Monica Edinger's Reviews > The Diary of a Young Girl

The Diary of a Young Girl by Anne Frank

by
221952
's review
Feb 17, 08

bookshelves: classic

** spoiler alert ** I'm the daughter of German Jews. My mother's family came from Berlin and my father's from Frankfurt. Yes, the same Frankfurt as the Franks. They were a very old German family --- there is still an Edinger Institut at the University begun by my great grandfather, and Edinger Strasse, and other vestiges of my family's existence there. Moreover I still have relatives in Germany, those who came from lines where people had converted.

Anyway, my father (whose father did not leave Germany and was eventually deported and killed) became an academic specialist in German politics and I spent several years of my childhood in Germany. One year was 7th grade. Before we left my father's mother gave me Anne Frank's diary and a diary. Later, upon visiting the Anne Frank House in Amsterdam and seeing her original diary, I realized that mine was just like hers. I mean, just like. Clearly my grandmother had given me one she had bought in Frankfurt and Anne's must have also been from Frankfurt, bought around the same time. They are identical other than a difference in coloring

But the diary was what woke me up to the Holocaust as well as to what it was to be a teenager. Anne's voice still echoes in my mind these many years later.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Diary of a Young Girl.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-8 of 8) (8 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Monica Edinger I do as well as the copy of Anne Frank she gave me. I wasn't much of a diarist and it is pretty painful to read it today.


message 2: by Debbie (new)

Debbie You should find some way to share your diary. People are starting to forget about the Holocaust and Hitler and they should never do this. The schools in the UK have taken it out of their curiculum because the Muslims said it was too offensive to them. Can you imaging. My heart cries when I think of what it is becoming. I read Ann Franks diary when I was 12 or 13 and the memory of it has never left me. I can't believe you only had one person respond to you in this app. I'd love to be your on-line friend. www.myspace.com/chessiewise and like Monica I say thank you for sharing. God bless


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

Monica; Send it to a publisher! If you want to. I loved this book.


Avery good review ;)


message 5: by Roxsanne (new) - added it

Roxsanne Its a good review and yes Debbie,they should never forget about the Holocaust and Hitler!!!!
And i just love Anne Frank's books they are just amazing.


message 6: by Roxsanne (new) - added it

Roxsanne And also I forgot thanks again for sharing your personal story Monica!!!!


message 7: by Shazoor (new)

Shazoor Mirza Thats a nice relation. Awesome.


message 8: by Jasmina (new)

Jasmina Mcnew Monica, thank you for sharing your story. Diaries are extra special when written in extreme and unusual s moments and situations. I kept a diary for the nine months my parents and I spent in refugee camps in Italy. Off and on I go back to it and reminisce that extreme and unusual time I lived at the age of 15 (some 48 years ago) I read and reread Anne Frank's Diary, and the sentiments of a young girl living with her family in extreme fear of extermination by Nazi savages move me deeply every single time.


back to top