And no, I don't think it's cool to just pretend it does for the sake of the story. Grant went out of her way to create the whole back story to Kellis-Amberlee, correct? So why is it so difficult for her to think up a semi-feasible reason as to why George is magically alive? The whole thing comes off a little too Resident Evil if you ask me, and no, that isn't a compliment (hide spoiler)] (hide spoiler)] (hide spoiler)]
(hide spoiler)]
. To be honest, I feel there is little of importance that goes down in this book. It's all a bunch of happenings that don't amount to anything in the end. If you've read Deadline and you don't agree with me, that's cool. Just do me a favor and ask yourself this: what, if anything, happened in this book that wasn't made so completely pointless by the way the book ended? I bet your answer is along the lines of 'nothing'.

And then there's the plot holes. So many plot holes. Gigantic ones. One in particular that is so infeasible, so massive you sort of want to write Mira Grant hate mail while reading it. Or maybe that's just me.

Speaking of holes, am I the only one that thinks the answer to the zombie problem, should a zombie apocalypse ever occur, is the Grand Canyon? I mean, it's a massive hole in the ground, right? All we'd have to do is round up and herd all the zombies to the Grand Canyon. We could walk them in at ground level and then brick them in, or just let them walk over the cliffs (this option is rather inhumane but, hey, it's flesh-eating, disease-carrying zombies we're talking about not adorable puppies and kitties). I'm also willing to consider using Carlsbad Caverns, as it is also a massive hole in the ground and I'm not a huge fan of New Mexico.

Also:

Photobucket

/tangent

Don't even get me started about Shaun's (not at all thought out) motorcycle ride of karma from zombie hell. I'm sorry but who is that stupid? Why would anyone let anyone else ride a motorcycle into a place so insanely infested with zombies? I kept wondering why they couldn't strap that thing to the back of the van, or, I don't know, LEAVE IT BEHIND. Hell, even if there really wasn't room left inside the van, Shaun could have easily strapped himself to the roof, or (call me crazy) strap some of their equipment to the roof of the van in order to make room for him. Either way, he would have been safer.

One last thing: (view spoiler)[I was so totally right about the incest thing. I knew George and Shaun were too close to not be sleeping together. And no, I don't think that Grant is so edgy by going that route. If anything Grant is all about cop-outs. The incest was a cop-out and so was the cloning of a dead character. (hide spoiler)]

I will not be reading the third book in this series. One-and-a-half stars.




Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Deadline.
sign in »

Reading Progress

06/14/2011
35.0% "Compelling story so far. Unfortunately a lot of the characters are starting to get on my nerves. If this persists I'm going to start hoping they all die and reanimate. Specifically Shaun, the MC. The boy is crazy-go-nuts and has a short fuse. He keeps threatening to punch everyone in the face--his employees, strangers, men and women. I suspect the psycho would punch a baby if it got on his nerves. Ihopehedies!"
06/14/2011
55.0% "I knew it. (EW!)"
06/15/2011
100.0% "Freaking cop-out of an ending. It pretty much undermines the point of this entire book. Plus, even though I'm not a geneticist I know cloning doesn't work like that. A POX ON MIRA GRANT'S HOUSE!" 3 comments

Comments (showing 1-6 of 6) (6 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Lucy Agreed on the massive cop-out ending. (view spoiler)[Advanced clone aging for plot sake = annoying. Retained memories that a clone would have no way of having = incredibly annoying. I wasn't crazy about Feed, but I respected an author willing to kill off their main character in a first person narrative. It was a risk most people don't take. Realizing she never actually took that risk = epic fail. (hide spoiler)]


Penny (view spoiler)[ If I had been reading this instead of listening to it I would have hurled the book across the room.

Shaun's answer to the "if you could have one thing what would that be?" question really turned me off more them anything else. Because, really, how self-involved is he? Why not just wish the zombie apocalypse never happened? That way everyone would still be alive. But then Shaun and georgia wouldnt have been raised together. He couldn't have that, not even hypothetically.

But still, the cloning gives this story a Resident Evil feel. And that's not a good thing. And anyway, why would they go to the trouble of cloning George even if the cure was in her blood? They would only need her DNA, not her entire body in order to produce the cure.

The sped up aging and the retained memories are the worst part. I think the retained memories are going to be explained away by saying the CDC took george's brain and put it in clone george's body. Very lame but a least it makes a little sense. But the aging process? There is no way that can be explained. Especially because they don't have the advanced technology to do it. The people in this series live decades in the future yet they still use thumb drives and use smart phones--technology we use now--yet their scientists can speed up the aging process and slow it down to a normal speed? Really? If they are so advanced why couldn't Dave control the lockdown system remotely through his freaking smartphone? Why are they still using thumbdrives?

I'm being a nerd. But still I can only suspend my disbelief so far when it comes to science and technology. (hide spoiler)]



message 3: by Lee (new)

Lee Excellent review, a great modifer to the hype.


Amber I assumed the ending was that the CDC had used George's blood to clone her and will now in some way use her against Shaun.


Penny Yeah, that's what I assumed as well. The thing is, even if they built a shiny new clone of George, that clone wouldn't have her brain, retain any of her memories. Don't even get me started on the fact that they somehow grew this new clone in one years time.

So they have the technology to speed age a clone AND THEN slow down the aging process to regular speed? That kind of technology is available but not the technology that would allow someone to hack into a building security system from a smart phone? While we're at it, why is this uber-advanced society still using thumbdrives?

And the storm. What was with that? Since when is a tropical storm let alone a hurricane, able to make it across the entire united states? Even if it managed to effect the nations weather system, there still aren't enough Mosquitos in the whole of Cuba that could cause that sort of devastation. And I'm sorry but don't you think it's more likely that a widespread outbreak would be caused by all the zombies that are still running wild all over the united states? By the way, how could a mosquito be a carrier when all animals under 40 lbs cannot be carriers.

Which brings me to my next point: how is it possible for children who weigh less than 40 lbs to become zombies?

Sorry about the long response. Every time I think about this book all those questions (Plus others) go through my head.


message 6: by Rose (new) - added it

Rose Your review convinced me that I shouldn't bother reading the sequels. I already had a hard time with Feed and its narration style. After I finished the book I kept wondering how readers could feel emotionally invested in the story. For me, Georgia's narration style was pretty dry. There were no emotions in the way she narrated the story and I couldn't connect with her or with any of the other characters in the book. Plot was meh. The political stuff (the campaign) made me fall asleep, even if it was interesting at first.

I read the spoiler tags and have to agree with you because to me Grant's move in Deadline sounds like a big, fat cop-out, too. (view spoiler)[I can imagine how hard it is to kill a character off when you, the writer, live with this fictional character's voice in your head for a while and grow to like him/her. But going the route, killing off the main character, getting praise for the ballsy move only to undo it in the next installment? Like, why would you do it in the first place then? If I'd read Deadline I would be pretty pissed off to have read a 500+ book about the main character's grief/way of grieving only for it not to make sense by the end of the book because SUPRISE! the person you're grieving isn't actually dead (hide spoiler)].

Now that I've decided that I won't continue with the series, I'm really curious how it all ends. (view spoiler)[Is Georgia there to stay? Will both Georgia AND Shaun survive? I don't really care about any of the characters but I have to admit I'm kinda curious if one of the main characters ends up dying and stays dead. (hide spoiler)]


back to top