Lyn M (readinghearts)'s Reviews > The Snows of Kilimanjaro and Other Stories
The Snows of Kilimanjaro and Other Stories
by Ernest Hemingway
by Ernest Hemingway
Lyn M (readinghearts)'s review
bookshelves: 2011, borrowed, ccclib, classics, stacks, short-stories
Sep 22, 12
bookshelves: 2011, borrowed, ccclib, classics, stacks, short-stories
Read from March 30 to April 05, 2011, read count: once
OK, It is official. Ernest Hemingway is just not for me. I read this book because I am doing a three month "Give an author a second chance" challenge, and I couldn't think of anyone who I needed to give a second chance more than Hemingway. I have only read two books by Hemingway in my whole life, The Old Man and the Sea and The Sun Also Rises. Both of those were a long time ago. So I thought, how perfect for the challenge. At first, as I started the book, I was beginning to think that maybe he wasn't as bad as I remembered, but every time I would really start to get into a story.....BAM, he would slap me upside the head with one of the traits of his writing that drive me crazy, thus reminding me why I don't read Hemingway.
For example, in one story he spends a whole page having the two characters say
"Watch the game with me."
"No, I'm going to pray."
"Watch the game with me."
"No, I'm going to pray."
"Watch the game with me."
"No, I'm going to pray."
"Watch the game with me."
"No, I'm going to pray."
Literally, a whole page. Or he describes something in the most undescriptive way possible. Or he doesn't describe it at all. In my opinion the man has no imagination at all. The only things that he writes about are old men who are womanizers, like to either hunt or fish, and want to commit suicide. In other words, himself. I will not be running out to get any more Hemingway anytime soon.
For example, in one story he spends a whole page having the two characters say
"Watch the game with me."
"No, I'm going to pray."
"Watch the game with me."
"No, I'm going to pray."
"Watch the game with me."
"No, I'm going to pray."
"Watch the game with me."
"No, I'm going to pray."
Literally, a whole page. Or he describes something in the most undescriptive way possible. Or he doesn't describe it at all. In my opinion the man has no imagination at all. The only things that he writes about are old men who are womanizers, like to either hunt or fish, and want to commit suicide. In other words, himself. I will not be running out to get any more Hemingway anytime soon.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Snows of Kilimanjaro and Other Stories.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 03/30/2011 | page 40 |
|
28.0% |
Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Shirley
(new)
Apr 13, 2011 04:28pm
Lyn, I love your review. I laughed out loud when I saw you gave this book 1 star. Then I thought, what a sin, how awful for you to read the whole book and not like it. I have never read Hemmingway and have no real desire to do so, nothing against him, just, I suppose, never thought of reading his work. I'm glad though you gave him a chance. I'm reading Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand, a book Jen lent me and one that she absolutely loved. I read 2 chapters and was ready to give up. I said so to Jen today and she said, not yet, don't give it up yet. Read another 5 pages and then decide. Guess what, I want to read the rest. Funny, huh?
reply
|
flag
*
The thing about Hemingway is that no one that I know likes his writing. Well, except for my dad. And he just likes him because he writes about wars. I think it is a guy/generational thing for him, lol. So I really don't get why Hemingway is considered a classic, but that's just me.
I agree with Shirley, your review made me laugh too! After reading many of Hemingway's works as various college lit assignments, I must say, I have never actually chosen to read one just for pleasure!

