Joel's Reviews > Ready Player One

Ready Player One by Ernest Cline
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
2863914
's review
Jun 03, 11

bookshelves: 2011, dystopia, ya, thanks-karen, vote-getters, i-am-8-bit
Read from May 27 to 29, 2011

There's this conceit that keeps popping up in sci-fi dystopia novels that it is only a matter of time before we will all be glued to our virtual reality goggles 24 hours a day as elaborate MMPORPGs slowly take over the world.

I think this is stupid. No matter how increasingly ubiquitous computers become, I just don't foresee Second Life replacing the first one (FarmVille may have replaced actual farming, but that conversation involves a lecture on government subsidies that I just don't have time for at the moment). But all of these books are written by sci-fi authors, therefore geeks, therefore gamers, therefore open to this kind of concept. If they are of a certain age, it probably seems like an extension of the D&D-fueled fantasy sessions that sustained them through high school.

I wasn't a D&D geek (though admittedly in a "there but for the grace of God" way). I have never played an online quest game -- I am not drawn to the fantasy. I don't have that strong a desire to escape the real world, as dissatisfying as it can be sometimes, as much as I'd rather be a Han Solo avatar flying around in the Falcon.

Ernest Cline, by all accounts, was exactly that geek, getting lost in fantasy worlds. And I give him credit: he goes to great lengths to justify the replacement of the virtual for the real, and he makes it sound damn plausible. Imagine the world forty years from now: we have run out of oil. Corporations have replaced governments with puppet regimes (all voting is online, so only celebrities and reality stars have a shot at office). The environment is in shambles, the Great Recession is in its fourth decade, overcrowded and dangerous cities are surrounded by suburban wastelands. Would not you rather stay in your efficiency apartment and play virtual reality?

Wade is an overweight and unattractive teen who barely has a life outside of OASIS, a web platform that, by 2044, has totally replaced the internet (with travel dangerous and difficult, most everyday commerce is virtual). His real life sucks. His parents are dead, and he lives in a teetering 200-foot-tall stack of trailers with his cruel aunt and her abusive boyfriend of the month. He was getting beaten up too much at school, so now he goes to classes online. All he lives for is OASIS, and the search for the Egg.

See, when James Halliday, the Bill Gates-like inventor of the OASIS, died, he hid his will (and the rights to his fortune and control of OASIS itself) somewhere inside the game, on any one of thousands of virtual worlds. For years, no one has been able to crack even the first clue to its location, though not for lack of trying: a whole community of gamers has sprung up in search of it. Some are lone wolves like Wade; others band together or go corporate and work for the evil IOI Corp. (Corporations: Your Friends in Evil Since 1601).

Most of their efforts are focused on studying the obsessions of Halliday's youth, which they figure are key to winning the hunt. Conveniently for Cline, his and Halliday's obsessions are one and the same: everything nerdy about the 1980s. Gaming, TV, movies, music -- if someone has gotten into a heated debate over it in a basement somewhere, or painted a mural of it on the side of a van, it's in here.

Look, this book is a lot of fun. A lot. I read it compulsively, like few books in recent memory. But... I don't think it is very well written. I have a lot of problems with it: Wade is a cypher, a blatant audience surrogate (provided the audience is or has been an introverted teen boy, which...). There is this whole romance angle between Wade and another hunter, Art3mis, that is just there because the plot needs a love interest. There is frequent, blatant exposition that often makes no sense (Wade tells his story in the first person, presumably to his contemporaries, so why is he explaining very basic things like what OASIS is and how you operate within it?). The background of various geek properties is often given in exhaustive, Wikipedia-like detail. I find it hard to believe that the solutions to the puzzles went undiscovered for five years, since they seem pretty obvious to me and my limited experience in online alternate reality games has taught me that there is no puzzle so complex that the internet won't solve it given 20 minutes and a Yahoo message board (read up on "The Beast" sometime for an interesting example). Oh, also there are several blatant continuity errors within chapters or even from one page to the next (minor example: at one point Wade freaks out about getting to class because if he doesn't, he will lose his school-issued OASIS machine; a few chapters later he stops going but it's fine because he already has the credits to graduate).

All that stuff: basically doesn't matter. At all. I still loved the crap out of every page. The plot is as propulsive, structured and satisfying as The Hunger Games. The corporate villains raise the real world stakes when they start murdering gamers offline. And Cline takes full advantage of an unlimited sandbox of geekdom, dreaming up some very cool scenarios (want to literally immerse yourself in your favorite '80s movie? How about transform into Ultraman to fight Mecha-Godzilla and Voltron?).

What's most fun is waiting around for Cline to name-drop your geek property of choice. Will there still be annoying Browncoats in 2045? Looks like it: Wade zooms around virtual space in a Firefly class shuttle. Lightsabers, transporters (Stars, both Wars and Trek). Giant robots (Voltron, Neon Genesis Evangelion, Ultraman). More video games than I can count (but no classic Nintendo! Where is Mario in all of this?). Blade Runner. Brazil. Back to the Future. Indiana Jones. Ghostbusters. Rush (Really? People like Rush?). One* almost needs footnotes to place them all.

*I mean, not me. If this book taught me anything, it is that I am a bigger geek than I ever imagined.

Can you enjoy this book without getting all the references? I think so. But... do you even want to? That is where I am confused. I believe this is being published as a YA title, and it's certainly written as one. Yet today's Ys think the '80s sound like they happened a looooong time ago, and I haven't read a YA book packed with jokey references to obscure 1960s pop culture lately.

I mean, do kids even know what a "modem" is? If you gained sentience post-2000, the internet has just always been there, floating through the air. What do you mean, they used to require a phone line and made annoying noises? What's that? A computer that uses a tape deck instead of a floppy disk drive? A) What is a "cassette tape"? B) What is a "floppy disk"? (Ooh, is it dirty?)

This book will probably make you feel old. I am not even old and it made me feel old. Remember dial-up? Remember AOL busy signals? Remember when no one had cell phones? Remember when no one but engineers, the military and Matthew Broderick had the internet? Remember the NES, Atari 2600, Colecovision?

I do. But how long until I'm senile? Probably not that long.
138 likes · likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Ready Player One.
sign in »

Reading Progress

05/27/2011 page 40
10.0%
05/27/2011 page 110
29.0% "a young adult novel this entrenched in '80s geek culture still seems weird to me. never mind that teens today would never believe that my family's first computer used a tape deck instead of a disc drive (cassettes? i thought urban outfitters made those up), they probably don't even know that using the internet used to require a phone line and the modems made funny noises. way to make me feel old, book."
05/29/2011 page 234
61.0% "whee!"
show 2 hidden updates…

Comments (showing 1-28 of 28) (28 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

karen you still want this?


Joel yes! can you get it with bookstore magic?


karen with fox and friends magic.

i will send it your way.


Joel karen wrote: "with fox and friends magic.

i will send it your way."


thank you! even though fox and friends magicks sound like the blackest sort!


karen i meddle with dark forces...


Joel crap, sorry for writing an 8000-word review.


message 7: by Kathleen (new) - added it

Kathleen Why are you apologizing? It was a darn good review.

You get 37 points for the Matthew Broderick joke.

Now if you can drop some Pink Lady & Jeff jokes into a review, then I'll know that you *really* are old.


Joel no doubt wade watched the entire run at some point as part of his research. in the future, everything from forever is available instant streaming. he claims to have watched more tv, read more books and played more video games to expert levels in five years of research than i believe humanly possible.


message 9: by Jasmine (new) - added it

Jasmine There's this conceit that keeps popping up in sci-fi dystopia novels that it is only a matter of time before we will all be glued to our virtual reality goggles 24 hours a day as elaborate MMPORPGs slowly take over the world.

I think this is stupid.


I keep seeing this about phones and I feel the exact same way about it.


message 10: by Joel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joel thanks! i recently spent about half an hour on youtube watching clips from atari XE games. hearing the music from moon patrol again really took me back.


karen heh.

load.


karen oh god, i hope these two sentences are unrelated,...


Micha LOL - I actually LOVED that this book made me feel old, because it has never happened before (and I am certain I will regret this novel feeling one day soon) and I knew there would be so many people in my age bracket that would feel the same way. Our generation is the closest thing available to the "cool hippy" generation that is occurring now in grandparents and that's kind of troubling and exciting. I loved you review, by the way. I really hit all the key points for me in terms of my own 'complaints' (If I could actually call them that) and happinesses with the book.


message 14: by Ben (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ben Hobbs A great review, as always Joel.

I must add that I remember sitting in my basement with nerd friends playing the parts of MP and The Holy Grail. In fact about 5 years ago I had the chance to see it on a huge movie screen at Cleveland's Palace Theater, complete with audience participation with coconuts.

I was equally surprised by the lack of NES references. A Metal Gear or Rad Racer reference would have made my day.

Thanks again for an insightful review.


message 15: by Joel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joel Monty python would be great with an audience! Have you seen the musical? They incorporate the audience quite a but actually.

Thanks for the kind words!


message 16: by Ben (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ben Hobbs The deal was if you went to the film you got to buy advance tickets for the musical. The musical was great. The Lady of the Lake scenes stole the show and I concur about the audience participation.

I've been trolling your shelves looking for what to read next (I trust your ratings and reviews) as I just finished Divergent after having read Ready Player One. Any suggestions of something not to be missed?


message 17: by Joel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joel are you specifically looking in the y.a./dystopia vein? i am going to assume you have read hunger games... i haven't read but have heard a lot of good things about Blood Red Road.

more generally, if you like sci-fi, the second-most fun book i read last year (after ready player one) was Leviathan Wakes.


Robert Trust me, for some people I've had the misfortune to know, Second Life has already replaced reality for them.


Readforthandconquer haha someone told me that their kid read this book and read your review, and they read the last three paragraphs and were just shaking their head because they had no idea what the hell you were talking about. is a floppy disk dirty? love that line


karen hahah! well, half the time i don't even know what the hell i'm ranting about, so that sounds about right to me!


message 21: by Joel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joel For instance, Karen didn't even realize this was MY review.


karen motherfuck! wow. that'll teach me not to half-read comments while doing other things on the computer. but that floppy disk joke is exactly the kind of sophisticated comedy gold for which i am known, so you can understand my confusion.

still. what shame i am feeling.


Peter Lyte I thought the virtual schools were overdone. Then met a teacher who works for a charter school. No virtual goggles for his class that's spread out all over the state. Each in front of their computer at home, all appearing on one of the monitors in his home. Student keeps acting up after several warnings, their connection is cut off and email sent to parents explaining what went on. Science fiction that's not really describing a hypothetical future.


message 24: by Joel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joel Fascinating, peter. I had no idea.


Peter Lyte Neither did I. In my state, Oregon, this particular charter school company has 250+ students, all in home, funded by Dept of Education, not parents. Parents choose wether their children will be home schooled. Not sure if the state provides computer &/or connection. Across country this one company services thousands of students, including special ed, this way. And there are many such companies.

Oh, 1 other "benefit, described while not as impressive as a virtual building on a virtual campus; when a change in curriculum is decided on, the companies tech dept is notified and voila, all appropriate students have access to the new materials.


Matt (replicant2019) Great review and yes, like James Halliday, Rush are one of my favourite bands of all time so I totally relate to that as well as a lot of the geek/gaming references -- thanks for the review :)


message 27: by Iris (new) - rated it 5 stars

Iris Joel, I found this little Gem by scouring through your read list! Glad I was being a good little cyber stalker otherwise I would have missed this possibly until the movie came out. I can't believe none of my friends have recommended this!


Nataliya "B) What is a "floppy disk"? (Ooh, is it dirty?)

This is awesome.


back to top