Brittany (finally graduated and can once again read for fun)'s Reviews > City of Ashes

City of Ashes by Cassandra Clare
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
854494
's review
Mar 27, 11

bookshelves: 2011, ya-my-first-love
Read from March 09 to 24, 2011

Hmmm, well I still don't get what all the hype is about, but I will say City of Ashes was a vast improvement over City of Bones. The good news is that in this latest imstallment we didn't have to put up with the awful world-building. It wasn't a straight Q&A which was better. What bothers me most is that I feel like Clare gets lost in her characters without really having the ability to progress the plot. Yes, getting to know your characters is important... but let's love it along. There is no reason for her books being so long. They could be easily cut in half. So again I ask... where is the editor?

I also thought the story itself was better. I liked the ending so much more. What I fail to get is the continuous way in which Clare telegraphs what is going to happen. It's not foreshadowing, it basically giving the whole thing away before you even know why something has to end the way it does. Foreshadowing is one thing, this is just a little too obvious.

Will I read City of Glass? Yes because I'm finally getting attached to the characters. Magnus Bane is quite intriguing and I loved watching him and Alec towards the end. Also Jace is growing on me because I really enjoy his no-nonsense attitude and I've come to respect it. Even if he is being a pain most of the time. Luke is the glue that is holding everyone together and Simon... well Simon is that tragic loveable character you can't help but fall in love with because he is loyal to our protag to a fault, and he wouldn't want it any other way.

There's nothing new or groundbreaking about this story, it follows a pretty common story arc, the writing is only so-so, but it is improving. But I like the characters and they alone are why I continue to read.

Update: just for the sake of seeing exactly how predictable these books are I'm going to write down what I think will happen. I haven't read a single page in City of Glass, not even the cover with the synopsis... That being said, here are my predictions...

1) Jace is the son of the Inquisitor's friend who died when she was 8 months prego, either that or the son of the Inquisitor herself. I don't know how or why, but Jace and Clary have to have a way to be together and this is the solution.
2) It's inevitable... Jace and Clary will be able to be together. Somehow, someway we all know it's going to happen even if the above prediction turns out to be completely wrong
3) Valentine is going to go after a 3rd Mortal Instrument. It's the rule of 3 people...
4) Dare I say sparks will fly between Simon and Maia... I mean the BBF deserves his HEA too right? I mean vampires, werewolves... who cares really. If they can make it work in Twilight surely they can make it work here.
5) Clary's mom is going to wake and eventually have to face Valentine
6) Luke is going to do one of 2 things either 1) sacrifice his life so either Clary or her mother will live, or 2) finally come clean to Clary's mom about how much he loves her and they get a weird and warped HEA too.
7) Magnus Bane will still stand out as the most intriguing character of the book.
8) oh... and the crew are finally going to have to make the trip to Idris.

Okay, there you have it. We'll see how it all goes. I'm hoping for surprises... really I am. I want to be wrong, about some things.
4 likes · likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read City of Ashes.
sign in »

Reading Progress

03/19/2011 page 114
25.0%
show 1 hidden update…

Comments (showing 1-9 of 9) (9 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Heidi *Listen. I'll just keep talking anyway. * Still skipping this series. Books without editors drive me insane!


Carmel Ha ha love your review Brittany. just one thing, I think in the first line you meant to write City of Ashes, no biggie, just someone else might get confused. I love your attempts at predictions for COG:)


Brittany (finally graduated and can once again read for fun) Thanks... I changed it.

We'll see what happens. I know there are 6 books in series, but I got the feeling there was a cut off after the first 3 and books 4-6 were just an extension. If that's not the case those are series predictions in general. I don't think there will be this big final showdown until the very end. so... book #6?


Catie The sad thing is, I don't even remember if a lot of those predictions are right or not!! I've completely forgotten the whole series.


Brittany (finally graduated and can once again read for fun) Catie, I'll let you know. It make be a little bit before I can read it because of other books on the list, but I'll probably finish it within a month or two.


Thalia I think this series is a hit or miss for most people. The people who've read it and liked it absolutely LOVE it, like I do. Then there are people who just don't care. There isn't really a, "Eh, well, I liked it sort of," with TMI.

I will tell you you're right about a couple of your predictions, but I don't think the ones you're most confident in are the ones you got right. As for #7; that's all matter of opinion, so I can't say right or wrong. Magnus wasn't my favorite; just a fun sideliner for me.

As for the length; I kind of wish they'd been longer! For me, getting to know the character and their emotions is HUGE for me; I simply can't love a story if an author doesn't focus on that. Especially in a tragedy-type like TMI. So I'll have to diagree with you about the length/editor thing, because I just adore lengthy stories that focus a lot on character emotion and building things.

PS - don't forget about Isabelle! She's a Simon-pairing contender, by far.


Brittany (finally graduated and can once again read for fun) I'm not surprised we disagree. I think you are absolutely entitled to your opinion. Tons of people really LOVE the series. I'm not one of them. But it's good enough to keep me reading.

As to my predictions, I think #2 and #8 are the ones I'm most confident about. We'll see. The book is currently in my possession and I'm planning to start it soon.

Ah yes, Isabelle. But she's all into the fae. Besides, I thought they did the whole Simon/Isabelle thing in Book #1? Either way, you're the one who has actually read them. I bow to your wisdom.

I'll be sure to let you know what I think. Thanks for the input!!


Thalia Oh well; I disregarded 2 & 8 because just by reading the cover of CoG you find out they go to Idris. 2 because happily ever afters just need to happen, hahaha.

Isabelle is a fickle girl; I always did like her better than Maia though; not sure why, hahaha. Anyway, even in the fourth book there's still no definite as to who it'll be so... D:


Brittany (finally graduated and can once again read for fun) oh... I haven't even read the inside cover. I usually don't, especially in series books. I hate spoilers.


back to top