Sara's review of Love Medicine: A Novel

Love Medicine: A Novel (P.S.) Love Medicine: A Novel (P.S.)
by Louise Erdrich
649158
Sara's review
recommended for: starbitrary

The rating system is starting to get to me. It is one way that the internet is rearranging values by inventing new value systems that are increasingly circumscribed. I mean, what choice do I have if my reading does not fit into five stars? Maybe it is too good or unreadable or maybe I just don't think lit up stars are an applicable way to express how I felt about it. What if I begin to judge everyone by similar ratings? I am walking down the street thinking "Oh. She is for sure two stars. But her buddy, he may be three." What about "Look at that one star yuppie. I should revoke that star for lack of originality." It could extend to all manners of existence, "This pepper is a four ripe." or "I am feeling 2.5 right now." I do have the option of pithy statements to accompany the stars. Which makes it better but most people don't even write. That is why people should write their reviews. You can't really tell what someone is thinking by ...more
Like this review?   yes    flag



comments (showing 1-2 of 2)

newest »
dateDown_arrow

message 1: by Ryan (last edited 02/05/2008 01:10PM)
02/05/2008 01:09PM

653157 This is truly an academic journey of a review. It sarcastically and sardonically eschews verses and verses from the vacant remotes of I don't know where. Why not use stars, if we don't have inapplicable rating systems to judge things, then why even judge things at all. The stars are half the battle.


message 2: by Anne
03/16/2008 08:15PM

652923 You, my dear, are five stars- but ask me tomorrow and you may only be three.


back to top

all of Sara's books »