Lisa Vegan's Reviews > All Clear

All Clear by Connie Willis

by
83445
's review
Jan 04, 11

bookshelves: fiction, historical-fiction, novel, speculative-fiction, time-travel, reviewed, orphaned-and-quasi-orphaned-kids, altta
Recommended for: all readers who enjoy historical fiction &/or time travel books &/or any speculative fiction
Read from December 16, 2010 to January 03, 2011 — I own a copy

This is a wonderful and amazing book. It really is the second half of a book. On the same day, I went from finishing Blackout and started reading this book, and it was like going from one chapter to another, not like going from one book to another.

Thank you to Goodreads friend and fellow group member Sarah Pi who didn’t let me see answers to my questions and therefore helped me avoid unwanted spoilers.

I am very proud that less than 1/3 the way through this book, I figured something out, probably because of all of the mysteries I’ve read, and I’m often able to prematurely guess their outcomes too. Even though I figured out that important plot point, the book managed to stay suspenseful for me all the way until the last page. The farther I got into the book, the harder it became to take any breaks from reading it; I was enthralled.

I love Blackout and this book so much didn’t even mind that they’re books 4 and 5 in the Oxford time travel series; normally, I’d want to read the books in exact order, but once I started these books I couldn’t put them aside to read the earlier books first.

This is a brilliant historical fiction and time travel/speculative fiction book, with a very complex time travel story. It’s ingenious and a great deal of fun. It’s funny, tragic, romantic, heartwarming, and completely engrossing. I cared a great deal about many characters. I got in lots of chuckles and smiles, and tears also.

I adored how Agatha Christie makes appearances. (I’ve loved her mystery books for decades.) Very cool! Also appropriate were all the mentions of Ernest Shackleton and his expedition to the South Pole.

This is a beautifully crafted book. I enjoyed how the dialogue between characters was in quotes and characters’ internal dialogue/thoughts were in italics. The quotes that are at the beginning of each chapter are fabulous; both their literary and historical origins and how they relate to what is going on in the book’s story are perfect.

I knew a fair amount about the Blitz, have read about it and listened to people who were there talk about it, I think that I learned more from this book/books than any other source to date. I think I fully appreciated for the first time what people in that time and place experienced.

I can recommend this book to any reader who likes reading historical fiction and/or time travel books and/or any type of speculative fiction. It’s imperative to read Blackout and then this book, preferably one right after the other as I was fortunate to do.

The very best thing about this book, and why I think it has appeal for all readers whatever their favorite genres are, is how it shows the importance in life of loving and caring about and caring for others. I was practically bawling by the end, but this theme runs throughout the entire story.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read All Clear.
sign in »

Reading Progress

12/16/2010 page 1
0.0% "I still have to finish Blackout; currently I'm on page 453, but this is in my hands and I can probably start it before bed. I should have the other finished by late this afternoon. Yay!"
12/17/2010 page 9
1.0% "Blackout and All Clear are really one book. Going from the last chapter of Blackout to this book's first chapter was exactly like going from one chapter to another in a book. I'm glad I had this book ready to read when I finished Blackout, and this is the perfect comfort read for me at this time of year."
12/18/2010 page 17
3.0% "I will be reading more than one short chapter a day. ;-) I hope."
12/20/2010 page 71
11.0% "I'm enjoying this. I wish I could curl up with it and read for long periods, and I am glad I'll have quite a bit of time to read over the next couple of weeks."
12/22/2010 page 100
16.0% "I'm having a fabulous time reading this! I can tell that when I've finished it, at some point I will want to go back and reread Blackout & All Clear again. it would be fun to know what what was going on the entire time."
12/24/2010 page 164
26.0% "I'm crawling through this at a snail's pace because I'm having trouble concentrating and I don't have enough time to read. AND, this is the type of book I want to fully immerse myself in and barely come up for anything else. So frustrating. Such a great book!"
12/25/2010 page 214
33.0% "So much for having more time/a good environment to read over the holidays. I am enjoying this book very much though!"
12/26/2010 page 243
38.0% "Oh! I'm speculating, but I have one idea about what may be going on. Very cool if it's true, and either way, this is a fabulous book." 5 comments
12/30/2010 page 322
50.0% "Finally! Some time to read, but not enough. Guess this novel will be my over the New Year's book because by tomorrow I'm also trying to finish a bunch of picture books, a cookbook, and maybe my Harry Potter movie book. So many books, so little time."
01/01/2011 page 377
59.0% "Fabulous book! I guess it's my going over the New Year novel, though I was hoping to be finished with it by now. I have so many books I've scheduled myself to read this month/in January."
01/01/2011 page 419
65.0% "I'm constantly surprised, and it's getting harder & harder to put down this book. It's so addictive!"
01/02/2011 page 471
73.0% "Ingenious and a great deal of fun." 3 comments

Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ann (new)

Ann Fantastic review, Lisa! I was enthralled reading the review, let along the book!! :) It sounds amazing!

I love Agatha Christie books, too, so I'll have to give this (or, Blackout) a try! Off to Mt. TBR! :)


Lisa Vegan Ann, thanks. Sorry to corrupt your to-read shelf, but this two book series is really worth reading, and I suspect this author's earlier books are as well. I want to read her book Doomsday Book soon.


Tina M. I saw nothing amazing about it. It needed much editing and I got so tired of the repetition. How many times did the flat characters narrowly miss Mr. Bartholomew? I lost count. The book should have been 200 pages long, not 600. Also, if writers write two books, they should be just that. Two books. You should be able to pick up the second and understand what was going on from the first page. The author gave no indication that that was not the case here on the jacket or otherwise.


Lisa Vegan Tina, Well I was so into it I didn't care and didn't want it to end, but I actually agree with you about the editing and about the 2 book concept. And, I prefer books that are standalone. I'm getting tired of trilogies, and even legitimate sequels. There are many books I've loved, especially some I read in childhood, where it took me years (or never) to read additional books in books that turned into series. I'm thinking of books that when I read them were standalone at the time (Time At The Top, A Wrinkle in Time, Meet the Austins (with their original covers!)) and books I knew had sequels of sorts (too many to list).


back to top