Dia's Reviews > The Castle

The Castle by Franz Kafka

by
1086452
's review
Jan 04, 11


Where did this book come from and why was its author not completely in love with it?

I'd liked Kafka already but felt I'd had enough, knew enough of him... I had no idea. No idea that Kafka could pull such rabbits out of such hats, that a such limited world could be so complete, that a hero could be so sleepy, that slapstick could be performed with words alone and be SO funny, so useful, so correct.

I don't read this as allegory, warning, or vengeful depiction of a bourgeois cul-de-sac. I read it as pleasure, with pleasure. Kafka played. He enjoyed his mind. His mind was related to ours perhaps like a bonfire is related to a flashlight. They both illuminate, but one is a festive riot of nature that resolves into poignant embers while the other merely gets the job done with an occasional change of batteries. Well, I now need to read a biography of Kafka to see just how playful he was. Recommendations, anyone?

**************************************************************************


A few days later, and I must append a note of gnawing dissatisfaction with the metaphor that I used to compare Kafka's mind to the hoi polloi's. The image of fire is completely wrong for Kafka, as it connotes organic passion, whereas Kafka's writing is uncannily clinical. His description of sex, for example, is perhaps the most dispassionate (and thus funny) as any that exists in the history of Letters: "...since the chair stood by the bed they stumbled over it and fell down. They lay there...she sought something and he sought something, in a fury, grimacing, they sought...like dogs desperately pawing at the earth they pawed at each other's bodies, and then, helpless and disappointed, in an effort to catch one last bit of happiness, their tongues occasionally ran all over each other's faces. Only weariness made them lie still and be grateful to one another. Then the maids came up, 'Look at the way they're lying there,' one of them said, and out of pity she threw a sheet over them."

So -- bonfire, no. More like magnifying glass that inspects and distorts as it burns. I think what I was trying to get at with the lame bonfire metaphor is how everything is fodder for Kafka -- how the details simultaneously proliferate and are consumed by his almost monomaniacal but also incredibly playful (I insist) vision. And I stand by my assertion that his mind was in some way really different from most peoples'. Most people would be compelled to make a story out of any one of his beginnings. But he was compelled to begin again and again and again. He couldn't let anything definite happen, and he delighted in this neurosis, played with it. Even this collection of indefinite vignettes was too definite for him, so he abandoned it. And we look at it and impute meaning...



Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Castle.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-8 of 8) (8 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Dancegrant (new)

Dancegrant Cheever did not like Kafka. Go figure.

I recently re-read the Metamorphosis and a couple other stories and had some similar feelings but definitely think he was fairly addled and mostly writing as a reactionary and was probably not very comfortable with life.

Max Brod had great access to his journals and may have written something about him from those? Brod wrote the introduction to the edition of the stories I read and seemed to offer some level of insight.


message 2: by Dia (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dia I just started the Brod biography.
Reactionary to what?


message 3: by Dancegrant (new)

Dancegrant Well, let's face it, if you awaken one morning and you have turned into a cockroach and end up enjoying being that more than being a son, brother, employee, friend, etc, it seems a reactive stance to society, yes?


message 4: by Dia (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dia It's been a while since I've read The Metamorphosis, but what I remember about it is that Gregor wakes up to find himself in a condition that he didn't choose to be in. He makes strenuous efforts to adapt to it. His family is disgusted by him. He comes to some kind of reconciliation with an unwanted, socially unaccepted condition. This is only a slightly exaggerated version of what some who develop disabilities or illnesses might experience.

And -- is it so bad to be reactive re: society?


message 5: by Dancegrant (new)

Dancegrant Try reading it again; I am not using the word reactive in a negative way. If you are reading Brod I am sure he will illuminate Kafka's difficulties with life which I think probably drove him to pick the kinds of situations, characters, and settings that he did as he wrote such bizarre indictments of the power of society. I think he was reacting to what he was experiencing.

For example, It is pretty hard to imagine someone other than a person meant to starve to death writing about a Hunger Artist. For me these stories have always been way beyond metaphors and allegories.

I think Kafka was quite good at illustrating the absurdity and vulnerability latent in the human drive for constructing a social reality (complete with all the attendant institutions such as families, laws, religion, money, etc) in order to feel "sane" and in control.

Usually something crazy or absurd and permanent occurs in his stories which leads to a forced "existential" examination by the protagonist. Meanwhile the rest of the characters in the story (who usually are banal representatives of various social institutions and hierarchies) are trying their best to continue on with their version of life by ignoring what is so insane to them that they can hardly bare to mention it, let alone look at it.


message 6: by Dia (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dia Or maybe it's a precursor to PETA, reminding us that cockroaches are people, too? Who knows what form we'll take next time around...!


message 7: by Dancegrant (new)

Dancegrant My argument has been, since before you were born, what we experiencing evolutionarily in humans is a widespread increase in what we have come to call autism; Kafka is a forerunner.


message 8: by Dia (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dia I first read this as "increase in...altruism" -- which seems as defensible as an increase in autism...perhaps an increase in both ends of the spectrum?


back to top