Rajat Ubhaykar's Reviews > Dune

Dune by Frank Herbert
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Jul 12, 2015

it was amazing
bookshelves: favorites, must-read-at-least-once, sci-fi
Read from January 16 to February 07, 2012

In my head, the purpose of this review is very clear. It is to convince YOU to read this book. Yes, you! Waste time no more. Go grab a copy.

Machiavellian intrigue, mythology, religion, politics, imperialism, environmentalism, the nature of power. All this set in a mind-boggling, frighteningly original world which Herbert ominously terms as an "effort at prediction". Dune had me hooked!

First impression

The very first stirring I felt upon opening the yellowed pages of Dune was that of stumbling upon an English translation of an ancient Arabic manuscript of undeniable power and potence which had an epic story to narrate. The tone was umistakably sombre and I realized Herbert was not here to merely entertain me, he was here to make me part of the legend of Muad'Dib. It was intriguing and challenging and heck, since I live for challenges I decided to take this one up too, gladly. The challenge was the complexity and depth of the plot, which left me perplexed, in the beginning. I knew there were dialogues which meant much more than their superficial meaning and was unable to grasp at it. I felt a yawning chasm between Herbert's vision and my limited understanding of it. However, of course, I plodded on and could feel the gap closing in with every page much to my joy and relief.

The Foreword

"To the people whose labours go beyond ideas into the realm of 'real materials'- to the dry-land ecologists, wherever they may be, in whatever time they work, this effort at prediction is dedicated in humility and admiration."

The foreword makes it pretty clear that Frank Herbert isn't kidding around. This is a serious effort at predicting how our world is going to look two thousand years from now and by God, it's a bloody good and detailed prediction. However, the real merit in this effort lies in the commentary on our lives in the present.

Why Frank Herbert is a genius

The setting of the book is arid futuristic. the plot is driven by political mindgames reminiscent of The Game of Thrones. The issues he tackles are as modern as the colour television. Herbert's genius manifests itself in his ability to combine the past, the present and the future in one sweeping elegant move called Dune.

Plot and Setting

Dune is set in a futuristic technologically advanced world which after the Butlerian Jihad (the bloody war between Man and Machines) has eliminated all computers and passed a decree declaring "Thou shalt not make a machine in the likeness of a man's mind". Since there are no computers, the essential working of the galaxy is still medieval and feudal with heavy reliance on men and their dallying around. Lots of thriller potential right there. Men with superhuman analytical abilities called Mentats have taken the place of Computers. On the other hand, we have the Bene Gesserit, an ancient school of mental and physical training for female students (it gives them superhuman intuitive powers) who follow a selective breeding program which makes them feared and mistrusted through the Imperium. Their desired end product of this breeding program is the Kwisatz Haderach, a superman who’ll be able to glimpse into the future. How he’ll be able to do this is rooted in Herbert’s idea of determinism: given that one can observe everything and analyze everything, one can effectively glimpse the future in probabilistic terms. Quantum physics anyone? The Kwisatz Haderach is the proposed solution to the male-female dichotomy, between the analytical and intuitive.

The plot of Dune is almost wholly set on the desert planet of Arrakis (also referred to as Dune), an arid wasteland where water is so scarce that men have to wear stillsuits which recycle human moisture for further consumption. The source of the galaxy’s interest in the planet is Melange, a spice which bestows upon one longevity and prescient powers. Everything on the planet is permeated with the spice, the air, the sand, the food. Everybody on the planet is hopelessly addicted to the spice, their only hope for survival being their continued intake of the spice. The Spacing Guild, the economic and trading monopolistic arm of the Galaxy badly needs the spice for interstellar transport. This is because their frigates travel faster than the speed of light and hence travel backward in time. The spice is the only way they can look into the future and see their way ahead. How cool is that! All the powers on the Galaxy are out to mine the spice, braving the sandworms, their name merely an euphemism, for they are gigantic 200 metre long creatures which always come digging through the sand whenever spice mining is undertook. Always. There’s also another little glitch. There exist on the planet, the kickass native desert tribal Fremen, whom the foreign powers look down with suspicion and disdain. The Fremen ethos is one of survival and scarcity, driven by tribalism and egalitarianism. Okay, I’ll stop right there. No more spoilers about this. Except that they value water to the extent that spitting on a person is the highest honour they can bestow upon him.

Our protagonists are the Atreides family, consisting of the Duke, his Bene Gesserit concubine Jessica and their son Paul, who have been entrusted the stewardship of Arrakis. We discover the alien planet of Arrakis along with them, firstly with fear, suspicion and wonder and ultimately, love and respect. Paul Muad’Dib, however is no ordinary prince. There’s a teeny weeny chance he might be the Kwisatz Haderach, something which troubles him constantly and gives us our conflicted hero. The poor chap trips balls over the spice and has visions of black hordes pillaging and murdering around town bearing his flag and sees his dead body multiple times.

My favourite character, however has to be the Baron Vladmir Harkonnen, the most evil character I’ve ever come across in my literary excursions. He is ruddy ruthlessness, he is virile villainy, he is truculent treachery. He executes the inept chess players in his employ which says oodles about his badassery and his fondness for cold-blooded logic. He sees everything in simplistic chess terms. What is my best move? What is my opponent’s best move? Is there anything I can do to completely squash his move? Is there a tactic which leads to mate in three?


In this setting, Herbert does so much, it’s unbelievable. Religion, politics, the dynamic nature of power, the effects of colonialism, our blatant destruction of our environment are themes which run parallel to the intensely exciting and labyrinthine plot. He shows the paramount importance of myth making and religion for power to sustain over long periods of time. Man, as a political animal is laid completely bare.

Real life

Now these are my thoughts about what Herbert could have meant to be Arrakis-


It makes perfect sense. Herbert draws heavy inspiration for the religious ideology of Muad’Dib from Islam. He says “When religion and politics ride in the same cart and that cart is driven by a living Holy man, nothing can stand in the path of such a people.” which is the philosphy of the politics of Islam. Islamism in a nutshell.

The spice, much desired by everyone, is the oil. Baron Vladmir Harkonnen is symblomatic of the wily Russians. The Desert foxes Fremen are representative of the native Saudi desert-dwelling Bedouin tribe who have a strongly tribe-oriented culture and undoubtedly value water in equal measure. And the ultimate loser is the environment.

Why do good books get over?

I almost forget this is a science fiction novel, it’s that real. It is also scary and prophetic. It is a reading experience that will leave you dreaming of the grave emptiness of Arrakis and make you wish you were there to brave it all in the privileged company of the noble Fremen. Frank Herbert achieves the pinnacle of what a sci-fi author aspires to rise to; authentic world building.

177 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Dune.
Sign In »

Quotes Rajat Liked

Frank Herbert
“I must not fear. Fear is the mind-killer. Fear is the little-death that brings total obliteration. I will face my fear. I will permit it to pass over me and through me. And when it has gone past I will turn the inner eye to see its path. Where the fear has gone there will be nothing. Only I will remain.”
Frank Herbert, Dune

Reading Progress

01/28 page 219
36.0% "Intrigue, mythology, politics, imperialism, environmentalism, the nature of power. All this set in a mind-boggling, frighteningly original world which Herbert ominously terms as an "effort at prediction". Dune has me hooked! P.S: Baron Vladmir Harkonnen is the most venerable badass I've seen, his unabashed devilry almost makes you root for him. "The day hums by sweetly when you have enough bees working for you." :p"
01/28 page 219
36.0% "All this scope for character development is making my head spin with unclear possibilities."
01/31 marked as: read

Comments (showing 1-25 of 25) (25 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Invidia And you'll find a lot of philosophical food for thought in this one.

Invidia Joy! How's the magic?

Jonathan You have me at "Machiavellian intrigue" not to mention that I have this on my shelf waiting to be read. Great review!

Rajat Ubhaykar Thanks Jonathan! Apart from ample Machiavellian intrigue etched in the plot, Dune is a fantastic feat of the imagination. You should dig it out of your shelf as soon as possible. Hope you enjoy reading it! :)

Jonathan I'm sure I will. Dozens have recommended it to me and I bought it at the same time as Way of Kings. No doubt it'll be good.

Rajat Ubhaykar That reminds me, must try some Brandon Sanderson soon.

message 7: by [deleted user] (new)

Great review of a great book.

Rajat Ubhaykar Thanks Steve! This happens to be one of those books that I believe everyone must read at least once.

sologdin agreed, there: no speculative fiction reader may skip it.

message 10: by Cate (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cate Earnshaw fantastic review, thankyou. I read thus years ago, and you've made me want ti read it again.

Rajat Ubhaykar Thanks Cate! I'm glad I made you want to read it again. :)

message 12: by Mick (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mick Best review I've ever read of dune !

Rajat Ubhaykar Thanks for the generous praise Mick!

message 14: by [deleted user] (new)

Great review Rajat. It's made me want to pick it up again and read it. Have you read the others in the series?

Rajat Ubhaykar Thanks Darren! I've read Dune Messiah which I thought was a worthy sequel to Dune. I'm yet to read Children of Dune.

message 16: by Riku (new) - rated it 4 stars

Riku Sayuj Wow, quite the detailed review. Nice work, Rajat!

message 17: by Joy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joy Don't miss CHILDREN OF DUNE. My second favorite of the series.

Hameed Superb review!

Rajat Ubhaykar Thank you!

Prabhav Desai Man this is by far the most detailed and convincing book review I've read ! Gonna start this one soon!

Rajat Ubhaykar Prabhav wrote: "Man this is by far the most detailed and convincing book review I've read ! Gonna start this one soon!"

Thanks Prabhav! Do let me know how you like it. :)

Hailey Chappell It was this review that had me read Dune and I want to say - THANK YOU. Honestly this is the best review that could ever have been written to introduce a book and I am throughly in debt to you because you have introduced me to one of my new favorite books.

Rajat Ubhaykar Hailey wrote: "It was this review that had me read Dune and I want to say - THANK YOU. Honestly this is the best review that could ever have been written to introduce a book and I am throughly in debt to you beca..."

Thank you so much Hailey! So glad my review was able to convince you to read Dune. :)

Mandy Wong A most eloquent, timeless review! I would also like to add that the female characters are also unparalleled. In so many otherwise great sci-fo works they fall flat, but in Dune, they are strong,intelligent,complex, and integral to the entire culture of the Dune world.

message 25: by Holly (new) - added it

Holly I saw the movie recently and I agree I saw some elements of Islam or that seemed inspired by it. I also got the parallel between melange and oil. Herbert is spot on with the future that could be.

back to top