Manny's Reviews > Max Et Lili Se Posent Des Questions Sur Dieu

Max Et Lili Se Posent Des Questions Sur Dieu by Dominique de Saint Mars
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Mar 28, 2011

liked it
bookshelves: ainsi-va-la-vie, children, french, linguistics-and-philosophy, well-i-think-its-funny, transcendent-experiences
Read on March 27, 2011

Max's friend Koffi is coming for a couple of days. On the way home from school, he asks Max what religion he is.

"Uh... dunno," says Max, who's clearly never even thought about it.

"Well, do you eat pork?" asks Koffi. "If you don't, then you're Muslim or Jewish."

"I'm not sure!" says Max. "We eat meat... and anyway, what's your religion?"

It turns out that's complicated. Koffi's father is Muslim, his mother's Catholic, and his African grandmother is animist. He's worried about Grandma, who's seriously ill, and he's praying that God will make her better.

"Don't they have doctors in Africa?" asks Lili.

"Now Lili..." says Mom.

"I mean," continues Lili, "you don't seriously believe..."

"LILI!!" says Mom. "Knock it off NOW!!!"

But Koffi isn't fazed. God, he tells them, is more powerful than any doctors. His simple faith impresses Max, who's never heard any of this before.

"So if I pray to God, I can get better marks on my tests?" he asks. Rather like Woody Allen in Hannah And Her Sisters, he's kicking the tyres before buying. "Maybe," says Koffi. But he's more interested in talking about Grandma. He had a dream that Grandpa appeared and said she would soon be joining him in Heaven, and he's terrified that something bad is going to happen.

"I need to make a sacrifice," he says. "Here, Max, you can have my Nintendo."

"Huh?" says Max. "Why?"

Koffi explains. Max doesn't get it, but he's pretty happy to receive the Nintendo.

Lili is starting to think that she should be a little more tolerant. "Well," she says at school, "I don't really believe in this prayer shit. But suppose we all join hands with you, Koffi, and think positive thoughts about your Grandma in our own ways. It can't hurt."

Koffi is a popular kid, and everyone says they're in. They're surprised to discover that it feels really good. The next day, Koffi comes in looking much happier. The operation went well, and Grandma's out of danger.

"You can have your Nintendo back then," says Max.

"Are you KIDDING?" asks Koffi indignantly. "Do you want my Grandma to get ill again?"

Max is almost convinced, but he still needs to run a few more controlled experiments. "Look," he says, "here's what I'm going to do. Before my next test, I'm not doing any revision at all, just praying. Then we'll know for sure, right?"

Lili sighs. "Max," she says patiently, "it doesn't work like that..."
5 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Max Et Lili Se Posent Des Questions Sur Dieu.
Sign In »

Comments (showing 1-5 of 5) (5 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

notgettingenough That is so specious, the pork Muslim Jewish thing. There are so many people in Australia, at any rate, who wouldn't dream of eating pork

(a) because they are old-fashioned and see it as a health danger.

(b) because they are new-fashioned and refuse to condon the way the pig is treated.

Manny Hey, Koffi's only six! He's pretty well informed, all things considered...

message 3: by notgettingenough (last edited Mar 28, 2011 02:31AM) (new)

notgettingenough Oh. So you don't think that is the author's opinion? It is odd, then, because I rather thought this series is supposed to be educational. If I'd read that as a kid, I would have gone away with the idea that this was true.

Well, perhaps she should write one about not believing what you read in books....

But I see what you mean.

notgettingenough That's hilarious. I have this image now of a little kid who has read this going around telling people well....he is either Muslim or or the other....

message 5: by Paul (new)

Paul Bryant reminds me of the one where the boy prays every night for a new bike, never gets one, finally figures out how the system works, steals a nice new bike and prays earnestly for forgiveness. On a gastronomical level I can't figure out why folks are so down on the humble porker, why single that one out. There was a pork butcher in Britain years ago whose slogan was "We use every part of the pig except the squeak!"

back to top