Kat's Reviews > Down These Strange Streets
Down These Strange Streets
by George R.R. Martin , Gardner R. Dozois , Charlaine Harris, Joe R. Lansdale, Simon R. Green, Steven Saylor, S.M. Stirling, Carrie Vaughn (Goodreads Author) , more…
by George R.R. Martin , Gardner R. Dozois , Charlaine Harris, Joe R. Lansdale, Simon R. Green, Steven Saylor, S.M. Stirling, Carrie Vaughn (Goodreads Author) , more…
Kat's review
bookshelves: fantasy, short-stories, urban-fantasy, 2012
Jan 09, 12
bookshelves: fantasy, short-stories, urban-fantasy, 2012
Read from November 22, 2011 to January 09, 2012
Basic premise: Urban fantasy stories that center around mysteries/detectives.
I hate George RR Martin on a personal level at this point. His SOIAF series has pissed me off to the point that I have been unable to continue reading it. So here I have a volume of stories set in my favorite genre, edited by GRRM. There's a fantastic introduction to the book, defining UF and the connections it has to the mystery genre. Then he proceeds to give me an overly-large volume of mostly "meh"-level stories, some of which are only VERY loosely tied to the UF genre. And on top of it all, there's no Harry Dresden story in an anthology seemingly tailored to the concept of Dresden. Grrrrr....
Generally speaking, UF stories take place in the modern (or very near modern) day. WWII? Ok, I can deal with that. Ancient Rome?? Ancient Babylon??? WTF???? Some of these stories didn't even have an actual fantasy element to them, just a "possible" fantasy element that got disproven, making the stories NOT UF at all, but regular mysteries, if set in odd time periods.
I'm hacked off. I renewed this book from the library twice in order to finish the bloody thing and still paid a late fine. It's only real saving grace in my mind is the Patricia Briggs offering, which features Warren instead of Mercy. The Charlaine Harris story was ok, but I don't find Dahlia to be a particularly interesting/sympathetic character, so I can't get into the few stories I've seen about her.
Stupid GRRM. I'm going to go read something by an author who's dead already so I won't feel the urge to go out and murder someone anymore.
I hate George RR Martin on a personal level at this point. His SOIAF series has pissed me off to the point that I have been unable to continue reading it. So here I have a volume of stories set in my favorite genre, edited by GRRM. There's a fantastic introduction to the book, defining UF and the connections it has to the mystery genre. Then he proceeds to give me an overly-large volume of mostly "meh"-level stories, some of which are only VERY loosely tied to the UF genre. And on top of it all, there's no Harry Dresden story in an anthology seemingly tailored to the concept of Dresden. Grrrrr....
Generally speaking, UF stories take place in the modern (or very near modern) day. WWII? Ok, I can deal with that. Ancient Rome?? Ancient Babylon??? WTF???? Some of these stories didn't even have an actual fantasy element to them, just a "possible" fantasy element that got disproven, making the stories NOT UF at all, but regular mysteries, if set in odd time periods.
I'm hacked off. I renewed this book from the library twice in order to finish the bloody thing and still paid a late fine. It's only real saving grace in my mind is the Patricia Briggs offering, which features Warren instead of Mercy. The Charlaine Harris story was ok, but I don't find Dahlia to be a particularly interesting/sympathetic character, so I can't get into the few stories I've seen about her.
Stupid GRRM. I'm going to go read something by an author who's dead already so I won't feel the urge to go out and murder someone anymore.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Down These Strange Streets.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 11/22/2011 | page 15 |
|
3.0% | "I can't believe there's no Harry Dresden story in this!" |
| 12/20/2011 | page 127 |
|
27.0% | "The problem with large books filled with short stories is that you need to let the book sit for a bit between stories or your brain turns to mush. This makes the reading a much slower process." |
| 01/06/2012 | page 387 |
|
81.0% | "Why are there so many stories that take place in ancient Roman times? This seems to be out of genre to me..." |
Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)
date
newest »
newest »
I don't quite remember where I heard it, but someone said GRRM hates his fans more than George Lucas does. I have to agree.
I like that. I have also heard/read, that whenver a fan somewhere asks or complains about the speed of GRRM's writing/release of books in this series, (you can click on this spoiler if you read Storm of Swords) (view spoiler)

But I did like the Briggs story. I am going to go read your reviews of the Fire and Ice series, I did not know you had such strong feelings for GRRM! But I can imagine a few reasons why.