Nicko's Reviews > Gone with the Wind
Gone with the Wind
by Margaret Mitchell
by Margaret Mitchell
So much has been said in praise of this book it feels redundant to add more. In terms of the slave-holding society, the film actually toned-down the pro-South view of Reconstruction (Scarlett's second husband joined the KKK in the book) and Mammy remains probably one of the most fully-developed and likeable African-American characters from 1930 you'll read.
Rhett Butler is the consummate alpha male. This book is definitely the timeless classic reputation it has earned, and though at times it seemed like the longest book ever, it is all worth it in the end. It touches on many misunderstood aspects of the civil war and its afterwords. What many people do not realize is how horrible it really was for Southerners after the war, mostly because they cannot get past the racism of the times (which it wasn't as if the North was full of equality and peace, either). If you can accept the times for what they were, you will see how well this book was written. I appreciate it for the well built characters, smooth flow, and albeit romanticized- depiction of the Antebellum South.
As far as being politically incorrect or the modern charges that the book is "racist," remember that this book was written in the 1930s. Not to mention, the time period is the Civil War era! To be completely unracist would not have depicted the era correctly. As if it represents anything more than the way people thought when it was made. Of course, it's racist. America is and has been a racist society since the beginning. This book mirrors the opinions held by the people alive and working at the time, no more and certainly no less. Have opinions changed since then? Of course, as society evolves so does the writing. All this aside, the character of "Mammy" is one of the most likeable and respected characters in the book. Rhett Butler treats her very well, and tries to win her approval. She’s the one person throughout the novel who sees through everyone’s follies and foibles, but remains forgiving of them anyway. There's a reason this book won so many awards and still endures! It is a timeless classic that everyone should enjoy and read in context.
Rhett Butler is the consummate alpha male. This book is definitely the timeless classic reputation it has earned, and though at times it seemed like the longest book ever, it is all worth it in the end. It touches on many misunderstood aspects of the civil war and its afterwords. What many people do not realize is how horrible it really was for Southerners after the war, mostly because they cannot get past the racism of the times (which it wasn't as if the North was full of equality and peace, either). If you can accept the times for what they were, you will see how well this book was written. I appreciate it for the well built characters, smooth flow, and albeit romanticized- depiction of the Antebellum South.
As far as being politically incorrect or the modern charges that the book is "racist," remember that this book was written in the 1930s. Not to mention, the time period is the Civil War era! To be completely unracist would not have depicted the era correctly. As if it represents anything more than the way people thought when it was made. Of course, it's racist. America is and has been a racist society since the beginning. This book mirrors the opinions held by the people alive and working at the time, no more and certainly no less. Have opinions changed since then? Of course, as society evolves so does the writing. All this aside, the character of "Mammy" is one of the most likeable and respected characters in the book. Rhett Butler treats her very well, and tries to win her approval. She’s the one person throughout the novel who sees through everyone’s follies and foibles, but remains forgiving of them anyway. There's a reason this book won so many awards and still endures! It is a timeless classic that everyone should enjoy and read in context.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Gone with the Wind.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-7 of 7) (7 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Heidi
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Apr 10, 2009 08:43am
I'm actually on page 75 right now and totally hooked. I am a fourth grade teacher. I teach my students about the history of our country, good and bad. Not everything in the past is the type of stuff as Americans we are proud of but it is important to know where we came from. If you don't acknowledge the mistakes and racism of the past you won't ever learn from it. I feel like it is a glimpse into that time period and I am personally fascinated. I loved your review and it makes me want to finish the book even faster!
reply
|
flag
*
At one point i thought this was one of the best books written but now that i'm wiser i think about the fact that black people weren't represented like they should have been. Mammy was the only sensible character throughout the whole book. And the stereotypes about black people was spilling over throughout this book. i give it 3 stars.
Excellent review! I love Gone with the Wind for many of the same reasons you have listed. Your review makes me want to pick up the book and read it again!
Very good review...I read this book as a teen and now I'm going to read it again.Thanks for this perception of your read.



