Lauren's Reviews > How I Live Now
How I Live Now
by Meg Rosoff
by Meg Rosoff
Lauren's review
bookshelves: favorites, teen-lit
Feb 03, 11
bookshelves: favorites, teen-lit
Recommended for:
critical readers, mature readers, thoughtful readers
Read in January, 2011
I spent a while considering how I would rate this book, but finally decided on a full 5/5 rating, and here's why:
It troubles me greatly that so many readers can't see past the unconventional relationship between our protagonist and her cousin, because it so wholly isn't what the book is about. That's the only real downfall of "How I live Now"--unfortunately, Meg Rosoff seemed to target her book towards an audience too immature to realize that this novel is a novel about SURVIVAL. It's a novel about how people change when faced with hardship and how people can come together in the oddest of ways. It's about family. It's about love. It's about hate. Meg Rosoff has a unique gift of just giving the reader the bare bones of a story--that is to say, no surnames are given, little background about the characters is revealed in depth, the enemy is referred to solely as just that, "The Enemy"--and still making a profound impact. This is a novel about people and our determination to survive even in the face of hopelessness.
Stylistically, this book is stunning. The prose is insightful and puzzling, but necessary given the circumstances of the novel. Finally, a book which reads as if the narrator is actually recalling events, rather than the artificially produced recollection of events and conversations, verbatim, which we have grown so used to.
I sincerely hope that people reading this book will start focusing on the beauty of the story--the prose, the characters, the structure which is at once remarkably simplistic and stunningly complex--and stop focusing on details which are not entirely pertinent to the story at large.
It troubles me greatly that so many readers can't see past the unconventional relationship between our protagonist and her cousin, because it so wholly isn't what the book is about. That's the only real downfall of "How I live Now"--unfortunately, Meg Rosoff seemed to target her book towards an audience too immature to realize that this novel is a novel about SURVIVAL. It's a novel about how people change when faced with hardship and how people can come together in the oddest of ways. It's about family. It's about love. It's about hate. Meg Rosoff has a unique gift of just giving the reader the bare bones of a story--that is to say, no surnames are given, little background about the characters is revealed in depth, the enemy is referred to solely as just that, "The Enemy"--and still making a profound impact. This is a novel about people and our determination to survive even in the face of hopelessness.
Stylistically, this book is stunning. The prose is insightful and puzzling, but necessary given the circumstances of the novel. Finally, a book which reads as if the narrator is actually recalling events, rather than the artificially produced recollection of events and conversations, verbatim, which we have grown so used to.
I sincerely hope that people reading this book will start focusing on the beauty of the story--the prose, the characters, the structure which is at once remarkably simplistic and stunningly complex--and stop focusing on details which are not entirely pertinent to the story at large.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read How I Live Now.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Sarah
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Apr 09, 2011 04:33pm
THANK YOU. I was so surprised to see the small minded reviews on here! I agree that the cousin relationship was not at all the focus of the story and I applaud any author's attempt to write about taboo subject matter. Literature should not be censored, if you don't like it, don't read it.
reply
|
flag
*
Loved the review.Thnx.Most people just don't seem to get past the unconventional relationship between Daisy and her cousin Edmund.They just fail to see that their relationship is just a part of the book which makes her seperation from her cousins all the more heartbreaking. A few parts of the book actually made my eyes tear.Thnx again for this review .It just said everything I felt about the book.
I love love love this book and I love your review--I was shocked by how low the rating was on goodreads! I think you summed up the intent of the novel perfectly :)
I have to say... I didn't even particularly notice the relationship between the cousins, I knew it was supposed to have been there, but I couldn't really see it. All I read about was these kids running away and trying to survive. Yes, clearly the book is about survival. I still found the book rather disturbing (not for sexual content as I didn't find any) and rather boring. Which is why I gave the book only 1 star.
