Khaya's Reviews > Secret Daughter

Secret Daughter by Shilpi Somaya Gowda

by
Nophoto-f-50x66
's review
Jan 04, 11

bookshelves: ebooks, southasia
Read on January 01, 2011

Meh. Not a bad story, but too superficially rendered for my taste.

Kavita, a poor village woman, has just given birth to an infant daughter she names Usha. Terrified that her husband will murder the daughter because she's a girl, she journeys to Mumbai to place Usha in an orphanage. Meanwhile, Somer and Krishnan, a California couple struggling with infertility, decide to adopt an Indian orphan and end up with Usha. The book follows the twists and turns in these characters' lives as Kavita and her family experience changes of location and fortune and Somer and Krishnan raise Usha (whom they call Asha) who eventually seeks her roots in India.

There were moments in this book which resonated and smacked of psychological complexity. Somer initially finds it difficult to bond with her new infant; Kavita comes to appreciate her husband despite his flaws; Kavita's husband eventually regrets and examines his zealousness to get rid of his infant daughter. But for the most part, the story was told in a way that seemed almost rushed as it spanned two decades. I didn't feel that I got to know any of the characters; the vicissitudes in their relationships and fortunes passed me by without my getting caught up in them. Where I often find myself complaining about the slow pacing in books, this was a case where the rapidity with which events unfolded precluded my feeling anything about them.

It wasn't a bad book, but the fact that it could have been so much better than it was made for a disappointing reading experience. Not to mention the high goodreads rating and Amazon's placing it on a list of 100 Best Books of 2010.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Secret Daughter.
sign in »

Reading Progress

01/01/2011 page 16
5.0%
01/02/2011 page 67
20.0% "This much-touted book seems kind of mediocre so far. Maybe it's just me."
01/02/2011 page 113
34.0% "Getting better, but I'm still not crazy about the writing."
01/04/2011 page 185
55.0% "Probably about a 3-star. It's not bad, but I'm not sure why it has such a high goodreads rating."

Comments (showing 1-10 of 10) (10 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Gail I agree with Khaya: " didn't feel that I got to know any of the characters; the vicissitudes in their relationships and fortunes passed me by without my getting caught up in them. Where I often find myself complaining about the slow pacing in books, this was a case where the rapidity with which events unfolded precluded my feeling anything about them.

It wasn't a bad book, but the fact that it could have been so much better than it was made for a disappointing reading experience."

The characters were insipid.


Gail I agree that the book was disappointing. The characters were insipid.


Khaya Absolutely. I felt they were puppets, or at best, stock types who kind of went through the motions but didn't seem to have an inner life that I could empathize with.


Erika I agree, not a bad book, but also not one that will stick with me for a long time.


Khaya Yes. I find myself saying that about many books I read. I guess that what defines an average book, as opposed to one that's spectacularly good or spectacularly bad.


Gabrielle Meh.. describes how I feel also.


message 7: by marg (new)

marg In a way, I think the "meh" books are the worst. With the really bad ones, you can either abandon them early on or have fun writing a really scathing review. With the "meh" ones, though, I find myself hoping they'll get better and end up feeling like I wasted more time on them.


message 8: by marg (new)

marg Whoops -- that was me (Khaya) accidentally posting on my sister's account. Sorry.


Emily Asha just got to India....should I stop reading now, or just go on? I've been feeling "meh" about this book, since I started reading it. I agree with all the reviews. It's too fast-paced and supeficial for me. Can't really "dig-in". So what's the verdict? Should I keep reading?


Khaya I'm always afraid to tell someone else what to do when it comes to these things -- reading tastes are very personal. But in my experience, if you're not loving a book by the time you're halfway through or so, it's probably not going to get better. There were a few times when I was glad I stuck with a book I wasn't loving, but mostly I found that my first impressions were accurate.


back to top