Andrew Georgiadis's Reviews > Bomb, Book & Compass: Joseph Needham & the Great Secrets of China

Bomb, Book & Compass by Simon Winchester

by
2343621
's review
Feb 16, 11

bookshelves: nonfiction, biography
Read in January, 2009

Also known as "The Man Who Loved China" in American editions (because our versions are necessarily dumbed-down), this is the story of Joseph Needham's quest to understand an Eastern culture to which he was introduced in adulthood. A professor of chemistry and one with no official qualifications to undertake a work of rigorous history, he embarked on one of the most ambitious, lengthy, and meticulously researched pieces of scholarship in human history. At twenty-eight volumes and still in print, "Science and Civilisation in China" is (I would find out) a modern masterpiece.

Simon Winchester has a loving eye for detail, and this is what fills his books with such wonder. He also seems to be more successful when the object of his inquiry is a character rather than a place or epoch (see his brilliant "The Professor and the Madman" to American readers, vs. the less regarded "Korea"). Needham is a perfect study for Winchester's discerning talents - at once brilliant, multilingual, hypersexual, a gymnosophist - one of several new words you will learn - charming and dashing, and, again, brilliant. You will inescapably notice that Professor Needham bears no small resemblance to the author, who has a love for detail, and for whom no small morsel of knowledge is too frivolous to be examined and ingested.

Joseph Needham, a married man, was introduced to the Chinese language and culture by Lu Gwei-Djen, a 33-year old Chinese woman who was working in a Cambridge University laboratory under his supervision. This is the fulcrum on which his life would begin to turn, will the full weight of history behind it. It would be such a shame to spoil his extraordinary journey with plot-like summations. As one never to be so blessed with such tremendous mental gifts and interests, I can only understand his story like we enjoy a shooting-star, as a flash of brilliant, incomprehensible wonder, and, minding that Needham's death was at 94 years old, it is always gone too soon.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Bomb, Book & Compass.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-1 of 1) (1 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Alex Excellent summary of the book, the author, and his subject. I am so curious about what I have missed by reading the "dumbed-down" version?


back to top