Ian Graye's Reviews > Norwegian Wood

Norwegian Wood by Haruki Murakami

by
5022264
's review
Dec 22, 11

bookshelves: read-2011, reviews, mura-karmic-wonder-land, reviews-5-stars, nippon
Read from September 25 to October 03, 2011

Twenty Revolutions

My most feared birthday was my 20th.

For people older than me, the most significant birthday was their 21st.

But when the age of legal adulthood was reduced to 18, turning 21 no longer had the same significance it once had.

Before then, you could be conscripted into the armed forces at 18, but you could not drink alcohol until you turned 21.

So, if you were old enough to die for your country, surely you were old enough to have a drink?

Either way, turning 20 for me meant that I had ceased to be a teenager, a group of people linked only by the fact that their age ended in the suffix “-teen”, but still it felt special not belonging to the grown up crowd.

On the other side of 20, you emerge from university (if you’ve been lucky enough to go there) and dive straight into full-time employment, maturity, responsibility, expectations and adulthood.

Suddenly, things are all a lot more serious, more permanent, less experimental, or this is how it seems.

Japanese-Style

Haruki Murakami writes about the Japanese experience in “Norwegian Wood”.

It’s set in the years 1968 to 1970, so it mightn’t be the same now.

However, it seems that the transition into adulthood is more demanding, more stressful.

It also seems that there are more casualties, more teenagers fail to make the transition and end up committing suicide.

Murakami writes about the transition almost like it’s a game of snakes and ladders.

You can climb into the future, success and normality, or you can slide into darkness, failure and death.

Well, Well

Murakami’s protagonist, Toru Watanabe, pictures the darkness as a well-like abyss early in the novel when he recounts the events of a day he spent with the girl he longs for, Naoko.

“I can describe the well in minute detail. It lay precisely on the border where the meadow ended and the woods began – a dark opening in the earth a yard across, hidden by grass. Nothing marked its perimeter – no fence, no stone curb (at least not one that rose above ground level). It was nothing but a hole, a wide-open mouth…You could lean over the edge and peer down to see nothing. All I knew about the well was its frightening depth. It was deep beyond measuring, and crammed full of darkness, as if all the world’s darknesses had been boiled down to their ultimate density.”

As a teenager, Toru’s life had been fairly innocuous, he had been playing in a meadow compared with the thicket that awaited him in the future.

But first he had to avoid the well in making the transition.

As his friend Reiko says in another context:

“She and I were bound together at the border between life and death.”

There is a sense in which we have to negotiate the boundaries as safely as we can, to cross the border and close the gap.

If we are lucky, we can do it together.

Unfortunately, not everybody is destined to make it into the forest and out the other side.

Vanishing Act

The overwhelming feel of reading “Norwegian Wood” is one of being in a blank, dream-like, ethereal world.

Although Murakami describes people, surroundings and objects with precision, it all seems other worldly, as if everybody lives and breathes in a world beyond this world.

There is a sense that at any moment, it could all disappear, that it might all just be part of some cosmic vanishing act.

Even if we make it through, we might turn around and discover that some of our friends haven’t been so lucky.

Talking about My Generation

Most of the action in the novel is dialogue, the characters talking about themselves and their relationships.

They are preoccupied with themselves, introspective and self-centred.

They converse, they play folk songs on the guitar, they write letters that are later burned.

Nobody makes anything that will last, other than perhaps themselves and the relationships that are able to survive into adulthood.

They struggle for permanence, when everything else around them is ephemeral.

Even their memories fade.

In the “frightful silence” of the forest, Naoko asks Toru:

“I want you always to remember me. Will you remember that I existed, and that I stood next to you here like this?”

Of course, he responds that he will, although 20 years later, he finds that his memory “has grown increasingly dim.”

“What if I’ve forgotten the most important thing? What if somewhere inside me there is a dark limbo where all the truly important memories are heaped and slowly turning into mud?...the thought fills me with an almost unbearable sorrow.”

To which he adds, “Because Naoko never loved me.”

“Norwegian Wood”

The Beatles song features throughout the novel.

It’s a favourite of Naoko’s and Reiko plays it frequently on her guitar.

For much of the novel, the lyrics could describe Toru’s relationship with Naoko and his other love interest, Midori:

“I once had a girl, or should I say, she once had me.”

There is a sense of sadness in the sexual subject matter of this novel, almost as if it's been written in a minor key.

Reiko sums up the Beatles pretty accurately, “Those guys sure knew something about the sadness of life,” she says, before adding, “and gentleness”, almost as an afterthought.

She Never Loved Me

I love all of this talk of love and longing and loss and loneliness and labyrinths (all the “L” words).

Not everybody feels the same, though.

You should have heard my wife, F.M. Sushi, when she noticed my tears and stole a look at what I was reading.

“Why don’t these people just stop moaning and get a life. Can’t they just grow up, for chrissake. Everybody’s responsible for their own orgasm.”

Then she flicked the book back at me across the room, adding defiantly (and defeating my prospects that night in one fell swoop), “Especially you.”

I pick up the book, find my place and resume reading where I left off (page 10), equally defiantly, and aloud...“Because Naoko never loved me.”

My wife turns her back on me as I snicker at her lack of understanding of my gentle side.

Growing Up (How Strange the Change from Minor to Major)

Still, a few hundred pages later, I am stunned by her prescience.

Toru grows up in Murakami’s delicate hands.

He has to stop dreaming, he has to live in the present, he has to embrace the now that is in front of him, he has to love the one he’s with.

He has to distance himself from the past, so that it becomes just a lingering memory.

Reiko tells him:

“You’re all grown up now, so you have to take responsibility for your choices. Otherwise, you ruin everything.”

Midori (who he has ummed and ahhed about) tells him:

“...you, well, you’re special to me. When I’m with you I feel something is just right. I believe in you. I like you. I don’t want to let you go.”

In the pouring rain, she reveals to Toru she has broken up with the boyfriend that has prevented her from committing to him.

“Why?” he asks.

“Are you crazy?” she screams. “You know the English subjunctive, you understand trigonometry, you can read Marx, and you don’t know the answer to something as simple as that?

Then in a scene that could come straight out of "Casablanca", she says:

“Drop the damn umbrella and wrap both your arms around me – hard!”

How did F.M. Sushi know this would happen?

That Toru would grow up and get a girl, not just any girl?

That they would fall in love and not into a deep, dark well.

Still I prefer Murakami’s way of telling the story.

It always comes as a surprise the way he tells it, the change from minor to major.

What would my wife know of these things?

What I find mysterious, she finds obvious.

When I find the harbour hard to fathom, she appears to walk on water.

If you put her in a labyrinth, she would always find her way out.

Whereas sometimes I prefer to hang around and enjoy the experience of being down in the rabbit hole.

Mystified. Confused. Excited.

At least for a little wile.

Original Review: October 3, 2011



Audio Recording of My Review

Bird Brian once initiated a Big Audio Project, where Good Readers record and publish their reviews. Unfortunately, BB deleted his page after the amazon acquisition of GR.

My recording of this review was my first contribution. You can find it on SoundCloud here:

http://soundcloud.com/inksterpop/soun...


Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Norwegian Wood.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-50 of 102) (102 new)


message 1: by K.D. (new) - added it

K.D. Oliveros Yey! This will be my next Murakami. Nice to see those stars!


Praj Excellent review, Ian.


Aylin Oh good. Really liked Wind Up Bird Chronicle.


message 4: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Thanks all.

I meant to say that I re-read this in preparation for 1Q84 (which comes out on 25 October).

I will re-read and review them all. I also loved Wind Up Bird Chronicle.


message 5: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye There are a couple of times when Murakami uses the expression "On Sundays, I didn't wind my spring" (p 262) and "I don't wind my spring on Sundays" (p 287).

This post is a reminder to follow up this expression and see whether it is a translation of a common Japanese phrase.

Also, check whether it appears in the later work, "The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle".


Aylin Wind Up Bird- it was mentioned a number of times that the the wind up bird wound the spring of their world- don't recollect the exact wording. Would be interesting to know if that arose from a Japanese phrase and/or myth.


message 7: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Thanks, Aylin.

I'm interested in forming a Discussion Group for 1Q84, if you and anyone else are interested.


Stephen M We've discussed this before, but I am most certainly interested.


message 9: by mark (new)

mark monday awesome review, Ian.


message 10: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Thanks, Mark.


Magdelanye Ian, I was with you all the way until the last line, which acted as a bit of a spoiler for me, of the review (not the book, which I quite loved tho its not my fave)

Apparantly,if you could question what your wife might know of things, you dont know your wife.


message 12: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye M, I was hoping that you would infer from the first part of the review that I had remained immature, and that my questioning of my wife was the teenager questioning the adult.


message 13: by Magdelanye (last edited Oct 05, 2011 03:18am) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Magdelanye sounds convoluted.
she must be very patient and understanding

cripes, she must love you!


message 14: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Patient? Understanding?

What would a teenager know of these things?


message 15: by Jim (new)

Jim Ian wrote: "Patient? Understanding?

What would a teenager know of these things?"


Exactly!

Mind the well, little one...


message 16: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Jim wrote: "Mind the well, little one..."

Thanks, Jim.

People don't realise how difficult it is being a fifty-something teenager.


Magdelanye Laurie Brown, on the signal last night had this to say about growing up. Its not just that you get to make your own decisions about stuff, the sure sign is that you've developed some patience and are capable of deferred gratification. And then she played some wicked music.
http://www.cbc.ca/radio2/thesignal/

Growing up has such a bad rep I never wanted to do it, but at some point I became intruiged by the possibilities. It does not have to mean forgetting about all the playful joys of life, or conforming, or ceasing to resist the machine. It means taking complete charge of my life, doing something instead of just whining about things or expecting somebody else to fix it.


message 18: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Nicely said, M.

I hope we can all grow up, while staying forever young.

I just want the right to be a little immature as well.


message 19: by Jim (new)

Jim Ian wrote: "Nicely said, M.

I hope we can all grow up, while staying forever young.

I just want the right to be a little immature as well."


You want to have your cake, and throw it on the floor as well?!? LOL!

Taking charge, playing, conforming/not conforming, whining/taking responsibility - it's a mix of just being human. Sometimes we're strong, sometimes we're not. The important thing is to know yourself, acknowledge your ups and downs, and hopefully have a loving partner around to help you mop up the cake!


message 20: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Jim wrote: "The important thing is to know yourself, acknowledge your ups and downs, and hopefully have a loving partner around to help you mop up the cake! "

Mine mops up the cakes and the ale.


message 21: by Jim (new)

Jim Ian wrote: "Jim wrote: "The important thing is to know yourself, acknowledge your ups and downs, and hopefully have a loving partner around to help you mop up the cake! "

Mine mops up the cakes and the ale."


You spill your ale??! Now that's just going too far!


message 22: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Jim wrote: "You spill your ale??! Now that's just going too far!"

That was clumsy of me.

I meant that the wifely one is there with her elbow on the bar, imbibing too.

Her approach is "more hops, less mops, that's what we pay a cleaner for".

I never, ever spill (I respect the brewer's art too much).


message 23: by Jim (new)

Jim Ian wrote: "Jim wrote: "You spill your ale??! Now that's just going too far!"

That was clumsy of me.

I meant that the wifely one is there with her elbow on the bar, imbibing too.

Her approach is "more hops..."


Separated by a common language!

The couple that drinks together, stays together.


message 24: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Share a bottle, share a bed!


message 25: by Magdelanye (last edited Oct 07, 2011 01:33am) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Magdelanye hey guys,taking your masculine reasoning to its logical extent,is that how I have ended up single, I just dont drink enough ale?

http://www.cbc.ca/radio2/assets_c/201...


message 26: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Magdelanye wrote: "hey guys,taking your masculine reasoning to its logical extent,is that how I have ended up single, I just dont drink enough ale?"

Nah, I suspect you just spill more than you drink ;)


Magdelanye at least it doesnt take much to get me started
and I mop up after myself :)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2j2uX...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dd6IbU...


message 28: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Who were those masked men?


Magdelanye I think the whole thing is a metaphor, its the only way to take it. The masked men must be all those anonymous corporation types that trap us in their system and cut away at our angelic being, infecting us with the same lusts and greeds and willingness to perpetrate the same kind of crimes against human life and liberty.


message 30: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye F.M Sushi and I saw the film yesterday.

Her first reaction was that, "if the book is like that, I don't want to read it".

Although I don't suspect that she will read it anyway, I tried to reassure her that the book was not as relentlessly dark as the film.

It is beautiful, but it is dark.

I bring to any Murakami enterprise a long history of reading and loving his work.

I read it from within a supportive web of dreaminess and absurdity and poignancy and humour.

Possibly, I import some of these things where they are not, because they have been elsewhere.

However, I felt that the film stripped out much of this.

I think it's because film necessarily involves images of the people (and the landscapes) you have been reading about.

Everything is more concrete, and the imagination is less involved in the creation of the characters and their temperaments.

It's a beautiful film, it's loving and responsible in its relationship with the book, but it's dark.

It misses out things that might have explained the narrative better (particularly in the way it deals with [arguably] secondary characters like Reiko, Hatsumi and Toru's male friends).

It forces you to make leaps in order to keep up, but F.M. Sushi didn't seem to mind after a while.

When I wrote my review, I had doubts about whether Toru really did get the girl Midori at the end.

I still do, but the film suggests that he did, because you can see Midori's reactions to their phone call.

In the book, you couldn't.

Also, the book starts 20 years later with Toru flying into Germany.

He is alone, and the musak version of "Norwegian Wood" on the plane prompts his reminiscences.

There is no hint that Midori is still in his life, except as a part of his retrospection.


Lori (Hellian) "People don't realise how difficult it is being a fifty-something teenager."

That sums it up. A line imminently worth stealing!

I never knew this was a film. This book is one of Murakami's finest.


message 32: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Thanks, Lori.

The film has been on the festival circuit and was released here this week.

The director is the Vietnamese director of "The Scent of the Green Papaya", Anh Hung Tran.

http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/norwe...

I would love to be able to read your review one day.

Some books just have to be re-read, for this purpose only (i.e., the GR review)


message 33: by Sue (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sue Growing up is pretty much over rated. That being said my 22 year old is still safely under my protective wing from the over rated world she treads lightl into occasionally and my 18 year old would rather not tread at all from his cozy room with a view of his 26"computer monitor :-)


message 34: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye I couldn't wait to move out, but I get the feeling that it will break our hearts when our daughters (16 and 13) eventually move out, as if it was some kind of rejection.


message 35: by Sue (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sue Trouble is you want to push them with on hand and let them fall to the ground hopefully flying with their strong wings while you grab them by the scuff of the neck knowing full well there is no fairy tail happy ending with white horse, prince etc awaiting them *sigh*


message 36: by Steve (new)

Steve After reading your review, I'm especially interested in reading this one. I may have to be out of my wife's view while doing it, though, to avoid the kind of reaction F.M. Sushi had.


message 37: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye It's a good place to start, Steve. I recently reread NW and South of the Border in that order.

I'm going to re-read some others next year, especially Wind-Up Bird Chronicle.


message 38: by Jim (new)

Jim Ian wrote: "It's a good place to start, Steve. I recently reread NW and South of the Border in that order.

I'm going to re-read some others next year, especially Wind-Up Bird Chronicle."


Hi Ian,

If you're interested, we're reading WUBC starting Nov. 15th with the group "Ambiclassics"

http://www.goodreads.com/group/show/4...

If you have the time/inclination, feel free to drop by and join the discussion. This will be my first Murakami and I'm looking forward to it.


message 39: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Thanks, Jim, I've just joined.


message 40: by Ian (last edited Nov 17, 2011 11:50am) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye I've added a section at the bottom of my review about my contribution to Bird Brian's Big Audio Project.

Make sure you check out the reviews (and return from time to time).


message 41: by Mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

Mark what a fantastic review. I read this book a year or so ago and you have made it make sense in a way I could not manage on my tod so thanks very much


message 42: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Thanks, Mark. I like venturing into his Murakarmic Wonderland and having a good squiz. I'm a third of the way into the big one right now.


Mel (who is deeply in love with Hal) Lovely review.

Enjoyed it nearly as much as the book itself!

:)


message 44: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Thanks, Mel.

I'll re-read the rest of his books, so I can review them.

Are you going to review it?


Mel (who is deeply in love with Hal) No-you pretty much said everything I felt-but managed to convey it more eloquently! I'm the kind of reviewer who basically calls a book "amazing" or "ridiculously bad" and can't elaborate much further than that without falling into a rambling rant.

Thank God there are more sophisticated readers (e.g. YOU) who manage to compose a response to a text which is a hundred times more likely to urge another potential reader to crack open the spine..

And..I also read your review of Murakami's other book, 1Q84, and guess what? Those haikus of yours swayed my decision to pick that one up the next chance I get it..maybe I'll drop in a haiku of my own once I'm finished...

*cue threatening music*

You've been warned! My haiku-writing skills are infantile at best.

:)


message 46: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Haiku very much, Mel.

If I can't urge you to write, I'll have to settle for urging you to read ;)

You've made a good start on the haikus:

Those haikus of yours
Swayed my decision to read
1Q84


Mel (who is deeply in love with Hal) Awesome. You stun me again. Seriously, this is ridiculous. Are there no ends to your talents?

(There is no way you can turn THAT into a haiku-right??)

:)


message 48: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Honestly, I had
Never written a haiku
Before I did these.

It's as simple as 5-7-5.


Mel (who is deeply in love with Hal) Your flair delights me.
Are you an English teacher?
Your skill suggests yes.

phew!

*wipes forehead*

Okay, maybe not as hard as I'd first thought..But still no match to any of yours!

:)


message 50: by Ian (last edited Dec 12, 2011 10:30am) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Graye Mel wrote: "Okay, maybe not as hard as I'd first thought..But still no match to any of yours!:)"

Well done, Mel. Practice makes perfect. Four stars.

But no, I'm more of a student than a teacher.

Too busy to teach.
Perpetually learning
From all that I read.

I felt bad about saying that, so I've added this about our children.

Though I suppose that
Children are always learning
By observation.


« previous 1 3
back to top