Marvin's Reviews > The Elegant Universe: Superstrings, Hidden Dimensions, and the Quest for the Ultimate Theory
The Elegant Universe: Superstrings, Hidden Dimensions, and the Quest for the Ultimate Theory
by Brian Greene

Do I understand string theory? Not sure.
Do I understand M theory? A little bit but don't ask for any algebraic reasoning.
Do I know exactly what a Calabi-Yau is? Not really but I think they look a little like the hair balls from my cat.
This is the second time I've equated quantum physics and all its detours to a hair-ball. That's because I can study a hair ball and still have no idea what it is for and why they exist. String Theory and the elusive TOE is in the same category. I could go on my entire life not knowing about them but now that I do, I need to know why. Newton, Einstein, Feynman, Hawking, and my cat can't all be right. Or can they?
That is essentially the dilemma of string theory and the book. Greene does a great job of putting everything in layman's term but there is a point which he must exceed the intellectual ionosphere and soar into the incalculable. I really like this type of book. The challenge is the fun. But rest assured when the scientists get their act together and write an Idiot's guide to The Unified Theory Of Everything, I'll be the first in line.
P. S. Hair balls and string theories have something else in common. Once you tore one apart, you can never get your hands clean.
by Brian Greene

Do I understand string theory? Not sure.
Do I understand M theory? A little bit but don't ask for any algebraic reasoning.
Do I know exactly what a Calabi-Yau is? Not really but I think they look a little like the hair balls from my cat.
This is the second time I've equated quantum physics and all its detours to a hair-ball. That's because I can study a hair ball and still have no idea what it is for and why they exist. String Theory and the elusive TOE is in the same category. I could go on my entire life not knowing about them but now that I do, I need to know why. Newton, Einstein, Feynman, Hawking, and my cat can't all be right. Or can they?
That is essentially the dilemma of string theory and the book. Greene does a great job of putting everything in layman's term but there is a point which he must exceed the intellectual ionosphere and soar into the incalculable. I really like this type of book. The challenge is the fun. But rest assured when the scientists get their act together and write an Idiot's guide to The Unified Theory Of Everything, I'll be the first in line.
P. S. Hair balls and string theories have something else in common. Once you tore one apart, you can never get your hands clean.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Elegant Universe.
sign in »
Reading Progress
Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Traveller
(new)
Sep 10, 2012 02:12am
Ah, the eternal hairball.. i too, have had a brush with that existentially puzzling entity.
reply
|
flag
*
So, we are both reading the same book. Your review is much more technical than mine, with far more insight. I'm re-reading the book to better "get" his following book, basically using it as a reference guide while reading "The Fabric of the Cosmos."Will you follow through with that one?
~jessThe Fabric of the Cosmos: Space, Time, and the Texture of Reality
My review is technical? That's a compliment I never expected! Thank you.I placed Fabric of the Cosmos on my reading list. Thanks for letting me know about it.
Yes, yes, your review is hilariously technical. I can picture a college professor standing up in front of his students and after you gave that presentation, they would be like, (while laughing) "Oh, I thought I understood that, but I was wrong. This dude must really know what he's talking about. He knows that it makes ABSOLUTELY VERY LITTLE SENSE...but we'll pretend to agree with the other dude who wrote the book anyway."And of course, pinning up that kitten photo next to your presentation board would be essential!
Seriously, I am happy you know about Fabric of the Cosmos. Most don't realize that he followed Elegant up with another book. Enjoy!
