Lora's Reviews > Enclave

Enclave by Ann Aguirre

by
4632071
's review
Jul 01, 11

bookshelves: g-dystopia-post-apoc, lib-read
Recommended for: fans of YA dystopian fiction
Read from April 30 to May 02, 2011, read count: 1

Enclave's premise drew my attention more than a lot of the other, more hyped YA dystopias. And I believe that most of it lived up to my expectations.

Enclave starts with Deuce - or rather, at the time, Girl15 - en route to her naming ceremony. In the enclave, your name is merely your gender and an exclusive number. But if you're lucky enough to make it to the age of fifteen, you get a real name.
Six cuts, three on each forearm - these are the marks that make you a Hunter or Huntress. It has been Deuce's ambition to become a Huntress for as long as she can remember, but soon after she is inducted into the ranks of the Hunters, she begins to realize that maybe the ways of the enclave and the elders that have raised and trained her aren't what they seem; that maybe their teachings and rules are as misleading and corrupt as they are false.
And if that isn't disconcerting enough, the Freaks - the terrible monsters that lurk in the tunnels outside of the enclave, the very ones she has been trained to kill - have begun to show signs of intelligence.

Almost immediately after Deuce becomes a Huntress, she is paired up with Fade. Fade is aloof and mysterious, and because of that he is ostracized from the rest of the Hunters, and when Deuce becomes his partner she soon realizes that she will forever be treated in kind simply because of association.
Deuce's character is much more practical and level-headed than most heroines in YA lit. She reminds me of Katsa from Graceling.
It's amazing how much Aguirre doesn't focus on the romance. I don't know if it's because of the genre, or simply because the author isn't trying to cash-in on the current romance fad, but Deuce doesn't spend the majority of the novel fantasizing about Fade's physique and having fifteen-year-old hot flashes over his mere proximity. I found this fact very refreshing.
And there's no love triangle! I was very pleased that there's no love triangle. (view spoiler)[Or at least until the author decided to add one! Why? There are so many love triangles in the YA genre. I think the interlude with Stalker wasn't called for. However, I did like Deuce's reaction to Stalker's impromptu affections. She didn't seem very interested in him - but I do wish that the author would've left that out. (hide spoiler)] Deuce seems to have her head on her shoulders and she has a lot of strength and determination that I think a lot of authors, unfortunately, aren't adding to their heroines.
The romance is still there, but it doesn't overwhelm the rest of the story - it's just enough to add a little spice that a lot of readers (including myself) are looking for. Think of it as a perfectly seasoned pumpkin pie (and if that's not your kind of dessert, feel free to use a different analogy).

FAVORITE QUOTES:
"I have your back. I didn't mean only when it's easy. All the time."

"He pushed away from the wall, skin gleaming pale in the torchlight. For a moment I wanted to put my hand over his heart so I could feel it beating, and the impluse frightened me. I took a step back."

This quote is kind of spoilery - click at your own risk.
(view spoiler)["It doesn't burn," I whispered.
In fact, it felt amazing. I hadn't bathed recently, and this was the next best thing. I started to smile. I turned slowly, admiring the flashes of light. Rain pounded against the ground until it sounded like a chorus of running feet combined with shushing whispers. I'd never heard anything so lovely."
(hide spoiler)]


While Enclave is Aguirre's YA debut, it isn't her first foray into writing. Aguirre has two other adult urban fantasy series - Sirantha Jax and Corine Solomon - and her experience shows.

I must say that I utterly detest zombies. And that is basically what the Freaks are. However, Aguirre doesn't describe them as moaning, relentless, brain eating stragglers - therefore they didn't bother me.
So, if you're like me and hate zombies, don't avoid this for that reason.

One of the best things I can say about Enclave - besides the writing and the characters - is the atmosphere: I didn't find it horribly depressing and/or disturbing. I tend to stray away from dystopias because of their often bleak and disquieting themes, but Enclave was anything but the aforesaid.

Sadly, Enclave - thus far - doesn't appear to be garnering the attention that a lot of other dystopias are. Especially when you compare it to the Goodreads' ratings of Matched (11.000+), Delirium (4.500+), and Wither (1.900+) - compare those to Enclave's 300+ ratings.

And with all of that said, you're probably wondering, why not five stars? Well, Aguirre does a good job of keeping the reader engaged, but there were times when I found myself wondering where exactly the plot (or, perhaps, lack thereof) was headed. Enclave is split into two parts, and the first half is considerably better than the second. And when things finally started to get interesting again in the second half, BAM - it was over.
The ending is probably one of the most annoyingly sudden I've ever read. It's what my GR friend, Tina, would call "evil cliffy".
And I wanted more of an explanation as to why (view spoiler)[almost (hide spoiler)] all of humanity chose to move underground. Not much detail is given about what exactly happened to change the world so drastically. Deuce doesn't really know, and therefore neither does the reader.

All in all, Enclave is a great start to what will hopefully be a great dystopian series. And I'm very much looking forward to its planned sequels, Outpost (currently set to release in September of next year - which I think is a really long time to wait) and Horde (set to release sometime in 2013).

And I'd like to give a shout out to the librarian who checked this out for me, who was so enthusiastic over this novel. I hope she can read it soon. :)

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Enclave.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-29 of 29) (29 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by ~Tina~ (new)

~Tina~ I'm curious about this book! Happy Reading hun!


Lora Thanks, Tina :)


Wendy Darling Bumping it up my TBR list! Nicely done.


Lora Thanks, Wendy :)


message 5: by Flannery (new) - added it

Flannery What are the requirements of the "debut author challenge"? Ann Aguirre writes an adult sci-fi series that is pretty awesome (Grimspace). Does it just have to be their first YA book?


message 6: by Lora (last edited May 05, 2011 03:55pm) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lora @ Flannery - The Debut Author Challenge is hosted over at The Story Siren. Basically, you read 12 YA or MG novels between Jan 1 and Dec 31. Each has to be a debut (meaning that it is the author's first young adult or middle grade novel - if they've already published an adult novel, the YA or MG novel still counts). Unfortunately, if you're looking to sign up, the deadline was Mar 1.

I'll try her adult sci-fi series if it's good. :)


message 7: by Flannery (new) - added it

Flannery Oh no, I was just wondering about what made someone a "debut author":) You should definitely read Grimspace if you are at all interested in sci-fi.


message 8: by ~Tina~ (new)

~Tina~ This sounds great! Awesome review, Lora. I'm gonna try to find it at my lib:)


message 9: by Jessica (new) - added it

Jessica Very impressive review, Lora! :)


message 10: by Lora (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lora Why, thank you, Jess:) I noticed that you have this on your "sitting unread on my shelf" shelf.

*whispers coaxingly* Read it soon . . . ;)


message 11: by Jessica (new) - added it

Jessica Yes, I do :) I'll definitely try to read it soon.


message 12: by Kristy (new) - added it

Kristy Great review lora!! Now I've got to get my hands on this one.... :)


message 13: by Lora (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lora Thanks, Kristy! I'm sure you'll like it^^


Zemira Warner I just finished it myself and it was great.


Lady Eilonwy Enclave...post-apocalyptia...just brings to me to the Fallout games, in a good way. Going on my to-reads list, thank you!


message 16: by KM (new)

KM I'm really sick of dystopians (mostly because of books like MATCHED and DELIRIUM and the like), but this one sounds so good! I like my dystopians action-y and I like that this one doesn't focus too much on the romance, which I feel like takes away from the awesomesauce that original dystopians were. DEFINITELY on my TBR list :)


message 17: by Chichipio (new) - added it

Chichipio Another great review for this book. I really have to get around to read it. It seems that Ann's YA writing is as good as her adult stuff.


message 18: by Alexa (new) - added it

Alexa Awesome review, Lora! I'm even more curious about this book now. Can't wait to read it. :D
(Just really REALLY hope the author doesn't add a love-triangle. heh)


message 19: by Lora (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lora Thanks, Alexa! And on the last sentence . . . *mumbles*


message 20: by Alexa (new) - added it

Alexa Your mumbles make me nervous. D8


message 21: by Lora (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lora Aww, sorry, Alexa:) It really is great, though. I'm sure you'll like it^^


Taylor Great review...I loved this book. You made some excellent points, especially about the "not-too-romance" and the first part being better than the second part. I wish the next books would come sooner, too...


message 23: by Nic (new) - added it

Nic Adding it to my list! Awesome review Lora :)


Arlene I put this on reserve at my lib. I'm at the top of the list. :) Awesome review Lora!


message 25: by Lora (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lora Thanks, ladies. Hope you both like it:)


message 26: by Milly (new) - added it

Milly Thank you for reviewing this Lora! I wasn't sure if it was worth reading and now I know, thanks to your awesome review!


message 27: by Lora (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lora Thanks, Milly:) Hope you like it.


message 28: by Angelee (new)

Angelee R you're review, and the sample, made me give this book a chance. i hope it's really good; better than divergent lol


Neila just picked up outpost and read your review to refresh my memory. Great review thanks a lot!!


back to top