Genia Lukin's Reviews > Sacred and Profane

Sacred and Profane by Faye Kellerman
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Apr 03, 2011

it was ok
bookshelves: mystery-and-detective
Read on April 03, 2011

It's a cute enough schlock series, I suppose. As brain candy reading goes, it's not horrible, nor brilliant. For me, the extraneous digressions into Judaism here, there and everywhere were very offputting; I felt that, as a literary coup, they were poorly done. And that is a pity, because I would have loved to see more orthodox authors and themes written for outside audiences, and the complex life of Jewish Orthodoxy, which very few people on the outside are actually familiar with, reflected in a mainstream novel.

Still, if you want to go mainstream, you must also cater to some mainstream technique, and that includes the capability to insert themes and observations about life in an understated way, not as sermons. I also find it hard to forgive, since Rina Lazarus is depicted more as Charedi than mild Modern Orthodox, the many times the lead characters hold hands, hug, kiss, sit in each other's laps, etc'. It's not that it doesn't happen, of course, but Rina doesn't even make noises about it being forbidden - which it is, as it violates negiah.

Perhaps I am more bemused and bored - as well as occasionally downright annoyed - by these asides because I am an Orthodox Jew myself. Most of her explications, put in the mouth of Rav Schulmann, as well as simplifications, leave me very cold indeed. I don't know. I just know it detracted from the story in my eyes.

On the opposite hand, so to speak, I must compliment her at least on some of the criminology research she's obviously done. I can't speak for many details, but the dental forensics, at least, had decent amounts of accuracy in it.

So, a tepid 2.5 stars leaning towards 3. Not bad for an afternoon with a slightly fuzzy head, but nothing to write home about.
3 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Sacred and Profane.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

04/03 page 200
04/16 marked as: read
show 1 hidden update…

Comments (showing 1-1 of 1) (1 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Rachel She made noises as u say in book one. I wondered why the lack of any such upset or indecision at touching Peter a mere 4 months after she initially could barely look up into his eyes for fear of breaking Halacha and also giving him or anyone else improper ideas. I don't know my firm opinion on this series isn't in yet so early on but my initial reaction is much like yours but with more of a 3 star leaning as it fits the bill and keeps me entertained sufficiently for when I want an easier read like this. Coming off Jerusalem maiden and Hotel Moscow both by Talia Carner a nice short little murder mystery with characters u follow along book to book n care about is good for me. Otherwise I spend longer than I would reading this book trying to choose my next deeper read.

back to top