Şahan Yatarkalkmaz's Reviews > The Catcher in the Rye
The Catcher in the Rye
by J.D. Salinger
by J.D. Salinger
I did not read this book once or twice. I read it whenever I could. Tens of times. Sometimes I had to hold my breath to finish it. It was a book to remind.
One may think that I was influenced by that average Mel Gibson movie Conspiracy Theory and "the assassin of Kennedy had a copy of Catcher in the Rye in his pocket" legend, but it was not so. However it is true that I found myself reading the book after I watched the film. But the reason I repeated reading it, is nothing to with the American this and that.
I suppose there are many people who may regard this book as pulp or a passtime magazine. I prefer to leave them be. Holden Caulfield is about how every one of us is disgustingly fake and how each and every one of us continues to pretend we aren't so. The only way out is to embrace that fake-ness. It's not as bad as it sounds you know.
I used to read the ending just to remind myself what was going on in the whole book. Holden's sister IS the catcher. She is the whole point in life. At least for Holden. Everyone has some catcher. Or else, I don't know what.
I also like the bit on the prostitute. I do not know why, she gave me a tense realization of Holden's inner conflict. She gave me possibilities of every character of the book. It is also the texture of the book. It is a book of possibilities. You never really know any character for sure. Except for the sister whose name I forgot. She is the only divine figure in this godless, wanna-be-tragedy. I'd very much like to dig into the concept of godlessness and the modern in "Catcher in the Rye" but that's a plan for the future for now.
This book must be read to love or hate, not to like or dislike or say "hmm, I guess it's just a book". Or else it's just faking to have read it.
One may think that I was influenced by that average Mel Gibson movie Conspiracy Theory and "the assassin of Kennedy had a copy of Catcher in the Rye in his pocket" legend, but it was not so. However it is true that I found myself reading the book after I watched the film. But the reason I repeated reading it, is nothing to with the American this and that.
I suppose there are many people who may regard this book as pulp or a passtime magazine. I prefer to leave them be. Holden Caulfield is about how every one of us is disgustingly fake and how each and every one of us continues to pretend we aren't so. The only way out is to embrace that fake-ness. It's not as bad as it sounds you know.
I used to read the ending just to remind myself what was going on in the whole book. Holden's sister IS the catcher. She is the whole point in life. At least for Holden. Everyone has some catcher. Or else, I don't know what.
I also like the bit on the prostitute. I do not know why, she gave me a tense realization of Holden's inner conflict. She gave me possibilities of every character of the book. It is also the texture of the book. It is a book of possibilities. You never really know any character for sure. Except for the sister whose name I forgot. She is the only divine figure in this godless, wanna-be-tragedy. I'd very much like to dig into the concept of godlessness and the modern in "Catcher in the Rye" but that's a plan for the future for now.
This book must be read to love or hate, not to like or dislike or say "hmm, I guess it's just a book". Or else it's just faking to have read it.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Catcher in the Rye.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-9 of 9) (9 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Alper
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Mar 03, 2007 02:55pm
One of the best book reviews I have read in a while Sahan'cim, thank you for sharing.
reply
|
flag
*
I loved your book review. You picked up on two of the most important moments (elements?) of the book that I actually left out when I taught my students The Catcher in the Rye -- the role of Sunny, the prostitute, and the fact that Phoebe really is the catcher. My students are not literarily-inclined (yes, I know, not a word), but that they saw this was by far the best moment of my young teaching career. I'm interested that you've read this book so many times. I couldn't. I read it once, put it down, and could not read it for several years. Almost ten actually. It haunted me. But yes - thank you for a great review.
I liked your review but I disagree. "we are all fake" is simply a cop out. We are not all fake. Many of us are fake but they are what is wrong with society. If you are fake, I suggest you (not you sahen, anyone reading this) try to rectify you're shortcomings and not try to pass them off as normal. Holden was a spoiled self centered brat and he does NOT represent teenagers or society. Holden is fake not everyone else, although he does pick up on a few fellow fakers.His almost religious regard for his sister (I forgot her name too) is less about godliness and more about Holden's Realization that he is a spoiled brat and any hope for the future rested on his sister who was not a complete waste of oxygen like himself.
since the words used in this books are easy and written in conversational language, once u pick up the book and read, u can keep read it, true.
Thanks for your review. i felt the book was spiritual. thats why i loved it. Now i dont know why i thought it was..




