Kathryn's Reviews > And the Show Went On: Cultural Life in Nazi-Occupied Paris

And the Show Went On by Alan Riding
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Mar 12, 2011

really liked it
bookshelves: world-war
Read from February 03 to March 08, 2011

Alan Riding’s new book, “And the Show Went on,” portrays, in a winningly detailed manner, the resistance and collaboration of those involved with French culture – the stage, the screen, visual art, writing, and music -- during the Nazi occupation.

After the fall of France, the Germans wanted Parisian cultural institutions reopened for several reasons. First, if Parisians were “kept entertained,” they might be less troublesome. But there was another reason, found in the words of propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels: “the result of our victorious fight should be to break French domination of cultural propaganda, in Europe and the world.” The Germans had a cultural inferiority complex regarding the French and now they felt they were in a position to vanquish French cultural dominance permanently.

To accomplish this goal, Goebbels set up the Propaganda Abteilung (Propaganda Department) in France, comprising a staff of approximately 1,200 people and which contained the Propaganda Staffel which had 50 bureaus (love that bizarre Nazi organizational mindset) in the occupied zone of France and which micromanaged French culture during the occupation.

Vichy, anti-Semitic to the core, was eager to collaborate with the Germans in almost everything; this created confusion for some Frenchmen and Riding recounts scads of collaborators, whose behavior ranged from enthusiastic collaboration to complete indifference; i.e., those who cooperated with but ignored the Germans as much as possible and focused primarily on their craft.

One particularly appealing but unapparent hero of the cultural resistance featured in the book is Rose Valland, a dowdy art curator who, for her efforts to track and save Jewish-owned stolen art, was granted numerous awards, including the Medal of the Resistance by France and the Medal of Freedom by the United States.

She was one of the only heroes in the arena of stolen Jewish art, however. Vichy’s official stance on this looting was blatantly anti-Semitic and Riding notes many Frenchmen who assisted in this enormous robbery. Really, for every notable culturally-inclined French hero Riding mentions, he also names at least a handful of either passive or active collaborators. The unified French Resistance was a complete myth, as Riding clearly illustrates again and again by highlighting scores of collaborationist profiles.

One of the chapters focusing on writers, ‘On the Side of Life,’ is uniquely inspiring, particularly its section on resistance poetry, which, as Riding points out, “enjoyed a monopoly since no collaborationist writer ever tried to express his Fascism in verse.” Poet Pierre Seghers, who was able to work openly, published French poetry mailed from German prison camps while other poets secretly wrote and distributed fiery Resistance verse.

In addition to the multitude of profiles included – each one ranging from a single paragraph to several pages – Riding also presents general information on the war, setting the profiles solidly within their historical context, so that “And the Show Went on” is a highly illuminating read on the subject of Nazi-occupied French cultural life.

(This review has also been published at CurledUpWithAGoodBook.com -- http://www.curledup.com/and_the_show_...)
1 like · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read And the Show Went On.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

02/03/2011 page 1
0.0% "A quote from the end of the book I just finished, "Citizens of London": "'Paris [in WWII] died like a beautiful woman, in a coma, without struggle, without knowing or even asking why. One left Paris with a feeling almost of relief. London one leaves with regret.'"

I also leave war-torn London with regret but am looking forward to learning more about that beautiful comatose woman . . ."
02/08/2011 page 63
15.0% "Fascinating reading so far. The image of Nazi-occupied France as a united Resistance effort is completely erroneous and this book explains how and why on a very detailed level."
show 1 hidden update…

No comments have been added yet.