Vinaya's Reviews > Eon: Dragoneye Reborn

Eon by Alison Goodman

by
4687823
's review
Apr 15, 11

bookshelves: fantasy, hmm-that-was-interesting, mixed-vibes, wrung-me-dry, ya-fantasy
Read from April 13 to 15, 2011

When I first started this book, I was like,

Photobucket

Then I read some more, and I became more like this:

Photobucket

Thankfully, before I went completely bald, the shit hit the fan, and it was THE END.

Photobucket

This book and I have a long and complicated history. About two years ago, a friend from the UK was visiting and she left behind a book called The Two Pearls of Wisdom. She told me I HAD to read it, and as I tend to do with most paperbacks, I shoved it in the black hole I call a bookcase and promptly forgot it existed.

Fast forward two years later, to when my book goddess Tatiana writes a glowing review of a fantasy novel called Eon: Dragoneye Reborn. Enthusiastic as always, I rush off to order the book, and while I'm waiting eagerly for it to arrive, I decide to sort through the overflowing mess of books in my room. I come across The Two Pearls of Wisdom, and while I'm randomly flipping pages, a name leaps out and stabs me in the eye. Eon. I read the synopsis in disbelief and log on to Goodreads to see that my terrible suspicion is true. The Two Pearls of Wisdom is, in fact, the original title of Eon: Dragoneye Reborn.

Photobucket


As I said, this book inspired a variety of emotions in me, most of them extreme. 'Ah, the hallmark of a great book', you think. But the truth is, I almost gave this book *whispers* three stars. Seriously, when I was halfway through the story, I thought I might have an apoplexy and splatter my overtaxed brains across the walls. (Now there's a pretty image for you!)

Eon is not an easy character to like. He doesn't have the easy courage of a Katniss, or the admirable and stoic, heroism of a Harry Potter. He is a little too real, if there can be such a thing. As the unprepared victim of political intrigue and power games, he is unwilling to accept the responsibility that has been thrust upon him. Expecting to be an apprentice, one of twelve and schooled by a Dragoneye, he is instead thrust into the position of Co-Ascendant, expected to govern the Council and prevent the usurpation of the Emperor's throne.

While Eon's fright and denial of the burden placed on him were beautifully drawn, and only mildly irritating, it was his attempts to reach his dragon that truly tried my patience. As a reader, you are well aware that Eon's continued consumption of the Sun drug, and his denial of his femininity, are distancing him from his dragon; but since Eon continues to struggle against this obvious conclusion for several chapters, it leads to a sort of hideous, helpless frustration on the poor reader's part. Combined with the general passivity of his characterization, I found it very hard to like him indeed.

It is not until the very end that Eon begins to accept responsibility for his decisions and moves up from pawn to queen. But I am still not ready to forgive an entire book where the 'protagonist' is subject to the whims of other people and gets tossed around like a leaf in a high gale with no motivating force of his own.

The reason I refer to Eon as a he, instead of a she, is because Goodman has skilfully portrayed him as a boy throughout the novel. Except for occasional thoughts about his hidden womanhood, Eon never deviates from the path of manhood.

The main thing that earned this book four stars is the sheer diversity of its mythos and characters. Unlike the large majority of Western-focused SFF, Eon derives its mythos from Chinese and Japanese culture. It is a viciously alien but colorful amalgamation of forced castrations, transvestites, bonded labour and magical energy.

There is a LOT of world building to process is in this book, but a familiarity with Chinese culture and history, and the sheer fascination of immersing myself in a world so far out of the norm, helped it all go down easy,

Eon was a difficult book emotionally, but it was gripping and edgy and real. Definitely a must-read, if you haven't already.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Eon.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-28 of 28) (28 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Kat Kennedy Glad you liked this one too.


Vinaya I'm not sure 'liked' is an appropriate word for the agonies of hair-pulling frustration I went through. Also, it sucks that I didn't hold off on this book for another couple of days so I could grab the sequel too! :'(


Kat Kennedy I know. There were so many points in this book where I thought my heart was never going to recover from the stress!


The UHQ Nasanta Interesting. First part of your review made me think Eon might be a little like Fitzchivalry Farseer in Robin Hobb's Assassins trilogy. Then the second part about his hidden femininity reminded me of Lynn Flewelling's The Bone Doll Twin's protagonist. If you've read either book, how similar to the two books I've mentioned would you say Eon is?


Catie I was completely there with you on the hair pulling (and the three stars...). She brought me to such a low of frustration and agony; it made the ending even more glorious for me. I think it's some of the best comeuppance I've ever read. Not to mention, if this goes the way I think it's going...that's a pretty bold choice.


Vinaya Oooh, are you talking about (view spoiler)[ the Ido luurve angle (hide spoiler)]? I'm kind of dying to see how that whole plotline works out!


Catie Yes! Me too.... Luckily, we both only have three days to wait.


Vinaya Not me! :( Everything takes TWICE as long to reach India!

@ niquae: I read the Farseer trilogy a while ago, so I'm a little hazy on the details, but no, this book didn't really remind me of those ones. For one thing, the politics and plotting were a lot more intricate in Hobbs's books, and for another, there is an almost complete absence of magic in that universe. As for the Bone Doll's Twin, Tamir doesn't know she's female, so the gender-bending in that book takes a completely different turn. There are some common elements, of course, but Eon doesn't feel derivative at all!


Tatiana Vinaya wrote: "Oooh, are you talking about [spoilers removed]? I'm kind of dying to see how that whole plotline works out!"

Haha. I so know how it all ends!


Vinaya Thank you, Tatiana, for gloating ignobly while rubbing salt in our wounds! :P


Catie I actually avoided reading this one until days before the release of the second, so I wouldn't have to go through the waiting. I have to say though, the ending isn't as abrupt as some - there's a good amount of closure.

I'm surprised that this one is releasing in the U.S. at the same time as the Australian release. I'm used to waiting for my favorite Australian authors too. I just went to Alison Goodman's website and the first chapter of Eona is up there. *Off to read first chapter*


Catie Also for a nice change, I think the U.S. cover of Eona is actually the best one! That's unusual.


message 13: by Yui (new) - rated it 5 stars

Yui Hmnn.. I've had this book for years now too. I don't forget but I always pass it off. I just can't bring myself to read it when I haven't finished my Eragon 1&2. I know they're probably not that alike but Eragon came 1st. It's not that I'm a V in dragon books but Eragon is like classic that I need to learn from 1st before I appreciate a good dragon book. I wonder if I could ignore the silly rule and just dive in Eon?


Melanie Any ROMANCE!?!?!?!?!?!


Vinaya Nope, not in this one, but there is the set-up for one in the sequel.


Lisa O. Vinaya wrote: "Nope, not in this one, but there is the set-up for one in the sequel."

You can tell by the way Eon/a describes HIS well formed muscles :-)


Michelle, the Bookshelf Stalker I really hope there are pictures in your review! I'm at work and sometimes, I can't see the pictures. All I see is "When I first started this book, I was like, Then I read some more, and I became more like this: Thankfully, before I went completely bald, the shit hit the fan, and it was THE END."

LOL


Vinaya LOL yes, in fact, there are some very cute pictures! :)


Michelle, the Bookshelf Stalker Vinaya wrote: "LOL yes, in fact, there are some very cute pictures! :)"

Ok, so that makes no sense at all! I can see naked man pics sometimes at work (no, I wasn't intentionally looking, they kind of just fell on my computer screen) but I can't look at cute, innocent pics. I wonder about my IT support team. Maybe I should check out THEIR computers! LOL


message 20: by Shannon (new) - added it

Shannon Is most of the book spent with Eon as a boy, or most as a girl, or bout half and half??
I really want to read this book, but for some reason I never really like books from the POV of a guy...weird I know


Vinaya No, you know almost from the beginning that Eon is actually a girl. It's just the rest of the characters in the book that take a while to figure it out...


Paige How old is everyone here? I was wondering at what age Eon should be read. I read Alanna and loved it but that was years ago and its really a kids book that I wouldint enjoy as much if I read it now.. how about Eon? what age are you enjoying it at? :)


message 23: by Vi (new) - rated it 4 stars

Vi Great review, Vinaya! I kept nodding at all the parts. Especially the middle part where Eon really really tries your patience. But now that I've finished, I'm very glad I finally picked up this book. Goodman has good writing skills :)


♥ Ashleigh ♥  contrary to popular belief im not actually mad! Fantastic review!


Terry Johnson I'm currently at the hair-pulling stage the sun drug and it's good to hear others felt frustrated with the character, and that it gets better. I'm compelled to keep reading because of the spectacular writing.


message 26: by Sheridan (new) - added it

Sheridan Thank You for letting me know that it get's better, I started reading this book months ago, but was not engaged and so moved onto other books, I have only just picked it up again and I am still in the hair pulling stages but your review has given me hope that if I push through, I just might enjoy the rest of the book.


message 27: by Lindsey (new) - added it

Lindsey I think I may read this one next from my giant YA to be read pile...


Shaft I largely agree with you about how ridiculously unlikeable Eon as a character is, it is the rich scenery and the political intrigue that kept me reading till halfway and after that I just had to finish because that is how I do stuff.


back to top