Emily May's Reviews > On the Jellicoe Road

On the Jellicoe Road by Melina Marchetta

by
4622890
's review
Mar 30, 12

bookshelves: ya-na, 2011, fave-ya, contemporary
Recommended to Emily May by: Tatiana
Read from August 30 to September 01, 2011



There's a monster in my mirror with puffy bloodshot eyes because she stayed up most of the night, crying and reading On the Jellicoe Road. But it was worth it.

Melina Marchetta never fails to remind me why she is one of my favourite authors and, in my opinion, this is the best of her books I've read so far. It's very difficult to put into words how I feel about On the Jellicoe Road, all I can say is that my heart has been ripped out and shredded, my throat has sealed up with emotion and when I finally get some sleep, I get the feeling I'll probably dream about Jonah Griggs.

The story is of Taylor Markham, a girl who was abandoned by her mother as a young child and now resides in a boarding school for kids who are troubled, neglected or criminally inclined, her closest friend and mentor being Hannah, a woman who lives on the edge of the school grounds. Taylor is elected as a leader in the territory war games played by her school with the Townies (locals) and Cadets. She tries to balance this responsibility with her own worries about Hannah's sudden disappearance and her belief that it is connected to her own mother. On top of that is Jonah Griggs, one of the Cadets and a boy from her past, who knows her a little too much for comfort.

The biggest concern of mine is that the intended young adult audience may not fully appreciate Melina Marchetta, I know she's somewhat of a celebrity here on goodreads but she's hardly a household name... and it irks me. I want to tell everyone to read this, scream praise from rooftops, and glare with disapproval at the teens in my local library until they drop Halo and pick up these fantastic works of fiction. But it makes me sad that Melina Marchetta is probably too sophisticated a writer for the Twilight generation.

Saving Francesca, The Piper's Son, On the Jellicoe Road... every book I read seems better than the last. She creates moods that permeate the entire book so even the most simplistic scenes or conversations become deeply emotional, and Melina Marchetta plays my emotions like Jimi Hendrix played guitar. I can't think of a single book that has had me choked up more often than this one.

And Jonah Griggs, you stole my heart. Though I do think Melina Marchetta could quite easily persuade me to fall in love with a goldfish.

Basically this book is everything... beautiful, powerful, tragic without being melodramatic, and I know this wonderfully sad story will stay with me for a very long time.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read On the Jellicoe Road.
sign in »

Quotes Emily May Liked

Melina Marchetta
“What do you want from me?" he asks.
What I want from every person in my life, I want to tell him.
More.”
Melina Marchetta, Jellicoe Road


Reading Progress

08/31/2011 page 156
52.0% "Yeah, you were all right, this book is fantastic. Except I feel like my guts have been torn out and are currently being used as a volleyball." 5 comments
09/01/2011 page 156
52.0% ""What do you want from me?" he asks. What I want from every person in my life, I want to tell him. More." 10 comments
show 1 hidden update…

Comments (showing 1-37 of 37) (37 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Tatiana You haven't read it yet, Emily? I am not keeping an eye on you well enough:)


Emily May LOL Fine, I'll read it next. In fact, I'll mark it as 'currently reading' now :)


Alyssa One of your best reviews. I'm glad you loved it, too. This book is why I don't give out 5 stars as easily anymore and it makes me really happy that people are reading it. (And you can read my favourite quote now) :P


Emily May Thank you:) and it was the first thing I did when I finished it! You're right, that quote is a heartbreaker.


Tatiana It is amazing that everyone who ever reads MM becomes so overprotective of her and enraged on her behalf because she is not more famous:)


Cory Tatiana wrote: "It is amazing that everyone who ever reads MM becomes so overprotective of her and enraged on her behalf because she is not more famous:)"

I've noticed that a lot. I like her. I love her debut. But I can't get into her other books. There are certain parts that I adore in Jellicoe, Francesca, and Piper's Son, but they aren't for me.


Trinity Great review Emily!
I think you're right about the Twilight teens, it's a sad sad thing.


karen hooray for marchetta!


Jasprit Awesome review Emily, you summed up how much I love this book perfectly :) lol at glaring at teens reading Halo!


Emily May Thank you everyone! :)
and Tatiana, that is so true.


Kayleigh {K-Books} Emily, I love your review and can't wait to read it now =)


Emily May Thanks Kay! Hope you like it (I'm sure you will) :D


Kayleigh {K-Books} I'll get to it eventually I have like 5 books on loan at the minute that i need to read lol


message 14: by Molly (new) - added it

Molly Talbert I just got this on my Kindle, since I've seen such great things about it on GRs. This will be my first time with this author! Great review!


Emily May Thanks Molly! This is such a great book, hope you enjoy it too :)


Hassan Thanks Emily! your review made me read this book and its the Best book I read in long time.


Emily May That's great, Hassan! I'm really glad you liked it, you should definitely try reading some of Melina Marchetta's other books :)


Hassan surely I'll be checking her books ..any recommendations.


Emily May All of them! But first I'd go for Saving Francesca and the sequel which is even better - The Piper's Son.


Hassan Thanks!


Hassan I had already put the Piper's Son on my to-read list but I didnt knew that it was a squeal of Saving Francesca.


Emily May It would still make sense by itself, but it's the story of one of the characters a few years later and I think it's more meaningful if you read them in order.


Olivia--Porcrastinator Extraordinaire I love your review, but I am a part of the Twilight generation, and I hate to admit it, but Twilight got me into YA, and I ADORE Marchetta. Froi is currently one of my favorite books!


Emily May Thanks Olivia! And if Twilight led you to Melina Marchetta then it looks like Meyer may be doing the world a service afterall :)


☆Jessie☆  (Ageless Pages Reviews) "Melina Marchetta plays my emotions like Jimi Hendrix played guitar." THIS A THOUSAND TIMES.

I loved this book so much I am scared to read her earlier contemporary ya novels in case they won't live up to this one.


Emily May Don't worry, Jessie, Marchetta always delivers :)


☆Jessie☆  (Ageless Pages Reviews) I quoted your line in my review, with a link back to here, if that's ok! If it's not, just let me know and I will delete it. I just thought it was a perfect description :)


Emily May No, I'm flattered :) Haha, thank you!


Arielle This review is perfect - it pretty much sums up all my feelings about the book. It's been a few months since I've read it, and some of it is stating to fade from memory but what's left is that feeling of raw emotion that Marchetta somehow lets the reader experience during it - I think I'm going to have to re-read it! Also, interesting to find that Piper's Son was a sequel (to Saving Francesca), absolutely must read it now too. =)


karen oh my god - that book is the best. the best, seriously.


Emily May Thanks Arielle :)
I really do think all Marchetta's novels are worth reading, she is one of those rare authors that can jump from genre to genre and still deliver something extraordinary. I wasn't a fan of the fantasy genre before I read Finnikin of the Rock.


✌ Kaye ♡ I totally agree with everything in your review! I get so drawn into the world she creates. My feelings are on overload. Mind blown. Always! I don't think I can say that about any other author.

I wonder what this would have done to me if I actually read this in high school.


Ronyell Awesome review Emily! I loved this book too and I really loved Jonah Griggs!


Emily May Thank you and oh yes, I do miss Jonah :'(


Ronyell Emily wrote: "Thank you and oh yes, I do miss Jonah :'("

You're welcome!


message 36: by Isabel (new) - added it

Isabel I started this book with high hopes, and a hundred pages in, I got discouraged. I'm picking it up again because I seem to agree with every one of your reviews. Thanks in advance haha :)


Emily May Thanks Isabel :) I hope you like it more this time around, but I also realise that Marchetta can be a touch on the slow side for some readers.


back to top