Maja 's Reviews > What Alice Forgot

What Alice Forgot by Liane Moriarty

by
4551536
487 pages of pure torture!
What Alice Forgot was not at all what I expected. That should teach me never to read a book that hasn’t been rated by at least one of my trusted friends. You see, I thought this would be a well written, intelligent, heartwarming story about a woman who loses ten years of her life, but finds some other, maybe even more valuable things instead. Obviously, I was very wrong. Nevertheless, I wouldn’t normally mind reading the Aussie version of a Maeve Binchy novel, but I DID mind reading a boring Aussie version of Tara Road.

In the beginning of What Alice Forgot, Alice is lying on the gym floor (Gym?! What's she doing in a gym? She hates that sort of thing!), surrounded by strange people who are asking all kinds of silly questions. The whole situation is pretty surreal since Alice has no idea how she got there in the first place! However, it takes more than that to upset her these days: she is only 29, she has a new house, an amazing sister who also happens to be her best friend, a baby on the way and a husband who tells her things like: “Don’t be ridiculous, you goose, you know I’m bloody besotted with you.” when she’s feeling insecure. One of them will surely arrive soon to take care of her. Now, if only these people around her would stop acting like they know her! The person they’re talking about can’t be Alice, because Alice is not having her 40th birthday party in a few days, she is not obsessed with exercise, she doesn’t have three children and she most certainly isn’t getting a divorce any time soon! Why would she? She and Nick are so happy together!
Only half an hour later she’s in a hospital, her sister refuses to answer her calls, Nick is yelling at her from Portugal and a strange boy is calling her Mum. She has carelessly misplaced a decade of her life!

Sounds interesting, right? Yes, I thought so, too. Maybe it would have been if Liane Moriarty knew when to stop. 250 pages would have been more than enough for this story, the other 237 were completely unnecessary. I could go into details, but the thought of wasting another minute on this gives me a headache.
I was just checking the other ratings for this book. It has 4.02 average rating so I guess that makes me the odd one out for wanting to give it one star. I only added the other one for those few laughs Moriarty managed to squeeze out of me.

My recommendation: Run for your lives!

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read What Alice Forgot.
sign in »

Reading Progress

07/04/2011
23.0% "This book is definitely too long. That's all I'm sayin'." 8 comments
07/04/2011
44.0% "God, this book is boring. It's so boring, I've started reading my sociology textbook instead." 7 comments
07/05/2011
56.0% "Why did I have to read 250 pagest for this book to become interesting?!" 6 comments

Comments (showing 1-26 of 26) (26 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Catie (new)

Catie Ha! Looking forward to it.


message 2: by Wendy Darling (new)

Wendy Darling I'm taking this off my list based on your review. Thanks for being the "trusted friend" who guinea-pigged this for me!


message 3: by Wendy Darling (new)

Wendy Darling PS--this did NOT show up in my feed! *sigh*


message 4: by Maja (last edited Jul 06, 2011 09:56am) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Maja Phew! I really did take one for the team this time.
You know what I just remembered?!? The Silent Girl was released yesterday! :D

P.S. Your feed is evil!


message 5: by Wendy Darling (new)

Wendy Darling Yes, I have TSG on its way to me from the library!

P.S. I agree. I'm not sure whether there's a cap on how many people you can see in your top friends, so I've been whittling it down even further...but it doesn't seem to be helping.


message 6: by Flannery (new) - added it

Flannery Gross. I was hoping this would have the same sense of humor that her sister's book had for me the other day. (though that one is YA) I had a thing for Maeve Binchy when I was in high school. I kind of loved Tara Road then. *blushes* 500 pages is awfully long for chick-lit...


Maja Wendy, of course it is. :) I can't wait to read it, especially because Ice Cold was a bit of a disappointment.

Flann, too long and going in circles. The first half was completely unnecessary. It reminded me of Binchy because it's not just Alice's story, but her mother's, her sister's and even her grandmother's.
(view spoiler)[I had a thing for Binchy, too - I own most of her books. But this doesn't even come close. (hide spoiler)]


message 8: by Annemarie (new)

Annemarie So... Does she remember at the end?! Lolol i need to know.. There are 3 kids running around my house.. No time to waste! ;)


Maja LOL (view spoiler)[Of course she does. Didn't I mention that it 's chick-lit? A disgustingly happy ending was inevitable. (hide spoiler)]


message 10: by Miss (new)

Miss Thanks for the warning -- I thought the premise was a good one too!


message 11: by Joni (new) - rated it 2 stars

Joni This book seemed disheveled and was a somewhat painful read for me. Like you, I was expecting something with more depth.


message 12: by Deb (new) - rated it 5 stars

Deb I LOVED this book.. glad I didn't go by your review. To each their own!


Cynthia Heh. I pushed through to the end and ultimately liked it, but I agree the beginning was painfully slow. Head injury, confused, WE GET IT.


Maggie agree, I cant finish it although I've tried and tried


message 15: by Mary (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mary Ellen I loved this book too!


Alana I loved this book also, so did several of my friends, as Deb said to each their own.


Andrea Ghizoni I am really liking it so far, as is my book club.


Barbara Stone I completely enjoyed this book.


message 19: by Roxy (new) - rated it 2 stars

Roxy I completely agree with you!!! The book opens with her on the floor after being knocked out with the medics on the way. And yet at page 100 she is STILL in the hospital,ind you not because they held her that long (it was only over night!) but because it draaaaged out. Blah. This book was toooo slow.


Karenmeg1 I actually quite liked the book ... there were moments that were more than a bit implausible, but I managed to suspend my disbelief because there were more things that I could relate to.
[And it fared even better probably because I read it so closely after "Shades of Gray" - compared to that mess, "Alice" seemed like a literary masterpiece - now that was torture :)].


message 21: by Alana (last edited Nov 22, 2012 12:51am) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alana I lived for some time not far from where the book is set I guess it was so easy to relate to it & I don't believe I was tortured at any time even the slow bits


Barbara Stone Karenmeg1 wrote: "I actually quite liked the book ... there were moments that were more than a bit implausible, but I managed to suspend my disbelief because there were more things that I could relate to.
[And it fa..."


OMG... you got that one right!


Heike I am agreeing with you totally. This book has shining moments followed by tedium. If I could skim ahead I would, (I'm listening to the audiobook version). Something about this book grates on my American nerves. I say this as someone that loves to travel and experience new cultures. I am going to blame this on Chris Cleve. "Gold" also really annoyed me for medical reasons.


Heike I meant Chris Cleave, sorry about that.


Shauna So, I liked this book... Is Tara Road any good?


message 26: by Meg (new) - rated it 2 stars

Meg This book took me a good 6 months to read, I've never dreaded picking a book back up until this one!! haha


back to top