Petra X's Reviews > Packing for Mars: The Curious Science of Life in the Void

Packing for Mars by Mary Roach

by
1237196
's review
Dec 28, 11

bookshelves: medicine-science
Read from December 28, 2010 to December 28, 2011

Note: the dolphin-sex thing appears to be a hoax. Shame that. I like the idea of space sex having to be a threesome.

Why the Space Program Costs so Much. Because its run by a load of backward-thinking dickheads, contrary to what you might think.

Mary Roach seems to have an obsession with poo. I did actually want to know about toilet facilities in space, but not two-chapters worth of knowledge. Similarly a chapter about sex, although no-one apart from one Russian wanker (literally) actually admits to having it at all. The author does make the point though that weightlessness might make union difficult unless one employed a third person to push the two together, much like dolphins apparently do in the equally weightless medium of water.

I wanted to know much more about questions the author chose not to address to do with food, leisure time Do they watch movies, read books or just go for a stroll? How did they do their hair, did it grow faster or slower on the space station? Did they grow food of any kind? What about insects - did any of those find themselves on a trip to space and what happened to them if they did? Loads of things...

What I did learn was that anything built for space is subject to one restriction - it must be as small and light as possible as each extra pound costs thousands of dollars in the extra thrust needed to send it into space. However, there are certain taboos that cannot be overcome and the governments of both the USA and Russia are willing to spend out all the extra money in the world to make sure that men, as ever, not matter how fake it is, reign supreme.

Women are smaller, lighter and consequently generally eat less food, drink less water and breathe less air so naturally they should be the astronauts. NASA could raise only one objection to women in space which obviously must have been solved by now, as there are female astronauts, that urine droplets do not separate from the genitals and pubic hair 'cleanly' as they do in men. I'm not joking. Have they never heard of http://www.thisnext.com/topic-female-... or couldn't they invent one? So essentially the whole space program would be much more cost-effective if women were astronauts and men, unless they were quite little, stayed home and looked after the babies. But we couldn't have that, could we? American values count for more!

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Packing for Mars.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-17 of 17) (17 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jim (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jim I'm almost done with this book & have a totally different impression than what I'm reading in your review. NASA's money is controlled by backward thinking dickheads, but I didn't see any indication the folks working there or running the place were such. Except for your question about insects, I thought all the rest were answered pretty well. As complicated as elimination is, it deserved all the space she gave it.

As for women in space, the author makes your very point as did a couple of people at NASA, but they seem quite concerned by the bone density loss issue, besides a lot of baggage from those who write their budget. It amazes me how little biology is even being studied, often due to that conservative oversight & the need to be perceived as immaculate.

You should re-read the chapter on sex. The bit about the dolphins was something she investigated & turned out to be a hoax, if I recall correctly. I do recall one astronaut assuring her that biology would find a way & the rat experiment proved it. I thought Roach did a good job researching it given how no one would talk about it.


Petra X Jim wrote: "I'm almost done with this book & have a totally different impression than what I'm reading in your review. NASA's money is controlled by backward thinking dickheads, but I didn't see any indicatio..."

Hi Jim, just seen this comment. Funny how we can all read the same books and see such different things. Much as I like Mary Roach, after reading the wonderful Surviving the Extremes: What Happens to the Body and Mind at the Limits of Human Endurance and its take on life in space, Roach just seemed to be playing to the popular audience rather than really delving into the issues I was interested in.


message 3: by Stephen (last edited Dec 28, 2011 10:06am) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Stephen Great review, Petra. This is on my "very soon TBR" list and I am really looking forward to it.


Kemper You're right about the poo. I learned way more than I wanted too....


Petra X Stephen wrote: "Great review, Petra. This is on my "very soon TBR" list and I am really looking forward to it."

I am sure you will write a better and more entertaining review than I did. Sometimes I like popculture books, but not when I've just read the 'heavy' version and that makes me all bitter, twisted and very petty when writing a review. When you get (a bit) like that, you write GREAT reviews.


message 6: by Ij (new)

Ij Nice review!!!

The whole space program is a hoax!


Petra X Ij wrote: "Nice review!!!

The whole space program is a hoax!"


You think its all filmed on a deserted Hollywood backlot?


Stephen Petra X wrote: "When you get (a bit) like that, you write GREAT reviews."

Thanks, Petra. I'm glad you enjoy my "angry" reviews.


message 9: by Ij (new)

Ij Not Hollywood. They can't keep a secret there.


Petra X Ij wrote: "Not Hollywood. They can't keep a secret there."

True. It would be professional suicide if they could.


message 11: by Mark (new)

Mark Clear review so thanks for that Petra. I got a tad distracted whilst reading it by a horrible flash rather like one of those subliminal messages re the Russian 'self-service' . Hoping he reflected on lack of gravity before 'letting rip'


Petra X ROFLMAO

Actually I've forgotten that detail.


message 13: by Mark (new)

Mark Petra X wrote: "ROFLMAO


Now that is going to drive me insane for the next few days as I try to work out what those letters stand for. Might it be Russian onanist flew less miles after orgy



message 15: by Mark (new)

Mark what a fabulous web page. Thanks for resolving the conundrum too !!


Petra X You're welcome. HNY ;-)


message 17: by Mark (new)

Mark ditto


back to top