Ben Babcock's Reviews > A Wizard of Earthsea

A Wizard of Earthsea by Ursula K. Le Guin
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1188122
's review
Dec 04, 13

bookshelves: 2011-read, didactic-fiction, fantasy, favourites, own, 2011-best10
Read from April 03 to 04, 2011 — I own a copy, read count: 3

This what A Wizard of Earthsea taught me:
* To know a thing's true name is to know its nature.
* Don't fuck with dragons (unless you know their true names).
* Summoning the spirits of the dead is a bad idea, especially on a schoolboy dare.
* Truly changing your form is dangerous, because you can become lost in the aspect you assume.
* If you find yourself hunted, turn it around and become the hunter.
* Above all else, know yourself.

I don't know how I acquired this particular copy of A Wizard of Earthsea. It's an old, 1977 reprint that is, aside from its yellowing pages, in remarkably good condition for something that, in its day, cost $1.50 in Canada or 50 p in the UK. It bears no evidence of a previous owner, be that person, library, or used bookstore. Perhaps someone gave it to me. However I got it, I remember that I read A Wizard of Earthsea for a second time through this copy. I read it mostly in the backseat of my mom's van and then in a hair salon while waiting for her to get her hair done. So this book is firmly ensconced in my mind as a book I read "when I was younger," and I associate it with my childhood (even though I suspect I was probably in my early teens).

When I first came upon China Miéville a few years ago, I was an adult and approached his books with an adult's ideas about fantasy. I've only ever known Miéville's works through the eyes of adulthood, and that is something outside of my control, but it definitely affects how I view his works. In contrast, Ursula K. Le Guin has been with me my entire life, stalking me, if you will. Curiously enough, her books have never played the formative role in my reading, especially my fantasy reading, that others like The Belgariad, A Song of Ice and Fire, or Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy have done. I don't have a pithy story about reading a Le Guin book as a child or adolescent that then opened my eyes and inspired me to read more fantasy. So it's all the more intriguing that I distinctly remember Le Guin being in my life ever since childhood. I don't remember when I first read one of her books, only that I did. And when I pick up A Wizard of Earthsea, I'm connected to my childhood, to that memory of this particular copy, as well as to memories of reading fantasy in general. This is a gateway book, and that's why it means so much to me.

If you don't have this type of connection to Le Guin or to A Wizard of Earthsea, I can understand how easy it is to dismiss this book as a 2- or 3-star endeavour. It's a condensed story with a small cast of characters who aren't necessarily the most intriguing bunch you'll ever meet. There's a lot of narration and exposition covering most of Ged's childhood and adolescent years. It's not exactly the big-budget, epic type of fantasy story that is so popular now. Nor is Ged your typical fantasy farm boy Called to be the Chosen One. He's a wizard of no small talent who, because he's a cocky adolescent boy, screws up and spends no small part of his adult life attempting to rectify the mistake.

There's a lot of darkness in this book. It reminds me, this time around, of Arthurian legends: well-meaning, valorous people struggling against their darker selves, and sometimes losing. Even the Knights of the Round Table had the advantage of knowing they were heroes though—Ged is not a hero; he's just this guy, you know? He's not preternaturally gifted with good sense, so like any inexperienced adolescent, he makes bad decisions and is full of flaws. He ditches his master on Gont, Ogion, to go learn wizardry at Roke because he's eager to learn "real magic." He feels like Ogion is holding him back (we readers, of course, recognize that Ogion is the wise sensei who teaches his student the value of wisdom and work first). At Roke, Ged allows himself to be manipulated into magical pissing contests by his rival, Jasper. The result is the escape of a "shadow" into the world of Earthsea, and its encounter with Ged leaves it with some of his power and a hunger to absorb the rest of his aspect. This would be bad, for Ged, and for the world. But A Wizard for Earthsea shares with Arthurian legend that underlying motif of temptation and the sin of pride: people and magic continually tempt Ged, and his successes are measured in the varying degrees by which he overcomes and rejects those temptations. Sometimes he fails miserably, resulting in the unleashing of a gebbeth into the world! Other times, he succeeds admirably, such as in the case of the dragon Yevaud.

Ged's encounter with the dragon of Pendor is nominally what turns him into a legendary "dragonlord." He manages to learn the dragon's true name, and with it he wrangles from the dragon a promise never to fly to the Archipelago. The safety of the islands of Earthsea thus secure, he departs Pendor to resume his life and his apparently-eternal flight from the gebbeth.

Ged's confrontation with Yevaud is right out of the classical "man versus beast battle of wits" canon. What stuck with me for the rest of the book, however, was how Ged deals with Yevaud's brood. He ruthlessly does battle with these dragonspawn, killing six of them. Dragons in Le Guin's Earthsea are predators but intelligent ones: their speech is the same Old Speech from which Earthsea wizards draw power. So I can't help but feel that in slaying these creatures, Ged is wreaking destruction on a much larger scale. He's destroying something unique and wonderful, even if it is dangerous to humans. And Ged is rather cavalier about it: he goes to Pendor because he's decided to leave the town he was protecting from possible dragon attacks, and before he goes he wants to ensure the town will be safe. This is his first act of major wizardry as a full-fledged wizard, and it is interesting that it is one of destruction, even if it benefits those he swore to protect.

After his encounter with Yevaud, Ged bums around Earthsea for a little while, faces another great trial, and almost doesn't survive. Fortunately he finds his way back to Ogion, who sets him straight and gives him the best possible advice:

If you go ahead, if you keep running, wherever you turn you will meet danger and evil, for it drives you, it chooses the way you go. You must choose. You must seek what seeks you. You must hunt the hunter.


If you read A Wizard of Earthsea as a straight fantasy story about good versus evil and wizards and dragons, you will probably be disappointed. Read this way, it's a good book, but it isn't great. It's too brief to be a satisfying epic meal. The strength of Wizard of Earthsea is neither its style nor its substance but its subtext. This book embodies "literary fiction" a lot better than much of what gets marketed under that term today.

The cover of my edition, aside from its regrettable whitewashing of the characters, seems to support the idea that this is a children's book. The brief description on the back of the book continues this illusion: "A tale of wizards, dragons and terrifying shadows, in which the young wizard Sparrowhawk strives to destroy the evil shadow-beast he has let loose on the world." This description does not do the book justice, nor do I think calling A Wizard of Earthsea a "children's book" does any favours for the book or for children. This is not a children's book any more than other books that children or adults might read are "adult books." This is a book, a book for children and for adults, and frankly one that people should read early and often.

I read A Wizard of Earthsea as a child, again as an adolescent, and now I've read it as an adult. Each time, I've read it slightly differently, and it has told me different things; my opinions of Le Guin and her works have changed as my perspective changes from childhood to adulthood. For me, A Wizard of Earthsea is memorable and magical because of what it teaches through its story. It deserves five stars because, for a fantastic tale at a slim 200 pages, this book seems to contain an inordinate amount of truth.

My Reviews of the Earthsea series:
The Tombs of Atuan

Creative Commons License
64 likes · likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Wizard of Earthsea.
sign in »

Reading Progress

04/04/2011 page 203
100.0%

Comments (showing 1-11 of 11) (11 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

Shit, man, this is awesome. I wanted to copy and paste too many sections as ones I agree with wholeheartedly, maybe especially the bit about the line between children's fictions and adult. And I hadn't noticed before how cavalierly Ged treats the death of the dragon brood, but I will watch out for it in my next read, which I'm sure I'll undertake sooner than later. I keep coming back to this story, again and again. There's something here for me like nothing else.

Have you read the rest of the series? (I know I could check, but, um, lazy.) Some of what I love about Earthsea is how the place seems to shift each time Le Guin returns to this world, and I bring back to Ged's first story the things I learn in later books so that the books lap against each other like the tides. Ah ah ah ah....


message 2: by Ben (last edited Apr 12, 2011 07:28PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ben Babcock Thanks!

Ceridwen wrote: "Have you read the rest of the series? (I know I could check, but, um, lazy.)"

I've read some of them. I think I've read The Tombs of Atuan, and I know I read Tales from Earthsea. But that was a long time ago and you won't find them on my Goodreads shelf. I have a copy of Tombs of Atuan and am going to read that very soon, which is one of the reasons I chose to re-read A Wizard of Earthsea right now.

Le Guin is on my list of authors whose entire oeuvre I want to read (aside from the odd short story that got printed in a single anthology that has since been relocated to the far side of the moon or whatever). I've hit many of her most well-known books, like The Left Hand of Darkness and The Dispossessed .

I also have mad respect for Le Guin, because she's been doing this for so long but is still so down-to-earth about it. She recently did an interview with the BBC World Service in which she very politely deconstructs almost every question the (well-intentioned) interviewer asks and explains why it's wrong. :D And listening to an 81-year-old woman talk about using a cell phone in an intelligent manner and her claims that she's "just a novelist" is so great. I really admire her as well as her works.


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

Oh! I started a UKL group a while back, and we're starting to do group reads. Join up if you'd like - we just started The Lathe of Heaven.

http://www.goodreads.com/group/show/4...


message 4: by Ben (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ben Babcock Thanks. Unfortunately, I have an oppressive number of books in my overflow pile that need attention, so I hesitate to add another group read. They stared at me as I took A Wizard of Earthsea off my bookshelf and passed silent judgement. I tried to explain to them that I needed to re-read it so I can read Tombs of Atuan and eventually work my way to them, but they don't understand. All they see is me reading a book I've read before, and it sends shivers up their spines.


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

Hahaha! Fair enough. I have a bunch of books silently recriminating me as well, so I understand.


Samuel García Well put, sir.


Thelonious Legend Now that is a review! It makes me want to re-read The Wizard of Earth Sea all over again. Well done sir...


Mary Have you seen the movie by Studio Ghibli? What did you think-if you did? Because I really want to read the book for the movie really glanced off a lot of things that made it confusing.


message 9: by Ben (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ben Babcock No, I’ve only seen the awful Sci-Fi channel miniseries.

I don’t think it would be impossible to film, but I think A Wizard of Earthsea requires a skilled director and writer who can translate the implicit parts of the book to screen.


Thelonious Legend Ben wrote: "No, I’ve only seen the awful Sci-Fi channel miniseries.

I don’t think it would be impossible to film, but I think A Wizard of Earthsea requires a skilled director and writer who can translate the ..."


I agree Ben. That mini-series was awful. I wouldn't mind seeing James Ponsoldt directing a film version. He has shown a deft touch in "The Spectacular Now" with Shailene Woodley and I think he would hit it out the park.


message 11: by Ben (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ben Babcock I haven’t seen The Spectacular Now (I don’t get a chance to see a lot of recent movies), so I can’t comment on that idea. I agree with the implicit premise that the series is filmable with the right director and the respect for the source material any good work deserves. I’d even go so far as to argue that, unlike many complicated novels that benefit from the miniseries treatment we can give them in the current state of the industry, A Wizard of Earthsea can work nicely as a movie. It has the right dramatic arc and pacing to it.


back to top