Margot's Reviews > On Chesil Beach

On Chesil Beach by Ian McEwan

by
4115471
's review
Mar 05, 12

Read from May 28 to June 06, 2011

If Ian McEwan was not written on the front page, I would hardly believe that it is one of his novels. I didn't read one of his books since almost one year and a half and On Chesil Beach was on the "Recommanded" list of my bookstore so I decided to give it a try. Actually it has been a huge torture to finish that book.

Of course, Ian McEwan's writing is still really beautiful. He knows how to write but the story doesn't go anywhere and the characters are uninteresting, and the opposite of deep. The only exception may be Edward but I'm not even quite sure. I find some themes that McEwan likes to explore in his works like misunderstanding and how it can change people lives forever. He has explored that question in Atonement because the vision that Briony had of the situation was totally different from reality but she believed it was true. I think that Atonement is really about misunderstanding, perception and the complexity of human relationships. But On Chesil Beach is far away from that. Edward misunderstands the signals that Florence sends. She can't properly understand him and at the same time blames herself for being different from other women. I mean... it's boring and they don't even get anything from that experience at the end of the book. I really wonder how I actually managed to finish that novel. It's not even like there was an evolution. It's just the story of two people, who thought that they were a couple, and that actually didn't listen or understand each other. Ian McEwan had great material and I know that he can do pretty amazing thing. He spend a lot of pages remembering the reader about Florence and Edward's past and actually it doesn't even contribute to the narrative process because when we go back to the bedroom, it is like they were totally different characters.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read On Chesil Beach.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Florencia What a great review. I felt the same way about this book! Having read Atonement, I had pretty high expectations regarding this novel & it was just such a disappointment. I couldn't make myself care of either of the main characters. There was also something uniquely weird about this book. On the one hand it was oddly intense with all the painfully ("painfully" being the keyword here lol) detailed descriptions of single movements & sensations, but on the other hand it was so... so unbelievably SHALLOW. I think the story idea was good but somehow it got lost in the writing process & the result is less than appealing. Certainly not a book I'd recommend to anyone.


Margot Florencia wrote: "What a great review. I felt the same way about this book! Having read Atonement, I had pretty high expectations regarding this novel & it was just such a disappointment. I couldn't make myself care..."

Absolutely! And the worst part of it is that I have read others reviews and people said that if you don't enjoy that book it's because you've totally missed the point. This is so ridiculous. I mean... It's not because it is Ian McEwan that we have to love it. He wrote "Atonement"!!! That book is a piece of art. And "Saturday" was great too. But "On Chesil beach" has been "painful" like you said. Such a disappointment.


back to top