Nancy's Reviews > The Importance of Being Seven

The Importance of Being Seven by Alexander McCall Smith

by
2884323
's review
Dec 24, 10

Read in December, 2010

Having just read the third Corduroy Mansions book this book compares well, with better realized and fleshed out characters, which hold up better against the author's off-character rambles/asides. Pat was back, if briefly, Antonia may have had an epiphany, Bruce makes a couple of sightings, Matthew and Elspeth get plenty of mileage, but this is really about Bertie who continues to dream of freedom. A charming, thoughtful boy who, unlike other children his age, seems to have fully developed the reasoning portion of his brain a full 15 years prior to normal maturity. Still, unbelievability aside, he is a pleasure to read about. And Ulysses turned into a more interesting character than would be expected at 1 year old.

A caveat, however, my feelings about his mother's continued efforts to crush any expressed thoughts or desires has gone from irritated amusement to distaste and repugnance. The continued cruelty, though apparently not malicious, requires even more from Bertie's father, who did manage to do some good this time around. I have decided to give the series one more shot but, if the unrelenting attack on Bertie and his little dreams does not come into balance, I will have to give up on thus series entirely as I cannot continue to read about even a pretend little boy who is treated in such a manner.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Importance of Being Seven.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Annalie I enjoyed your review, Nancy!
There really are gifted children out there that have an amazing grasp on logic and are mature beyond their years, amazing every adult who deals with them (as I have experienced). Sadly there are also mothers like Irene in real life, who are so certain they are always right that they shut themselves off from that which their child is so desperately trying to communicate to them. She is a good example for us mothers of how not to be!


Nancy There are, although the reasoning part of the brain isn't fully developed until the early 20's - so he is quite advanced for a long-term 6-year-old. But they are sure full of surprises... my six-year-old niece was asking what I know about and I told her "trees", I know a lot about trees. So she asked me - what is the rarest tree in the world... urgh... stumped by a kid as that is the hardest question I have ever been asked in 25 years of forestry and urban forestry. I still have to look that up and see if I can find an answer...


Annalie Nancy wrote: "There are, although the reasoning part of the brain isn't fully developed until the early 20's - so he is quite advanced for a long-term 6-year-old. But they are sure full of surprises... my six-y..."

Oh, what a lovely surprise to stumble across a person who loves trees as much as I do!!! Perhaps the answer is the Wollemi Pine, Wollemia nobilis. (More info at www.wollemipine.com) It seems that all the Wollemi Pine trees have identical genetic material (propagated vegetatively, even in the wild) so you could say there is only one specimen left! It really is a pretty tree and if I had any space left in my garden, I would have planted one. (If you look at our house on Google Earth, it's the spot where all the trees are).


Nancy Well it was the bois dentelle of Mauritius, but then I found this website and that there are 2 of those and only 1 of a species in NZ, but if you look down the list on the RH side you will see your tree. http://www.globaltrees.org/


back to top