LJ's Reviews > Palace of Justice

Palace of Justice by Susanne Alleyn
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Dec 08, 2010

really liked it
bookshelves: 1700s, female_author, france, georgian_1714-1811_1820-37, licensed_investigator, mystery, historical, police_procedural
Read in November, 2010

First Sentence: “God help me,” Désirée said to herself, as she tried to ignore the dull, persistent ache of her empty stomach, “I cannot even earn a living as a whore.”

While the guillotine is hard at work in Paris, someone is performing their own executions. Seemingly random victims of beheadings are being found in Paris. Aristide Revel, an investigator for the police, is concerned about the fate of his arrested friends, including one from childhood. In the meantime, he must find a killer.

Having read, and loved, all the other books so far in this series, I was concerned about whether this book, second chronologically yet fourth published, would seem out of place and, somehow, less significant since those of us who have read the other books know the outcome of some of the events taking place here. I need not have worried.

I appreciated the information included in the Preface and the glossary of Terms. Alleyn includes relevant historical information on both the geography of Paris and the Revolution. However, at its core, the book is an excellent police procedural. The story begins, sans prologue thank you, in a way that both touches your emotions yet shocks your senses.

The characters are interesting and fully dimensional. Aristide is fully developed, not only by description, but by habits and ethics. He is a complex character, dedicated to justice in a time of great injustice, judicial murder and the debasement of the law. I like the relationship between Aristide and Brasseur, his boss. How refreshing that it is supportive rather than the clichéd adversarial. The inclusion of Sanson, the master executioner and a real person from history adds veracity. Alleyn skillfully takes someone with an appalling job and humanizes them to the point where you feel respect, or at least sympathy and admiration, for his bringing as much compassion and professionalism to his position as possible.

The plot is very well done. On a high level, one could draw a parallel between the period of the book and today with the chasm between the wealthy and those who are not; the disassociation of the powerful minority from the working class and poor majority. On a story level, Alleyn is excellent at creating tension points throughout the story. It does not quite earn a rating of excellent as I did perceive the villain and there was one large, convenient coincidence. However, these minor flaws were offset by a very dramatic, emotions scene so painful, I wept.

Susanne Alleyn is a remarkable writer. This book surpassed my expectations and I loved it. It wasn’t always an emotionally easy book, but it was an exceptional book and one I recommend. May there be many more books to come.

PALACE OF JUSTICE (Pol Proc-Aristide Revel-Paris-1793) – VG+
Alleyn, Susanne (4th published in series – 2nd chronologically)
Minotaur Books, ©2010, ARC – Hardcover ISBN: 9780312379896

1 like · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Palace of Justice.
Sign In »

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Shomeret I'm surprised that you didn't run away screaming, LJ. This is definitely a French Revolution book. That's why I chose to read it. I expect to like it better than the before and after the revolution books in this series.

message 2: by LJ (new) - rated it 4 stars

LJ Believe me, I was very leary when Susanne sent me the first three books. However, they do work for me as One they are mysteries set in the time around the Revolution but don't focus specifically on the Revolution. And she's an excellent writer.

back to top