Brandy Painter's Reviews > Jellicoe Road

Jellicoe Road by Melina Marchetta
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Jan 12, 2011

it was amazing
bookshelves: contemporary-fiction, favorites, young-adult, books-i-own
Read in January, 2011

Review originally posted here.

This is one of those books that sucks you in from the first sentence, which happens to be, "My father took one hundred and thirty two minutes to die." From that point on I barely breathed for the three hours it took me to read the rest. Just being able to suck a reader into a story does not qualify a book to be a great book though. There are plenty of books that suck in readers that are just awful. This one is a good book in every sense of the word: good story, strong characters and a light handed touch to the themes.

The story is complex and the pieces are given to the reader a bit at a time. However, the execution of this is so brilliant it is actually a simple book to read. There is Taylor's story and then there is the story in Hannah's manuscript which is only given a little here or there. The places where Hannah's written story are inserted flow perfectly with Taylor's story. Piece by piece they are information and Taylor hugs every bit of story she has read close to her heart and goes over them again and again. "So I go back to the stories I've read about the five and I try to make sense of their lives because in making sense of theirs, I may understand mine." The five suffered a lot of tragedy. Taylor has too. At one point I did pause and think exactly how many bad things can happen to one group of ordinary people. I thought about it for a moment and realized it was exactly this many and a whole lot more are possible. Despite all the bad things that happen though the book is not at all depressing because it is balanced with a great sense of wonder and hope. It is life.

The story is told in first person from Taylor's point of view. The synopsis describes Taylor at the beginning pretty well but as the book progresses she takes more risks. She steps out of her self imposed boundaries and starts to connect with people a little more. And then she begins to trust them too. The difficulties in a person deeply emotionally scarred doing this are realistically portrayed. What I love about the way this is written is that despite the fact that Taylor is telling the story it is not just her story. It is also the story of Jonah and Chaz and Raffy and Ben and Jessa and the five kids from the past. This is what I really love about Marchetta's writing. She manages to convey community so well. No individual, no matter, how hard she may try, can live her life isolated. Everything we do as an individual affects a community of some sort and the ripples are far reaching. The friendships of Taylor, Jonah, Chaz and Raffy are a small picture of this. There is nothing at all tragic about the lives of Chaz and Raffy. They are, however, affected by the tragedy of Taylor's and Jonah's. How the four of them interact in their fights, their play time, their moments of joy, their moments of grief and their understanding paints a vivid picture of what true community with your friends can be. With the story of the five it is also shown how one generation impacts another, and not just the older generation the younger. Taylor and her friends have an impact on the adults in this novel too, changing their perceptions on things they were too close to see all the angles of. I love this.

The story also explores romantic relationships of many different types. Intense romantic connection, romantic relationship that didn't work but where the people are still crazy about each other, romance that ended in tragedy, former best friends having feelings towards each other, married life with kids, it's all in this book. The central one being the relationship between Taylor and Jonah. What I like best about these two is that they are both working hard to not repeat the mistakes of their parents. Taylor recognizes some of her mother's weaknesses in herself and wants to overcome them. Jonah is doing the same thing. Nothing about their relationship is easy. Jonah is a really great match for Taylor despite their equally screwed up pasts and he is pretty awesome as a person in his own right. Okay, not pretty awesome. Really awesome. I have to say that this book is brim full of really awesome guys. At least five. And as much as I love Jonah and Jude, the one that caught my heart the most was actually Chaz. There is one point where Taylor thinks, "I'm very disturbed to find out that the leader of the Townies has a soul and I'm beginning to develop a bit of a crush on him." Oh me too. (The other two I was counting were Webb and Ben.)

Note on Content: There are many disturbing topics touched on in the story. Death, abandonment, abuse (in all its forms) and suicide are all included in some way. There are two sex scenes neither of which are overly detailed. There is also some strong language used. None of this is gratuitous though. All of it fits into the characters and themes of the story.

There is so much in this novel and yet it is so simply written. I am in awe of the artistry of it.
1 like · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Jellicoe Road.
Sign In »

Quotes Brandy Liked

Melina Marchetta
“I'm very disturbed to find out that the leader of the Townies has a soul and I'm beginning to develop a bit of a crush on him.”
Melina Marchetta, On the Jellicoe Road

Melina Marchetta
“It's funny how you can forget everything except people loving you. Maybe that's why humans find it so hard getting over love affairs. It's not the pain they're getting over, it's the love.”
Melina Marchetta, On the Jellicoe Road

Comments (showing 1-8 of 8) (8 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Lorie (new) - added it

Lorie V. This sounds interesting Brandy... I think I will add it to my "to read" list. Thanks for the review.

Chachic Yay, so glad you loved this one! It really is an intense read, isn't it? It's amazing how there was so much suffering for the characters and yet the main message of the book is about hope.

Can't wait for The Piper's Son.

Brandy Painter Hope you like it Lorie!

Chachic, I am so ready for it to be March. I'm actually going to preorder The Piper's Son and that's not something I do often.

Beth One thing, Brandy - there is some language in the book. I didn't think it was offensive (more that it fit the book) and language usually bothers me, but I thought you should know :)

Brandy Painter More language than there was in Jellicoe and Francesca? I'm really just curious. From what I've read so far Marchetta doesn't strike me as an author to do something just because she can. If it fits into the book properly and is in keeping with the character's personality/situation strong language won't bother me.

Beth I think it's more language, but it fits with Tom's voice and situation. Have you read Long May She Reign? It reminds me of that.

Brandy Painter I don't think it will bother me then. I haven't read Long May She Reign. I haven't read any of that series (which I know to you is appalling, I will get to it eventually). :)

Beth GET ON IT. Seriously :)

back to top