Annalisa's Reviews > Plainsong
Plainsong
by Kent Haruf
by Kent Haruf
I get the point of the novel: to give a glimpse of small town life without extravagance. Beauty in simplicity. But I felt more depressed then touched by Haruf's picture of a whole town of people lonely in their own selfish wandering aimlessly without direction. I didn't like any characters in the book, except for maybe the boys who weren't old enough to yet become bitter, mean, and immoral. Nobody else in the book cared about anyone else as they focused on their small lives. Nobody did anything for another person unless thrust upon them. Every last one of them was swallowed up by an environment that dampened motivation, optimism, love until the whole town was just going through the motions worried only about how daily life and others were affecting them. Nobody made me care what became of them and I did not relate to a single one of them. I understand that just plain people is the point, but I suppose my issue is that I disagree with Haruf's interpretation of life. All people have redeeming qualities and I have found that most people are likable. These people were not. It saddened me that someone would think that empty souls is what ordinary life is all about. I wanted to feel something for anyone, anything in the book, but I did not. I didn't learn anything nor was I left with any lingering sensation or thought and it wasn't the type of book that was just an enjoyable read and I could get caught up in the story. I suppose that's the thing with art is that a piece of work that will touch one person is just a collection of strokes to another and this was not a piece of art that grabbed by attention.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Plainsong.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-6 of 6) (6 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jeana
(new)
-
rated it 2 stars
Feb 09, 2009 06:12pm
We read this in our book club a while back.
reply
|
flag
*
I agree that I didn't care about any of the characters. As I was reading it, I couldn't believe this was an award-winning book. I didn't particularly care for the language/wording the author uses.
I really loved this book! I think it shows how people can get stuck in their routines and be very resistant to change. But when change is thrust upon them they can rise to the occasion. I especially like the McPheron brothers. Isn't it funny and wonderful how different everyone's perspective is?
I think you missed the point this story is about the healing power of love. The story lays out the bleak everyday lives of this small town group. The pregnant 17 year old is thrown out by her mother. Her teacher helps her find a home with two elderly, unmarried farming brothers. They take her in and protect her and her baby despite the fact that they barely communicate with the outside world. In fact, i'd call then recluses. Here is the beauty of the story. Their generosity allows them to make a place for her. They are even a little afraid of her, but they respect her. They grow to love her and she them. That love heals them all.

