Jason Pettus's Reviews > The Almost Moon
The Almost Moon
by Alice Sebold
by Alice Sebold
Jason Pettus's review
bookshelves: contemporary, character-heavy, dark, personal-favorite
Jan 24, 08
bookshelves: contemporary, character-heavy, dark, personal-favorite
Read in January, 2008
(My full review of this book is much longer than GoodReads' word-count limitations. Find the entire essay at the Chicago Center for Literature and Photography [cclapcenter.com].)
I freely admit it; that as a man, there are sometimes things that women do that utterly baffle me, and will probably continue to baffle me until the day I freaking die, just like it is with women regarding men. And that's because, avoiding any kind of qualitative judgment, I think we can all agree that there are fundamentally different ways that men and women sometimes react in different situations, based on a variety of criteria and societal concerns, and that in some cases such actions and behaviors can seem incomprehensible to the other gender. You don't hear of too many men, for example, who just lose their marbles one day, drive their kids to a nearby lake and calmly drown them; not too many male jilted lovers go on insane cross-country drives in the middle of the night, with bizarre weapons in tow and while wearing adult diapers so that they don't have to make bathroom breaks, all in the name of some crazed crackpot scheme thought up in the middle of the night regarding stabbing their lover's new lover then turning the knife on themselves.
It is one of these very topics, in fact, that fuels the entire storyline of acclaimed author Alice Sebold's latest brilliantly twisted dark little novel, The Almost Moon; in fact, that's what the very first chapter of the book is devoted to, is a real-time blow-by-blow accounting of a middle-aged woman suddenly going insane one day and murdering her senile, sh-t-covered old-age mother, just randomly one afternoon while over at her house and preparing to clean her like a baby for the thousandth time in a row now. What the rest of this delightfully wicked story is about, then, is a fascinating and detailed look at the decades leading up to this moment, told in a non-narrative "hyperfiction" style that jumps from early-childhood to just yesterday at the blink of an eye, painting one of the deepest portraits you'll see in contemporary literature of a dysfunctional mother-daughter relationship, and of all the teeny, tiny, strange, entertaining, depressing, hopeless, fascinating ways the relationship affects the way the woman deals with each and every other person in her life too. It is utterly a female story, the kind that can only be told by a female author, but told in a way so that I as a male reader can get it too; I love such novels, as I've mentioned here before, and am always glad to come upon another one like I have this week.
So why does Sebold's name sound so familiar, you're thinking? Well, because she's the mousy dark novelist who seemingly appeared out of nowhere in the early 2000s to write The Lovely Bones, an emotionally devastating crime thriller and meditation on loss that happened to have been written from the standpoint of a murdered teenage girl as she watches the proceedings from heaven. I read it too when it first came out, and like many others it made me openly weep in public; it became not only a runaway bestseller, but is also slated to be the next movie by Lord of the Rings impresario Peter Jackson. Oh yeah, that Alice Sebold!
This is only her second novel, after taking a break between them to pen the true rape memoir Lucky; and it is the best kind of second novel to write, to tell you the truth, one that...
I freely admit it; that as a man, there are sometimes things that women do that utterly baffle me, and will probably continue to baffle me until the day I freaking die, just like it is with women regarding men. And that's because, avoiding any kind of qualitative judgment, I think we can all agree that there are fundamentally different ways that men and women sometimes react in different situations, based on a variety of criteria and societal concerns, and that in some cases such actions and behaviors can seem incomprehensible to the other gender. You don't hear of too many men, for example, who just lose their marbles one day, drive their kids to a nearby lake and calmly drown them; not too many male jilted lovers go on insane cross-country drives in the middle of the night, with bizarre weapons in tow and while wearing adult diapers so that they don't have to make bathroom breaks, all in the name of some crazed crackpot scheme thought up in the middle of the night regarding stabbing their lover's new lover then turning the knife on themselves.
It is one of these very topics, in fact, that fuels the entire storyline of acclaimed author Alice Sebold's latest brilliantly twisted dark little novel, The Almost Moon; in fact, that's what the very first chapter of the book is devoted to, is a real-time blow-by-blow accounting of a middle-aged woman suddenly going insane one day and murdering her senile, sh-t-covered old-age mother, just randomly one afternoon while over at her house and preparing to clean her like a baby for the thousandth time in a row now. What the rest of this delightfully wicked story is about, then, is a fascinating and detailed look at the decades leading up to this moment, told in a non-narrative "hyperfiction" style that jumps from early-childhood to just yesterday at the blink of an eye, painting one of the deepest portraits you'll see in contemporary literature of a dysfunctional mother-daughter relationship, and of all the teeny, tiny, strange, entertaining, depressing, hopeless, fascinating ways the relationship affects the way the woman deals with each and every other person in her life too. It is utterly a female story, the kind that can only be told by a female author, but told in a way so that I as a male reader can get it too; I love such novels, as I've mentioned here before, and am always glad to come upon another one like I have this week.
So why does Sebold's name sound so familiar, you're thinking? Well, because she's the mousy dark novelist who seemingly appeared out of nowhere in the early 2000s to write The Lovely Bones, an emotionally devastating crime thriller and meditation on loss that happened to have been written from the standpoint of a murdered teenage girl as she watches the proceedings from heaven. I read it too when it first came out, and like many others it made me openly weep in public; it became not only a runaway bestseller, but is also slated to be the next movie by Lord of the Rings impresario Peter Jackson. Oh yeah, that Alice Sebold!
This is only her second novel, after taking a break between them to pen the true rape memoir Lucky; and it is the best kind of second novel to write, to tell you the truth, one that...
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Almost Moon.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-18 of 18) (18 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Simba
(new)
Aug 09, 2008 09:17am
I thought male jilted lovers were more likely to kill their former partners than female
reply
|
flag
*
Male jilted lovers are more likely to kill their former partners than females. They just generally prefer a quick shotgun blast to an elaborate scheme, because they're simple-minded like that. :)
Oh, yeah. I hated this review about like most of you hated the book I don't plan to read. Yeah, men have never done anything crazy for love. How about attempting to assassinate the president to impress an actress you don't know? Hello! John Hinkley and Jodie Foster? Dude? There are plenty of male whack jobs. WTheck are you talking about? Equating this character's sociopathic indifference and lack of moral compass to the everyday idiosyncrasies of women in general is ludicrous.
How many men have wiped out their whole families when the wives have filed for divorce. Or the idiot who burned his son in a hotel room to get even with his wife who was divorcing him. Yea, you're right, men don't do anything whacked out like women do. Jeez!
I am seeing some mysogynistic tendencies here from this reviewer. This is not the first one that I have seen from him. Perhaps a good therapist or an anger management seminar/course would be the thing? :)
Here below are the further thoughts I've since had about this book since originally reviewing it, which I first wrote up in December '08 for my arts center's annual "Year In Review" of my favorite books; I apologize for going so long without posting them here, and of course I very much apologize for coming off as misogynistic, as so many have accused me of here. I didn't mean to imply at all that men aren't capable of doing crazy things; as these further thoughts below will hopefully show, what I really meant to emphasize was how great a dark, dark comedy about unstable middle-agers this book is, and how it is in many ways a wicked satire of the kinds of real-life tabloid-worthy jilted lovers who get caught in the middle of cross-country sprees while wearing adult diapers, so that they don't have to stop for bathroom breaks as they chase down the lover of their husband (or wife of their lover) who's a couple of thousand miles away. CERTAINLY men do just as crazy of things as this on a regular basis too, and I never meant to imply that they don't. I very sincerely apologize for the misunderstanding.My end-of-year thoughts:
"I was shocked to see this wickedly naughty black tragicomedy by the much-loved Alice Sebold get routinely dismissed by her existing fans; but then when I thought about it, I realized that maybe that's because it's simply so different than her surprise runaway bestselling debut a few years ago, the weepy tearjerker 'The Lovely Bones' (which I also loved, don't get me wrong). See, that one is a delicate, poetic drama about a dead girl watching her own murder investigation from heaven, so I guess many of her fans were disappointed by her not turning in yet another tome along the same lines; but I thought it was brilliant of her to turn in a witty, trashy, very dark and surprisingly funny family melodrama instead, which like the camp classic Whatever 'Happened to Baby Jane?' takes a hard-edged look at a bizarre familial relationship, an inner-brain portrait of one of those frazzled middle-aged women who suddenly go nuts one day and smother to death their crap-covered mean-as-hell dementia-plagued elderly mother, then try to stuff the cadaver in the basement freezer. Smart yet traumatic, it made me spend much of my reading time looking through splayed fingers, laughing and cringing and saying, 'Oh no, Sebold, you're not taking us there, are you? Oh yeah, I guess you are!'"
Yeah. It's a pity how you try to wipe the slate clean in this added bonus of a post. I'm not buying it.I don't know you but you still seem as misogynistic as you were in the last post. Want to talk about crazy, jilted lovers? You ought to meet some of the guys I know. They'd change your whole perspective.
For all those fans of The lovely Bones I just thought that I would add that a trailer has been posted for the movie.
I've not read this book...yet. But I think I'll check it out. I'm intrigued by all of the negative reviews listed here. And I'm disappointed that the one review not bashing the book but rather giving an alternate perspective is, in turn, being bashed. Wow. Isn't that why we are all here sharing our thoughts and reviews...to gain alternate insights and pose varying ideas, interpretations, etc? Give that dude, Jason, a break! Too sensitive... Toughin' up, Ladies.
I took the time to go and read you full review at CCLaP, and enjoyed it. It will be harder to write my own now, since you said what I would have much better. I'll reference yours in my review. :-)
You do hear of countless men killing their significant others, or ex lovers who are trying to leave them. You do hear of countless men who beat, rape, neglect and generally abuse their children. Many of the examples you have highlighted have got the media attention that they have because women are supposed to be excellent mothers, all of the time, so when one goes off the rails, it's not only heinous, it's socially sacrilegious against the cult that is Motherhood. Please don't further gender stereotypes that women are beyond fathoming/crazy/impossible to relate to on a fundamental level, and that men do not do these same things.
I will add that although I didn't find this book to be very strong in structure or even use of language/craft of writing, it was interesting to read a character's unapologetic point of view. There is an emphasis in literature right now to write likable characters, or at the very least, make moral judgments on ones that don't fit in with our world views so that we can comfortably condemn them. Writing isn't always about escapism, or approving of what a character does or how they feel. There are ugly-souled people out there, and ignoring this and/or insisting that we are given the opportunity to take a superior stance to them during our reading experience is limiting.
Finally someone else that enjoyed the brilliant work in this book. Yes it is very much a female story that only a female write could create but it isn't the horrible mess that everyone is making it out to be. This is seriously told through the mind of someone who snapped because her mother had warped her mind over 49 years. She loved her mother and that was obvious (having hidden her mothers slips away in her home and then wearing the rose petal pink one the day after the murder) but it has been said many times before that the hardest thing in the world is to love someone and them not love you back. That is exactly what she is going through. To have a mother that clearly doesn't love you. That itself is too hard to take and enough to make someone snap.
Wow. I am not ignorant of the flaws my sex seems to share but to say that calmly drowning all of your children is "a woman's thing" is ludicrous. You come across as a misogynist because you are the misogynist. You seem to have as much understanding of women as you do this novel.
Hey, I went to your website to read the rest of your review, but wasn't able to find it. Did you remove it because of what the readers are saying about you review here? Could you put a direct link to your website review before I go crazy looking for it? I like to read what else you have to say. Thanks, Cindy
I am a man, there was a***ole this morning at the entrance of Homedepot with the trunk of his car open and his stupid music blasting outside-inside.He was nowhere to be seen probably getting some materials. I've never seen a woman doing such a blatant show of her stupidity, have you? Most jilted men do not wear space suits to get lover back, they are in jail because they did not have a plan or dead, because after doing the deed, we cannot think of knowing what to do other than pointing the gun at ourselves.
(Insert laugh). Thanks for liking this book along with me, Jason! I was astonished by the reviews and the backlash Sebold received because of this book (though I can understand).I think your comment brings to light a lot of interesting food for thought. I don't justify the actions of women (killing their children, etc.), but perhaps this happens more often because it is reported more and because, most importantly, the burden of care-giving and all things nurturing rests, societally, on a woman's shoulders. We all know that men are just as important when it comes to the raising of children, etc. but carrying a life and birthing a life forces women to take a precedence in carrying the weight of raising children. We still live in biased times.

