Rachel Haimowitz's Reviews > Bloodlines

Bloodlines by Andrea Speed
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Nov 30, 2010

really liked it
bookshelves: contemporary, m-m, own, shifters, dark, mystery
Read from December 22 to 25, 2010

** spoiler alert ** I must start off first and foremost by saying that this was a brilliant world with supremely well-crafted characters, the best closing line I think I've read in years (I mean seriously, that could NOT have been more perfect), and enough emotional punch to leave me in tears. I was literally crying hard enough to make reading the last few pages a challenge.

I also want to applaud Andrea Speed for having the courage to end the book the way she did. When you create such lovable characters, treating them like she did can get you lynched by your readers. But this ending was truest to the story and served it best. I think a lesser author might have whipped up a miracle to avoid the hard choices.

For me, this would have been 5-star read if not for craft issues, which were fairly significant in some places. As with Infected: Prey, Infected: Bloodlines has some serious flab. Literally not one meaningful thing happens in the first 16% of the book; it was all backstory and setup, clumsily done and not interesting at all. Had I not already been so invested in the characters, that beginning would likely have led me to put the book down and not pick it back up. And of course there were also the paragraph-long physical descriptions of every character to wander onto the page, no matter how minor, that tighter editorial control would have caught and cut. There were also some strange POV shifts, where she'd head-hop into a minor character for one or two paragraphs in the middle of the scene, and then hop back out again; and some fairly stark factual inaccuracies that I felt there were no excuse for in a book about cat shifters (cougars can't roar, and boy how did that throw me out of the story when one of hers did, but I'll concede that probably not too many people know that). It's hard to reconcile all these craft issues in the beginning and middle with the ending, which was sleek and elegant and beautiful; I'm not sure how they came from the same author.

Despite these things, this was a brilliant, affective read. I recommend this series quite highly, and I look forward to seeing Andrea's next work. (I'd especially like to see her publish at a house with a deeper editorial touch; hands-off editorial can be a joyous thing for those eagle-eyed writers who can really cut their own works to the bone, but most of us can't, and need the editorial assist. I think if she had that oversight, her work would be masterful.) I hope she revisits Roan, because after leaving him bleeding and broken at the end of Bloodlines, I'm desperate to see him find some semblance of happiness again.

And now I need to go watch kittens playing, or something, because this book basically punched me in the solar plexus and then killed my dog. Which is an amazing thing, to be moved like that. But it also kinda sucks :-p

Thanks, Andrea, for such a powerful, captivating read. This one will stick with me for a good long while.
2 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Bloodlines.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

16.0% "Eeeeeeh. Same lack of focus in the prose as with Infected: Prey. I'm 16% in and nothing's even happened yet; it's still all setup and back-story."
38.0% "Really picked up, thank goodness. Eager to know what the deal is with the sick kitties, aw."
55.0% "Sooooooo much better now. Also depressing, but hey, we all knew what we were signing up for."

Comments (showing 1-5 of 5) (5 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Bubbles  Hunty Honest & Direct Opinions The next book is called Infected: Life after Death (or something like that) and is out in March if I remember correctly

I still haven't been brave enough to read this one, I bought it but haven't even down loaded it

Rachel Haimowitz Read it. The ending's no surprise, so you can sort of brace yourself for it ahead of time. Sort of. But seriously, it was GOOD.

Bubbles  Hunty Honest & Direct Opinions I know i just need to find a day to read it where i don't mind sitting at home crying.

Rachel Haimowitz LOL, indeed :`(

Bubbles  Hunty Honest & Direct Opinions i am thinking next month will be a good time to do it

back to top