Madeline's Reviews > The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie

The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie by Muriel Spark

by
111921
's review
Mar 22, 11

bookshelves: the-list
Read in March, 2011

"Miss Brodie's special girls were taken home to tea and bidden not to tell the others, they understood her private life and her feud with the headmistresss. They learned what troubles in her career Miss Brodie encountered on their behalf. 'It is for the sake of you girls - my influence, now, in the years of my prime.' This was the beginning of the Brodie set."

Six girls at a Scottish school in the 1930's form "the Brodie set", the group of favorites specifically chosen by the most interesting teacher at their school. Miss Brodie is charming, well-traveled, literate, passionate, and has an opinion on everything. The girls who form her set spend their time, from ages ten to eighteen, idolizing Miss Brodie and being influenced by her in almost every way. But all of these girls will go on to live very different lives, and one of them will betray Miss Brodie. The book follows their school careers, from ages ten onward, and shows us how one of those girls came to admire, love, and then betray her teacher. It's also an amazing character study thanks to Miss Brodie, an endlessly fascinating figure. She's funny and brilliant, but she's also manipulative and foolish. Also she's a fascist. Like, literally a fascist - she gives her girls lots of speeches about how Mussolini is improving Italy, and convinces one girl to run away to Spain to fight for Franco.

I liked this book a lot more than I expected it to - although, who doesn't love vicious backstabbing schoolgirls? Reading this book, I could see it's influence reaching all the way to modern times. It reminded me of, among other things, The Secret History, The Lake of Dead Languages, most of Margaret Atwood's books, A Great and Terrible Beauty...the list goes on. The book is about more than just a bunch of schoolgirls growing up. It's about passion, and friendship (superficial and otherwise), the disappointment of seeing your idols as mere human beings, and the constant need to belong.

"It occured to Sandy...that the Brodie set was Miss Brodie's fascisti, not to the naked eye, marching along, but all knit together for her need and in another way, marching along. That was all right, but it seemed, too, that Miss Brodie's disapproval of the Girl Guides had jealousy in it, there was an inconsistency, a fault. Perhaps the Guides were too much a rival fascisti, and Miss Brodie could not bear it. Sandy thought she might see about joining the Brownies. Then the group-fright seized her again, and it was necessary to put the idea aside, because she loved Miss Brodie."

As an ending note, has anyone seen that movie Cracks that came out recently? I need some more vicious schoolgirl antics in my life, and I was wondering if it was worth seeing. Thoughts?

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie.
sign in »

Reading Progress

03/21/2011 page 109
68.0% ""Give me a girl at an impressionable age, and she is mine for life." Damn, Miss Brodie, you scary!"

Comments (showing 1-9 of 9) (9 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Kaethe There are so many stories about teachers in boys' schools who are inspiring and magnificent, so I think I just kind of hate that Brodie is inspiring and wrong about everything. To me it's a bitchy book that devolves into a cat-fight over the only eligible male around. Nonetheless, I enjoyed your review for a different perspective.


Madeline But I think the book deserves credit for being truthful - the sad fact is, the people that we idolize (especially when we're growing up) rarely live up to our elevated opinions of them. I love The Dead Poets Society as much as the next girl, but I think Miss Brodie is more realistic as a character because even though she's so inspiring, she's also a real human being with flaws.

And I didn't think the point of the book was that it was a cat fight over Mr. Lloyd. Instead, Sandy realized that Miss Brodie was using her girls as stand-ins for herself, and manipulating everyone to serve her own agenda. Sandy got tired of Miss Brodie having so much power over everyone and wanted to put a stop to it. Mr. Lloyd was only the catalyst.


Kaethe You're right about the people we idolize when young. It's just that Brodie's flaws are so HUGE that she doesn't feel realistic to me; she feels like a strawwoman.

Now it's been twenty years since I read it, but I thought Sandy was just as manipulative as Brodie. I recall it as Sandy seducing Lloyd, which squicks me out.


Madeline I don't think Sandy seduced him, exactly. She discovered when she was fifteen that if she looked at him a certain way he would kiss her (and then tell her she was ugly - nice), and then when she was eighteen she tried it again. Miss Brodie always intended for one of her girls to become Lloyd's lover, so Sandy figured it might as well be her.


Kaethe Thanks, I didn't remember the details. So, Lloyd behaves inappropriately with a student and the two females are the ones responsible? Smells like rape apologism to me.


Madeline Whoa, nobody's saying anything about rape. Sandy and Lloyd's relationship occurred when she was eighteen and was completely consensual. If anyone's at fault it's Miss Brodie, for encouraging an underage girl to have an affair with an older man. It's never clearly stated in the book whether she intends this to happen while the girl is underage or not, but the book seems to hint that she doesn't really care.


Kaethe No, sorry, I know the book doesn't say anything about rape. But Lloyd kissing her when she's fifteen: given their later sexual relationship that looks a little like grooming. Brodie's encouragement of the girls looks like grooming too. And I know it was set in a different time. But the whole thing really squicks me out.


Madeline Oh, Brodie's definitely grooming the girls. I think there are even specific lines in the book that literally say, "Miss Brodie was preparing Rose to be Mr. Lloyd's lover." That's why she's so creepy: she has these very specific plans for her favorite girls, and because she's so charismatic and interesting they manage to convince themselves (at least for a while) that they genuinely want what Brodie decides for them.


Kaethe Oh, good. After posting that yesterday I spent the rest of the evening wondering if I was imagining things.

Seriously though: how weird is that? I mean, it's one thing for a teacher to want to mold the creme de la creme, and make clever young adults. But creating the perfect lover for someone else is really strange.


back to top